# Sustainability Discussion. My hot take: indie devs need to worry about battling dead-on-arrival, instead of focus on the "top" — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:gamedev.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/10a5ccae63e7e0d0

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:gamedev)  published 2026-09-16 15:07 ingested 2026-09-17 02:36

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1whzvv0/sustainability_discussion_my_hot_take_indie_devs/)

## retained text



```
Hey guys,

Wanted to drop you my take on what I believe is an interesting story that popped up not that long ago. First off: I’ve worked 16+ years in the industry in games marketing, PR, publishing, and most recently development.

I just saw Simon’s GameDiscover newsletter where he talks about if *“the game biz.. sustainable for the average indie?”* He puts forward the following point:

*“Let’s say you spent USD $500k of your own money to make your game: no publisher, but you get all the upside. If you released that game on Steam in January 2026 (above), you’d need to be one of the 16 games of 1,230 (1.3%) that grossed >$1m LTD to have made $550k+ net back (after refunds, chargebacks, Valve’s 30%), and now be profitable, w/ongoing cashflow.”* 

Now, I can sincerely say that these numbers look right to me. So why this wall of text? 

Because I feel the GameDiscover data is true but only tells one part of the story. And Simon’s story is largely correct (it's a tough-cookie world, and you likely won’t make money), which I’m not going to argue against, but I know his insights will be misconstrued by some in the community, since they paint only one part of the picture. 

For many, 500k might be a lot - it's clearly in the territory of a studio that has released one game or more and has multiple collaborators - but it doesn’t mean your indie game will not be sustainable. Everyone will have a different lead time, amount of collaborators, overhead, size of team, time working, doing it part-time, etc.

I also found it to be a very specific take, that doesn’t really address the big elephant in the room: it’s not about making half a million net, it’s about setting yourself up for success. 

My post is not about the sustainability for an average indie, rather, it is about how many small indies **fail to climb** even the first rung of the ladder to success. 

So, let me offer a different view and an alternative take on January 2026, zooming in on the bottom rung, with some marketing food for thought. I will argue that for small indies, hobbyists, solo devs, there is a land of opportunity there (but maybe not a land of plenty). But many of you will not follow the **basic steps** to get yourself even a ticket to visit this magical land. 

GameDiscover shows a total of 1230 titles released in January 2026. I can’t really parse the data in such a way to check reviews (and if you check individual Steam store pages, the review numbers are skewed after a couple of months out in the wild). According to the data for January (found here), no copies sold were 412, no reviews were 686, and no revenue were 519 titles. I took the average, getting 530+. So about 43% of the total. It might be closer to 50% or higher, but much lower I wouldn’t say would ring true. 

SteamDB has a nice graph, showing Steam Releases by Review Count (only does this per year). For 2026, and counting, we are at almost 19,000 games released (2025 saw 21,299). But if we take out the 0 reviews and the 1-9 reviews, we get a current total of 10,150 titles in 2026 (already more than 2025’s 9,813). That’s 53% of the total in 2026 being either slop or failed efforts (46% in 2025). Correlates pretty well with January’s number. At least it gives us a good ballpark figure to wrestle with. 

Some key points and statements looking at January 2026.

* First statement: you are not competing against the total number of weekly or monthly releases; you are competing against **competitor games** in your chosen genre or niche. 
* Second important statement: You are not competing against 1200+ titles, but against roughly half of that: 530+ titles. Why? Close to 43% of the titles released on Steam in a month are **dead on arrival.**  Not even twitching… just a cold slab of code, inert, taking interweb space. Who does this? Why? But wait, there is more.
* If you get between 1-9 reviews, that’s not even taking advantage of friends and family (or you really don’t have any friends, but c’mon, not even a couple?), but furthermore, you likely don’t recoup your Steam Direct entry cost. We're talking about 370+ titles according to ICO Partners Footprints newsletter for January 2026. GameDiscover data is a bit trickier, but if we look at titles that sold fewer than 200 copies (which is already a vague data point), we get 281 games. Say an average of 325 titles that went through all the work of being developed and getting a release, but with likely zero marketing push or thinking. 
* No marketing or promotion or thinking about your positioning or looking at your Steam page or even making a trailer, or looking at what’s happening in your game genre/niche - **if you don’t do any of this**… expect to languish either in the 0 or 1-9 review underworld, together with roughly 855+ other titles. 
* This means (very roughly) that out of 1230 games released in January 2026 and storming the beaches (*ratatatata*), only 375 get past the shingle and up to the bluff! That’s a 30% survival rate.

There is one big caveat. 

* You are not only competing against the other January releases, but all the ones in your chosen genre/niche that came before. Ever. There is no other way around it. Your game exists as part of a greater whole. Picture your game as part of a longer family tree of similar games; that’s why thinking about what your game does differently matters. 

Coming back to January 2026. That last segment, those 375 other games, that’s where the real work is. 

You can’t tell me that if you want to spend 1 or 2+ years developing a game, you can’t or are unwilling to find the time or energy to look at your marketing or positioning, to check against competitor titles, to make sure your game has the best chance of success against 20% of the released titles in a month? What’s more, you are competing against a subsection of these 375, specifically in your genre. 

This really boils down to **a) making a game b) making a game that excites (be it art, game loop, freshness, theme) c) market said game.** And the sad truth: many will not finish a), they will have not thought one iota about b), or will completely ignore c). 

Everybody talks about how it is not only difficult to make a game (very), how difficult it is to get it sustainable, but also for this game to be discovered. But if you don’t even put a modicum of effort, time, and money into getting your foot in the door, how do you expect to succeed?

Don’t think about being part of the January’s 16 titles that make enough revenue to get 500k within a year; be an indie that does their homework and takes all steps to allow for success to come. 

So, GameDiscover talks about a specific case for studios. But before you worry about getting to that point, make sure you get out of the door first.  
```



document fetched 2026-09-17 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1whzvv0/sustainability_discussion_my_hot_take_indie_devs
