# I built a game that now has 690 daily players without spending anything on ads. Here's where they came from. — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:gamedev.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/1a107108e742b0b9

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:gamedev)  published 2026-11-13 15:23 ingested 2026-11-14 02:37

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xvaon2/i_built_a_game_that_now_has_690_daily_players/)

## retained text



```
I have 1890 registered players and about 690 play every day. I have spent $0 on ads. I also track where almost every signup comes from so I can share the actual numbers instead of guessing.

Short background: I worked in games for 15 years, always on a team. In February I started building an idle RPG alone. It runs in the browser and on Android, and has been in open beta since September.

**THE NUMBERS**

* 1,890 players have made an account
* 695 played yesterday. On 1 October it was 159
* 278 accounts came through Google Play
* 51% are still playing a week after they start, 40% after a month
* $0 spent on ads. Hosting costs about €60 a month

Note I allow guest accounts so only 36% visitors register and numbers are from registered users that's why are so high. 

**WHERE THE PLAYERS CAME FROM**

I tag every link and record where each account first came from, so these numbers are counted, not guessed.

**1. Reddit: about 550**

Every post gets its own tagged link. Posts in subs for my exact genre were the best by far. Nearly half the people who clicked made an account.

One post brought 62 players from 112 visitors. A second post in the same sub a week later brought 10 to 17. Each sub seems to work best the first time.

**2. Game vote sites and toplists: about 375**

I didn't expect this one. Small lists, one of them made just for my genre, with a small in-game reward for voting. 

My own players vote, the game climbs the list, and strangers browsing the list find it.

**3. Google Play: 278**

The Android app is the web game in a wrapper, with the same save. It took a weekend to make and is now my third biggest source.

**4. Player invites: 194**

Every player has an invite code and both sides get a reward.

**5. Direct and word of mouth: 194**

One small YouTuber made a video, and it also lands here.

**6. Google search: about 170**

A wiki generated from the game data gives Google about 1,000 pages to find. These players also stay as well as the Reddit ones. D7 retention from Google search is 56%.

**WHAT WENT WRONG**

**My most viewed post was one of my worst.**

It went up in a developer sub, about how I built the game. 1,868 visitors, more than all my other posts together. Only 58 made an account, about 3%.   
Developers click to see how you did it, look for 30 seconds and leave.  
All my developer sub posts together: 2024 visitors, 80 players.  
If I had judged by upvotes and views, I would probably still be posting there.

**Playtest subs gave me almost nothing.**

7 posts in play-my-game style subs: 18 visitors, 0 accounts.  
They are mostly other developers posting their own games. Fine for feedback, not so good for finding players.

**The art.**

The first versions looked cheap and generic, and people told me so. I asked a sub what gave it away and got almost 100 honest comments, twice.  
I fixed what they named and added a second, warmer storybook look you can switch on. It is better, but still not where a real artist would take it.

**Progress and saves.**

Most of the hard work was not features. It was making sure nobody loses progress: offline time, two devices on one account, a reload that freezes.  
Some of these bugs were found by players, not tests. One update wiped a skill's progress for a few players and I restored each one by hand.

If your game has saves, build the guards and backups before you need them.

**WHAT I WOULD DO AGAIN**

* Tag every link from day one. My gut was wrong about which source was best.
* Post in player subs for your genre, not developer subs, if you want players.
* Build things that bring players without me: search pages, vote sites, invites.
* Count accounts, not clicks. Views told me the opposite of the truth.
* Create discord again! I have 500+ players on discord and best feedback comes from them. Honestly 50%+ good things are from them and bad are all mine

If you want to check it: [https://dragonscapeidle.com/?utm\_source=reddit&utm\_medium=post&utm\_campaign=beta&utm\_content=gamedev-2&style=storybook](https://dragonscapeidle.com/?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=post&utm_campaign=beta&utm_content=gamedev-2&style=storybook)

**Question for you:** Do you track players per post or per channel, or only views and upvotes? And has a developer sub ever brought you real players? How you promote your game?
```



document fetched 2026-11-14 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xvaon2/i_built_a_game_that_now_has_690_daily_players
