# 220 comments later: where I was wrong about "nothing simple works — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:algotrading.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/10789a9117edcd31

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:algotrading)  published 2026-11-17 16:08 ingested 2026-11-18 02:43

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/algotrading/comments/1xyoe52/220_comments_later_where_i_was_wrong_about/)

## retained text



```
a few days ago I posted that there's no edge left in what anyone can download for free, and asked people to prove me wrong. the title was bait, I said so in the comments. I didn't expect 220 replies. I went through them, and here is what I took away, including where I was wrong.  
**where I was wrong**  
"nothing is left" was too strong. one commenter put it better than I did: what my examples actually showed is that one-line rules on free candles don't survive costs. that's a narrower claim, and I'll take it.  
I also got my own math wrong. I wrote that the best of 1,000 random backtests lands around t = 3.7. that's the ceiling. the typical best is about 3.2 (picture, 10,000 runs, anyone can redo it in ten lines). that makes the point worse, not better: a t of 3 from a big parameter sweep is what pure noise gives you on an ordinary day.  
**what the people who said "it exists" had in common**  
nobody shared a setup and I didn't ask. but the descriptions had a pattern.  
they hold for days, not minutes. one person ran about 6,500 short-term FX configs and every two weeks picked the best one. in-sample it made +0.23R per trade, the week after −0.12R, same as a random pick. what survived for him was a plain trend system held for days, because one trade's cost is small next to the move. someone with NQ order book history said almost the same thing.  
there's a reason others don't take it. one commenter has run an ETF system since 2009 that has 50-70% drawdowns about once a decade. his point was that an edge survives when it has something that makes other people not want it: a drawdown a fund can't sit through, or capacity too small for a fund to bother with.  
breadth. one person trades intraday edges across many single stocks, found on plain minute bars, after "years and years of failure". not one chart, a whole cross-section.  
trend in futures over a century came up a lot. I'd still call that pay for sitting through long bad stretches more than something others missed, but it does make money, so it counts against my title.  
**the corrected version**  
a simple rule found by searching and traded short-term is almost certainly noise, or eaten by costs. what survives seems to hold longer, sits where big players can't or won't go, and comes with a reason you can say in one sentence.  
question for this round: if you have something that survived, what was the reason others weren't taking it? the drawdown, the size, the effort, or plain boredom? curious which one is most common.
```



document fetched 2026-11-18 00:48 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/algotrading/comments/1xyoe52/220_comments_later_where_i_was_wrong_about
