# Visibility Is Getting Harder: Next Fest 2026 Data and Analysis for Developers — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:gamedev.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/0fedc36d37b2f370

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:gamedev)  published 2026-10-31 08:18 ingested 2026-11-01 02:37

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xk4o98/visibility_is_getting_harder_next_fest_2026_data/)

## extract

Hello everyone,

Before we start, I'll summarize who I am as briefly as possible: Almost 15 years in the gaming industry, 2 years as a jr product manager, 10 years in gaming marketing/biz dev, and for the last 3 years, back to the roots and running a small (6-person) studio. Released 2 commercially successful games, working on 2 others.

Why am I writing this summary? Because I believe in data: it helps validate gut feelings, both while working on game ideas and when handling marketing.

So grab a drink, it's gonna be a long WoT...

**Steam Next Fest 2026**

Compared to the previous festival, participation increased by about 66%, and we experienced an event that is starting to turn into more of a Horror Fest than a Next Fest, especially for indie developers.

Now, based on data-driven insights, I’ll try to explain what happened at the festival and what might happen in future events from my own perspective:

**1/4**

**The difficulty level in the visibility war is increasing**

The most talked-about topic of the October 2026 Next Fest was the number of AI games and how increasingly difficult it was to find other games in this crowd.

So what do the participation numbers say? I tried to summarize this quite broad topic under 4 headings:

There were 7,300+ games in this festival. Compared to the 4,400 games in June, that’s an increase of roughly 66%.  Compared to last year’s October (around 3,000 games), it’s 143%.

At its core, in an event people participate in for visibility/wishlists, we had a first 48 hours that felt like “good luck finding what you’re looking for.” Chaos had already erupted on social media before the algorithm pulled itself together on Wednesday.

We already know that more games are released on Steam every year.   
**But there’s a problem:** Next Fest participation is growing even faster than that.

Between 2023 and 2026, annual game releases on Steam increased by about 62%, while total Next Fest participation increased by 458%.

So it’s hard to explain the rising competition just by saying “more games are being made now.” More projects are heading to the festival and competing for the same visibility. The event that Valve encouraged developers to join in the early days has now reached a point where developers are saying things like “maybe not everyone should join…” because of the crowd of games people call “AI SLOP.”

At this point, suggestions like “releasing a game on Steam should cost $500 or $1000” aren’t logically sound proposals.  

Because the “vibecoder game developer” wave that is already okay with spending hundreds/thousands of dollars on AI tool credits to produce games can’t really be stopped this way, and it would only serve to put another barrier in front of the amateur crowd whose intention is simply to make an enjoyable game.

Of course, just because there was a big jump this year doesn’t mean we should expect 66% or 50% growth every festival. Even so, I tried to estimate it with 13.4% compound annual growth, which puts the October 2028 Next Fest at around 15,500 games.

There’s another possibility that could prevent Next Fest participation from continuing to increase so sharply. Similar to the “searching for a needle in a haystack” situation, the risk is growing that copies of an idea’s games will be cloned so quickly that they overtake the original game in popularity, maybe even becoming more popular than the original.

The fact that copies of “simple but fun” ideas or text-based/incremental etc. games that can be produced quickly with AI are becoming increasingly easy to make has already started making developers more hesitant about sharing demos. I think the real issue isn’t how much a single festival has grown, but how full a developer’s hands are (the number of wishlists collected beforehand) against the crowd they’re facing.  

**Because Next Fest is no longer a strong “wishlist multiplication tool.”** It’s more of an event for amplifying an already high wishlist count or well-timed virality (see Unharvest) and collecting feedback.  

In the rest of the post, I’ll explain with some painful numbers why Next Fest is no longer the wishlist-boosting stage it used to be.

**2/4**

**Which genres are standing out in this crowd?**  

I created a compilation by looking at three tags each from the 150 games I examined. (Because as you increase the number of tags, the data can get a bit diluted.)  

I ignored tags like Online Co-Op, Multiplayer, Co-op, Indie, Free to Play, Open World, PvE, and PvP because they don’t fully define the genre.

Looking only at a single tag/genre, Simulation is in first place with 32 games.  

It’s followed by Action with 23, Strategy with 22, Casual with 16, RPG with 15, and Adventure with 12 as the most popular. The rest is in the image, but it looks like the unchanged thing is that the simulation genre (powered by its sub-breakdowns) is still very strong.

In this festival, with titles that either sank Bullet Heaven into the sea or lifted it into the air with drones, we once again saw that niches can still be found even in a highly saturated genre. I still stand behind my belief that there is no genre saturation (saturated market), there are good ideas.

What we’re seeing here is, of course, not the genre distribution of the entire festival. It’s the 150 games I selected that reached the highest CCU. Unfortunately, I didn’t have time to check all of them.

Also, among these Top 50 games, according to my perception of the game world, there are 16 games that I would label as “friendslop.”  

That’s 32% of the list.

“Slop” games that have still managed to achieve enough “wishlist success” to brush aside criticisms like “We’re sick of this, what is this, are these even games?” continue to exist.  

Of course, how this success translates into sales is something that needs to be looked at with a separate statistic. (If I had the time, I’d compile which of the past Top 50 games were successful/unsuccessful, but if someone isn’t lazy, please do it for me :)

**3/4**

**Is the game that reached the most concurrent players the most liked game?**

When we match this ranking with the current demo ratings, we see that “the most liked is not the most popular,” because genre effect is bigger than pure likability.  

I was able to find ratings for 15 of the Top 25 games (CCU wise):

So saying “I made a very good game” once again shows that this alone is not enough to rationalize its value when you remain in a niche or can’t get people to hear about this quality.

And when it comes to making your voice heard, unfortunately another frustrating piece of data emerges:

**According to Simon Carless’s report from Gamediscover.co:**

In the October Next Fest, a game in the top 10% boundary gained 63 new Steam followers.  

In June this number was 121,  

Last October it was 173.  

So there are drops of 48% and 64% respectively. A similar decline is seen in other percentile ranges as well.

What’s being measured here is, of course, follower growth. The source’s approximate 1,500 wishlist equivalent for 63 followers is an estimate. (I’m also working on a database for similar estimation methods, which I’ll share later, if i can finish, TBs of data sitting on SQL database and Sam Altman trying to prevent us having more space and ram as you know, lol.)

There’s also a drop at the peak of Next Fest: The median wishlist gain of the top 10 games was 143k in June and fell to 80k in October.  

About a 44% decrease.

Moreover, because the festival has grown, the top 10% now covers a numerically larger group of games, you shouldn’t forget that.

**4/4**

**Is it the power of AI, or the AI problem?**

On the AI side, both the numbers and the fears need to be evaluated separately.

In the data shared on Weloveit’s site (compiled by Ichiro Lambe, a former Valve employee), AI usage was detected in 1,437 of the 4,238 demos evaluated within the scope of the festival. This corresponds to roughly 33.9%.

In our 150-game sample (Peak CCU), 43 games had an AI indicator next to them: 28.7%.

So as we go higher up, the likability of AI-made games drops a bit, but there isn’t a scenario where we can say AI games aren’t getting any attention at all.  

Of course, we don’t know the proportion of games on the list that don’t provide information specifically about GEN AI usage. Not disclosing doesn’t mean AI wasn’t used. Automatically counting every game that uses AI as low quality isn’t a thought that resonates with every gamer. The tool used alone doesn’t tell you how good the game is.

But I can understand both developers and players wanting to filter AI-marked games (because I want to as well). However, it doesn’t seem like things are heading that way, if you didn’t hear the news this week, I’ll explain why below.

**There’s a big problem with the AI filter part:** If disclosing reduces visibility, the honest developer is at a disadvantage while the developer who hides usage gains an advantage.

If the tag is only providing information, that’s one thing; if it affects visibility or ranking, that’s something else.

For example, what happens if a big publisher incompletely discloses AI usage?  

When indie devs hide it, can there be sanctions?  

When Activision made a mistake with a 6-fingered Santa Claus character in CoD, they got backlash from players we know that. But game companies like Ubisoft that will actively say “I will use Gen AI!” tomorrow or the day after release their games by disclosing or not disclosing, will Valve filter these games that are multi-million-dollar revenue sources and reduce their visibility? 

Can the same sanction be applied to AA/AAA developers and small developers? This isn’t a claim about a company; it’s a question that needs to be answered when designing the system.

The fear of cloning is another side of this. An easily understandable idea could already be copied. AI can further reduce the time and cost of doing so.

The real concern is that we start viewing everything a developer does with suspicion and people become hesitant to openly share their ideas. If someone can quickly copy these ideas and turn them into commercial products, running the development process openly can feel riskier, especially for solo developers and small teams.

Teams with limited budgets, time, and access to legal support will of course have a harder time responding to this competition.

**So what will Steam do about this?**

Let’s look at what Tom Giardino from Valve said at the Steam Indie Connect event on October 27:  
(I remember this topic already shared on this or indiedev subbreddit so probably you already know that, but let me share again for newcomers)

“Instead of relying on a single mechanic that someone can easily copy, you need to continue developing your game with features, personality, and creativity that come from your own perspective.”

In the statements conveyed, Valve does not want to decide whether developers will use AI or not. It advises them to continue developing original games and maintain a relationship of trust with players.  However, it does not announce any concrete new system that will prevent cloning or low-quality AI games in Next Fest. It asks that threat and blackmail cases be reported to them.

So frankly, no concrete step has yet been taken in response to the fears and requests of indie developers. Other than hoping that they make a decision with a much more comprehensive way of thinking for the reasons I mentioned earlier and share it, there’s not much we can do.

💡 Finally, my takeaway on escaping AI-assisted production competition and copycat products, and more importantly, a rapid transformation process is this:  

Small developers coming together with complementary skills can become more valuable now. This could be in the form of teaming up, or collective action through associations, unions, etc.  Instead of staying around a single easily copyable idea, producing games with stronger identity and creative integrity can also be a defensive approach.    

The second point is the increase in the value of publishers/partners.  

Because having a wingman by your side who can provide all kinds of PR, legal, etc. support that you as a solo developer can’t keep up with, or help with issues like AI clone wars or not having enough time left for marketing in accelerated production, will be quite useful.

Of course, all of this is a transition period scenario. I don’t assume that this big AI leap we’re experiencing will keep repeating continuously for years. After all, a very large portion of developers weren’t making money even in the period when they weren’t being crucified for using AI. The games that come with the AI increase will just further increase the number of unsuccessful games.  Because also most of the AI game developers not game developers or game designers, their sucess ratio will not be better than a "normal" game dev, i assume.

The era is more clearly shifting toward a direction where originality and the relationship established with the player will become more important.  

Best of luck and enjoyable game dev sessions to all of us :)

## retained text (truncated)



```
Hello everyone,

Before we start, I'll summarize who I am as briefly as possible: Almost 15 years in the gaming industry, 2 years as a jr product manager, 10 years in gaming marketing/biz dev, and for the last 3 years, back to the roots and running a small (6-person) studio. Released 2 commercially successful games, working on 2 others.

Why am I writing this summary? Because I believe in data: it helps validate gut feelings, both while working on game ideas and when handling marketing.

So grab a drink, it's gonna be a long WoT...

**Steam Next Fest 2026**

Compared to the previous festival, participation increased by about 66%, and we experienced an event that is starting to turn into more of a Horror Fest than a Next Fest, especially for indie developers.

Now, based on data-driven insights, I’ll try to explain what happened at the festival and what might happen in future events from my own perspective:

**1/4**

**The difficulty level in the visibility war is increasing**

The most talked-about topic of the October 2026 Next Fest was the number of AI games and how increasingly difficult it was to find other games in this crowd.

So what do the participation numbers say? I tried to summarize this quite broad topic under 4 headings:

There were 7,300+ games in this festival. Compared to the 4,400 games in June, that’s an increase of roughly 66%.  Compared to last year’s October (around 3,000 games), it’s 143%.

At its core, in an event people participate in for visibility/wishlists, we had a first 48 hours that felt like “good luck finding what you’re looking for.” Chaos had already erupted on social media before the algorithm pulled itself together on Wednesday.

We already know that more games are released on Steam every year.   
**But there’s a problem:** Next Fest participation is growing even faster than that.

Between 2023 and 2026, annual game releases on Steam increased by about 62%, while total Next Fest participation increased by 458%.

So it’s hard to explain the rising competition just by saying “more games are being made now.” More projects are heading to the festival and competing for the same visibility. The event that Valve encouraged developers to join in the early days has now reached a point where developers are saying things like “maybe not everyone should join…” because of the crowd of games people call “AI SLOP.”

At this point, suggestions like “releasing a game on Steam should cost $500 or $1000” aren’t logically sound proposals.  

Because the “vibecoder game developer” wave that is already okay with spending hundreds/thousands of dollars on AI tool credits to produce games can’t really be stopped this way, and it would only serve to put another barrier in front of the amateur crowd whose intention is simply to make an enjoyable game.

Of course, just because there was a big jump this year doesn’t mean we should expect 66% or 50% growth every festival. Even so, I tried to estimate it with 13.4% compound annual growth, which puts the October 2028 Next Fest at around 15,500 games.

There’s another possibility that could prevent Next Fest participation from continuing to increase so sharply. Similar to the “searching for a needle in a haystack” situation, the risk is growing that copies of an idea’s games will be cloned so quickly that they overtake the original game in popularity, maybe even becoming more popular than the original.

The fact that copies of “simple but fun” ideas or text-based/incremental etc. games that can be produced quickly with AI are becoming increasingly easy to make has already started making developers more hesitant about sharing demos. I think the real issue isn’t how much a single festival has grown, but how full a developer’s hands are (the number of wishlists collected beforehand) against the crowd they’re facing.  

**Because Next Fest is no longer a strong “wishlist multiplication tool.”** It’s more of an event for amplifying an already high wishlist count or well-timed virality (see Unharvest) and collecting feedback.  

In the rest of the post, I’ll explain with some painful numbers why Next Fest is no longer the wishlist-boosting stage it used to be.

**2/4**

**Which genres are standing out in this crowd?**  


I created a compilation by looking at three tags each from the 150 games I examined. (Because as you increase the number of tags, the data can get a bit diluted.)  

I ignored tags like Online Co-Op, Multiplayer, Co-op, Indie, Free to Play, Open World, PvE, and PvP because they don’t fully define the genre.

Looking only at a single tag/genre, Simulation is in first place with 32 games.  

It’s followed by Action with 23, Strategy with 22, Casual with 16, RPG with 15, and Adventure with 12 as the most popular. The rest is in the image, but it looks like the unchanged thing is that the simulation genre (powered by its sub-breakdowns) is still very strong.

In this festival, with titles that either sank Bullet Heaven into the sea or lifted it into the air with drones, we once again saw that niches can still be found even in a highly saturated genre. I still stand behind my belief that there is no genre saturation (saturated market), there are good ideas.

What we’re seeing here is, of course, not the genre distribution of the entire festival. It’s the 150 games I selected that reached the highest CCU. Unfortunately, I didn’t have time to check all of them.

Also, among these Top 50 games, according to my perception of the game world, there are 16 games that I would label as “friendslop.”  

That’s 32% of the list.

“Slop” games that have still managed to achieve enough “wishlist success” to brush aside criticisms like “We’re sick of this, what is this, are these even games?” continue to exist.  

Of course, how this success translates into sales is something that needs to be looked at with a separate statistic. (If I had the time, I’d compile which of the past Top 50 games were successful/unsuccessful, but if someone isn’t lazy, please do it for me :)

**3/4**

**Is the game that reached the most concurrent players the most liked game?**

When we match this ranking with the current demo ratings, we see that “the most liked is not the most popular,” because genre effect is bigger than pure likability.  

I was able to find ratings for 15 of the Top 25 games (CCU wise):

So saying “I made a very good game” once again shows that this alone is not enough to rationalize its value when you remain in a niche or can’t get people to hear about this quality.

And when it comes to making your voice heard, unfortunately another frustrating piece of data emerges:

**According to Simon Carless’s report from Gamediscover.co:**

In the October Next Fest, a game in the top 10% boundary gained 63 new Steam followers.  

In June this number was 121,  

Last October it was 173.  

So there are drops of 48% and 64% respectively. A similar decline is seen in other percentile ranges as well.

What’s being measured here is, of course, follower growth. The source’s approximate 1,500 wishlist equivalent for 63 followers is an estimate. (I’m also working on a database for similar estimation methods, which I’ll share later, if i can finish, TBs of data sitting on SQL database and Sam Altman trying to prevent us having more space and ram as you know, lol.)

There’s also a drop at the peak of Next Fest: The median wishlist gain of the top 10 games was 143k in June and fell to 80k in October.  

About a 44% decrease.

Moreover, because the festival has grown, the top 10% now covers a numerically larger group of games, you shouldn’t forget that.

**4/4**

**Is it the power of AI, or the AI problem?**

On the AI side, both the numbers and the fears need to be evaluated separately.

In the data shared on Weloveit’s site (compiled by Ichiro Lambe, a former Valve employee), AI usage was detected in 1,437 of the 4,238 demos evaluated within the scope of the festival. This corresponds to roughly 33.9%.

In our 150-game sample (Peak CCU), 43 games had an AI indicator next to them: 28.7%.

So as we go higher up, the likability of AI-made games drops a bit, but there isn’t a scenario where we can say AI games aren’t getting any attention at all.  

Of course, we don’t know the proportion of games on the list that don’t provide information specifically about GEN AI usage. Not disclosing doesn’t mean AI wasn’t used. Automatically counting every game that uses AI as low quality isn’t a thought that resonates with every gamer. The tool used alone doesn’t tell you how good the game is.

But I can understand both developers and players wanting to filter AI-marked games (because I want to as well). However, it doesn’t seem like things are heading that way, if you didn’t hear the news this week, I’ll explain why below.

**There’s a big problem with the AI filter part:** If disclosing reduces visibility, the honest developer is at a disadvantage while the developer who hides usage gains an advantage.

If the tag is only providing information, that’s one thing; if it affects visibility or ranking, that’s something else.

For example, what happens if a big publisher incompletely discloses AI usage?  

When indie devs hide it, can there be sanctions?  

When Activision made a mistake with a 6-fingered Santa Claus character in CoD, they got backlash from players we know that. But game companies like Ubisoft that will actively say “I will use Gen AI!” tomorrow or the day after release their games by disclosing or not disclosing, will Valve filter these games that are multi-million-dollar revenue sources and reduce their visibility? 

Can the same sanction be applied to AA/AAA developers and small developers? This isn’t a claim about a company; it’s a question that needs to be answered when designing the system.

The fear of cloning is another side of this. An easily understandable idea could already be copied. AI can further reduce the time and cost of doing so.

The real concern is that we start viewing everything a developer does with suspicion and people become hesitant to openly share their ideas. If someone can quickly copy these ideas and turn them into commercial products, running the development process openly can feel riskier, especially for solo developers and small teams.

Teams with limited budgets, time, and access to legal support will of course have a harder time responding to this competition.

**So what will Steam do about this?**

Let’s look at what Tom Giardino from Valve said at the Steam Indie Connect event on October 27:  
(I remember this topic already shared on this or indiedev subbreddit so probably you already know that, but let me share again for newcomers)

“Instead of relying on a single mechanic that someone can easily copy, you need to continue developing your game with features, personality, and creativity that come from your own perspective.”

In the statements conveyed, Valve does not want to decide whether developers will use AI or not. It advises them to continue developing original games and maintain a relationship of trust with players.  However, it does not announce any concrete new system that will prevent cloning or low-quality AI games in Next Fest. It asks that threat and blackmail cases be reported to them.

So frankly, no concrete step has yet been taken in response to the fears and requests of indie developers. Other than hoping that they make a decision with a much more comprehensive way of thinking for the reasons I mentioned earlier and share it, there’s not much we can do.

💡 Finally, my takeaway on escaping AI-assisted production competition and copycat products, and more importantly, a rapid transformation process is this:  

Small developers coming together with complementary skills can become more valuable now. This could be in the form of teaming up, or collective action through associations, unions, etc.  Instead of staying around a single easily copyable idea, producing games with stronger identity and 
```



document fetched 2026-11-01 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xk4o98/visibility_is_getting_harder_next_fest_2026_data
