# From Illustrator to Indie Game Developer: My Complicated Relationship with AI — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:gamedev.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/066a26baf7745191

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:gamedev)  published 2026-10-29 11:00 ingested 2026-10-30 02:37

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xigud5/from_illustrator_to_indie_game_developer_my/)

## retained text



```
I'm an indie game developer currently working on my game entirely on my own. With all the discussions about AI following this recent Steam Next Fest, I'd like to share some of my personal experiences and thoughts.

Before I decided to make a game, I worked as an illustrator. The emergence of AI had a significant impact on my career. More and more clients began choosing AI-generated illustrations instead of commissioning artists, and as a result, my livelihood became increasingly uncertain.

Feeling lost and unsure of what to do next, I started exploring game development. To me, games are a medium that can carry my own ideas and artistic vision. They allow me to tell stories and express things that feel genuinely personal to me.

So I began learning everything from scratch: game engines, programming, writing, and music production.

As someone who had never worked with code before, programming was by far the most challenging part for me. It was very different from the kind of work I was used to. Programming requires logic, structure, and precision, whereas drawing gives me much more room for intuitive and emotional expression.

Along the way, I eventually decided to use a technology that had once profoundly disrupted my original profession: AI.

That might sound contradictory, but AI has genuinely helped me understand code, troubleshoot development problems, and attempt to implement features that would otherwise have been extremely difficult for me to build on my own.

It's been almost two years since I first started outlining the story for my game. During that time, I've taken on nearly every aspect of development myself: creating the artwork, writing the story, building scenes, implementing the game in the engine, and even learning music composition so I could create some of the soundtrack.

Without AI helping me with some of the technical work I'm least comfortable with, I think bringing this project to life would have taken considerably longer. I would also have faced many more obstacles that might have been difficult to overcome on my own.

But that doesn't mean I've handed the rest of the work over to a tool, or that I've lowered my standards for the game.

Art is where my experience lies, and I still create the game's visual assets in a very time-consuming way, drawing them stroke by stroke. I also revisit and refine the music and writing repeatedly, trying to get them as close as possible to what I envision. From the placement of a single object, to the timbre of a musical passage, to the way a character phrases a line of dialogue, these are all details I've thought carefully about.

Some people might ask: why not work with other people instead?

Building a good working relationship isn't always easy. Beyond budget constraints, collaboration involves communication, mutual understanding, a shared creative direction, and sometimes differences in artistic taste. Given my circumstances, working alone is simply the approach that makes the most sense for me right now. It allows me to realize my original vision more fully while keeping costs within what I can afford. After all, I've already lost the work opportunities I once relied on, so budget is a very real limitation for me.

After nearly two years of development, I finally put my game on Steam. When submitting the store information, I was transparent about my use of AI.

I know that the use of AI remains a highly contentious subject. I also understand why players have concerns about training data, artists' rights, the impact on employment, and the different ways AI can be used. These issues don't disappear simply because I use AI myself.

Still, I hope we can recognize that not all uses of AI are the same.

Using AI to mass-produce assets or imitate and copy other people's work without permission is not the same as using it to help understand code, troubleshoot programming problems, or translate portions of a game's text. The specific ways these tools are used, the rights and ethical issues involved, and the quality of the finished work all deserve to be considered separately.

I'm not suggesting that putting a lot of effort into a project makes every concern about AI use irrelevant. Time and effort alone cannot resolve disputes over artists' rights.

But by the same token, I don't think a game should automatically be dismissed as low-effort or poorly made simply because its developer has disclosed some use of AI. Nor should it lose the opportunity to be seen and experienced before people have even had a chance to see what it actually is.

I lost work opportunities because of the rise of AI, and now I'm using AI to help me overcome some of the technical barriers involved in making my own game. I know that contradiction isn't easy to explain, but it's the reality of my experience.

For creators like me, who have limited budgets and work alone, AI can sometimes be a tool that helps us bring our own projects to life, rather than something that determines what those projects should be. The artwork, story, scene design, music, and overall experience of my game still require me to think, make decisions, create, and refine things myself.

Since choosing to disclose my AI use, I've also become more aware of the practical limitations that disclosure can bring. For example, I recently reached out to an adventure game community because I wanted to share my work there, only to be turned away because the community explicitly prohibits promoting games that have used AI.

I respect the community's right to establish its own rules, and I understand that its members may want to maintain a particular kind of environment. Still, the experience left me wondering: do developers who openly disclose limited uses of AI, while putting genuine effort into their work, still have a chance to let more people discover their games?

I realize that some uses of AI can be difficult to identify from the finished product alone, while disclosing its use can lead to real restrictions on where a game can be promoted. I'm not saying that disclosure is pointless, nor am I asking every player to accept AI. I simply hope that, once a developer has been transparent about how these tools were used, there can still be room for discussion about the actual work, the specific uses of AI, and the issues involved.

I can also understand why the sheer number of low-quality games during this Steam Next Fest left some players feeling exhausted. With more and more games competing for attention, finding genuinely excellent ones takes time and effort.

But even before AI existed, not every game was good. Truly outstanding games have always been a minority. AI has lowered the barriers to entry in certain areas of development, giving more people the opportunity to try making games, while also making the competition more intense. The number of developers may grow, but so may the number of people looking to capitalize on the trend without much regard for the craft. Those two groups aren't necessarily the same.

If anything, I have even greater respect for developers who continue to take game development seriously in this environment, stay true to their creative vision, and put in the work to polish their games.

I'm not writing this to defend AI unconditionally, nor am I trying to dismiss the choice of any player who doesn't want to play games that use it.

I simply hope that when we discuss AI, we can talk not only about the technology itself, artists' rights, and its impact on the industry, but also about the specific ways it is being used and the different creative journeys behind individual games.

I hope every developer who takes their work seriously gets a fair chance to have their game seen, and I hope players can ultimately find games that genuinely move them.

These are simply some honest thoughts from me: a former illustrator who is now making a game on my own.
```



document fetched 2026-10-30 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xigud5/from_illustrator_to_indie_game_developer_my
