# 60% Penalty under FAST DS is absolutely ridiculous especially if your tax liability is Zero even if the FSI was not disclosed. But still better than BMA. You are just choosing lesser of the 2 evils! — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:IndiaTax.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/29b814fecfcee0e0

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:IndiaTax)  published 2026-11-11 18:03 ingested 2026-11-12 02:43

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaTax/comments/1xtouwd/60_penalty_under_fast_ds_is_absolutely_ridiculous/)

## retained text



```
I have about $ 4,000 USD of foreign bank interest income not disclosed about a couple of years back under FSI. Plus the bank balance  more than 20 Lacs + not disclosed under FA.

Even if I had shown it, my tax liability would be still zero, as total income that year was below 12 Lacs, so after 87A rebate, no tax. No loss to ex chequer.

A. Now I have to pay $ 2,400 penalty on it under FAST DS.  (30% + 30% = 60% ).  Under Category 1 of FAST DS.

Also 1 Lac additional penalty under Category 2 of FAST DS. For not showing the bank balance 20 Lacs + under FA.

So with these 2 Category penalties, all my  hard earned $ 4,000 is pretty much gone. ($2,400 + 1 Lac Rs.)

B. Or 10 Lacs under BMA , plus prosecution! This is my other option.

Just for a compliance mistake. No tax evasion . No black money. No loss to the government. Money not even earned in India and taken out of India.

Money already taxed abroad at source and Savings White money.

I earned and saved this money abroad by doing retail jobs and brutal warehouse labour jobs. And by living frugally.

The irony is my tax would be Zero and I get to keep the $ 4,000 if I had just filled some FA & FSI schedule. Now all gone under FAST DS.

Coming back to India as an OCI was a mistake. Lot of people had warned me, not to go back. What a fool , I was!

I will pay this money & leave again. This time for good.

Came back to take care of my ageing parents.

One of them passed away. Called  3-4 ambulance, none came for 1 hour. The emergency numbers like 100, 108 & other hospital emergency lines were hanging up on me. Died waiting for an ambulance. This is the service we get after paying taxes.

Was literally running on the streets looking for an ambulance like a mad man as none were coming over the phone. Emergency services are a joke in this country

Now taking care of the other parent. Will take care of them till their final days.

After that the Income tax department can do whatever they want to me. I have nothing to lose by then. Jail won't affect me either. 
```



document fetched 2026-11-12 00:48 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndiaTax/comments/1xtouwd/60_penalty_under_fast_ds_is_absolutely_ridiculous
