# Replacing/upgrading domain controllers advice — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:sysadmin.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/0745cbf7c408cf7b

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:sysadmin)  published 2026-11-13 13:56 ingested 2026-11-14 02:40

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/1xv8j5z/replacingupgrading_domain_controllers_advice/)

## retained text



```
We have some 2016 DCs which we are upgrading to 2022 next week, been doing a ton or reading and testing in my lab and i just wanted to check with people who have done this in the wild that i have covered everything i need to before going deep into production. Id be really grateful for any advice, we are not doing in place upgrades either.

We have 5 DCs in total 4 virtual and one physical across two sites. 

London has UK-LON-DC01 (vm), UK-LON-DC02 (vm), UK-LON-DC03 (physical)

Manchester has UK-MAN-DC01 (vm) and UK-MAN-DC02 (vm)

My plan is to:

1. Spin up a new 2022 VM UK-LON-DC1 fully patch it then join it to the domain and then promote to a DC. 

2. Set the new UK-LON-DC1 dns to UK-LON-DC02 and itself then leave 48 hours for it to settle and replicate. 

3. Remove any FMSO roles off the old UK-LON-DC01 if it has any then demote and shut it down. 

4. Use the IP of the old UK-LON-DC01 and apply it to the new UK-LON-DC1 and reboot.

5. Remove any dns entries that point the new UK-LON-DC1 to its temp IP from before.

6. Transfer some roles to UK-LON-DC1 for testing.

7. Check new UK-LON-DC1 shows under the London site and add it to Global Secure Access under our DC enterprise app for cloud kerberos trust to carry on working.

  
Then I plan to repeat for the other DCs, always using an available DC for its primary dns and itself for secondary (something else if there is a better practice) DHCP is done on the firewall so no worries with that on any of the DCs. Check for any other services running on them before demoting and removing.

One i have to be careful of is UK-LON-DC02 which is set in group policy as the timer server so i need to make sure this is passed onto another DC before demoting it. I also need to move Entra connect off of UK-LON-DC02 as well and onto a non DC server.

Hopefully i have not missed anything to obvious but would be really grateful for any advice or gotchas to be wary of from guys that have done this before.

Thank you everyone
```



document fetched 2026-11-14 00:40 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/1xv8j5z/replacingupgrading_domain_controllers_advice
