# Alphabet vs Amazon vs Meta vs Nvidia: which stock would I choose for the long term Horizon? — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:ValueInvesting.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/3540c76b21895661

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:ValueInvesting)  published 2026-10-28 14:23 ingested 2026-10-29 02:43

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xhpgpx/alphabet_vs_amazon_vs_meta_vs_nvidia_which_stock/)

## retained text



```
# Four companies, four different ways to win from AI. Nvidia sells the chips. Amazon rents out computing power and sells to customers. Meta uses AI to make its ads more valuable. Alphabet is growing Cloud while defending Search. At the October 27, 2026 closing prices, my overall research order is Amazon, Nvidia, Meta, Alphabet. I’d choose Nvidia for two years and Amazon for five to ten. That is a ranking of potential returns from these prices, not a claim that any one business is certain to win.

**Nvidia wins the two-year contest because the earnings are arriving now.** It just earned **$2.46 a share** on **$96.2 billion in quarterly sales**. Management expects about **$108 billion in next-quarter sales** at a **74% gross margin**, though it has given no EPS forecast. At **$217.94**, I get roughly **25 times annualised operating earnings**. My two-year case needs annual sales to reach **$600 billion** while Nvidia keeps a remarkable **62% operating margin**. That produces about **$12.82 of operating EPS**; at **25 times**, the share would be worth roughly **$320** before costs and dividends. The risk is in that margin: customers building their own chips, price pressure or slower AI spending could cut it faster than sales grow. [investor.nvidia.com](https://investor.nvidia.com/news/press-release-details/2026/NVIDIA-Announces-Financial-Results-for-Second-Quarter-Fiscal-2027/default.aspx?trk=article-ssr-frontend-pulse_little-text-block&utm_source=chatgpt.com)

**Amazon’s $5.75 quarterly EPS is the number I would** ***not*** **build a thesis on.** It includes **$53.4 billion of non-operating pretax income**, mainly tied to Anthropic. Even operating profit benefited by about **$1.2 billion** from tariff refunds and energy-contract accounting. The stronger evidence is AWS: sales rose **37% to $42.2 billion**, and operating profit reached **$16.6 billion**. Amazon guides to **$197 billion–$202 billion of next-quarter sales** and **$22.5 billion–$26.5 billion of operating profit**, with no EPS guide. At **$253.10**, the shares cost roughly **34 times** my annualised operating-earnings estimate after removing those operating benefits. That is expensive for a company whose trailing free cash flow is **negative $7.6 billion** and whose **2026 cash capital-spending plan rose from about $200 billion to about $220 billion**.

**Why put Amazon first anyway? Because it has more than one route to higher earnings per share.** AWS can sell more computing power, advertising can earn more from shoppers, and a more efficient delivery network can leave more profit on each order. My five-year case assumes **$1.7 trillion in annual sales**, a **16% operating margin** and **$17.90 of operating EPS** after allowing for more shares. At **25 times earnings**, that is about **$448 a share**. At ten years, **$3.1 trillion in sales**, a **17% margin** and **$32.46 EPS** at just **21 times** give roughly **$682**. My weighted scenarios imply **+79% cumulative net return over five years** and **+173% over ten**. Those are demanding forecasts, especially while cash is being spent ahead of returns. If Amazon’s five-year margin reaches **14% instead of 16%**, its modeled return drops to about **+57%**—below Nvidia’s **+67%**. Amazon earns first place only if the spending eventually turns into cash for each share.

**Meta:** Meta’s advertising business is strong, but the bills are getting bigger. It reported **$3.83 in profit per share** last quarter. Without a **$9.89 billion legal charge**, Meta says that figure would have been **$7.40**. At a share price of **$620.19**, that looks like a reasonable price if the adjusted profit can be repeated. But the legal bill has not gone away: one settlement allows payments of up to **$18.59 billion**, and a separate court ordered a **$25 billion penalty plus interest**. Meta is appealing the second ruling, so we do not know what it will ultimately pay. Even before the legal charge, its profit margin fell from about **40% to 35%**. Management expects **$73 billion–$76 billion in sales next quarter** and **$135 billion–$145 billion in capital spending this year**, but has given no profit-per-share forecast. Cash left after investment was **negative $2.12 billion last quarter**, though positive for the first nine months. Meta is also raising money in ways that could leave each existing share with a smaller slice of future profits. My five-year forecast is **$47.88 of annual profit per share**, valued at **19 times**, which leaves Meta third. Its planned extra Class C share works like a stock split; it does not make shareholders richer by itself.

**Alphabet:** Google’s businesses are growing, but I think the shares already charge me for a lot of that growth. Search-related sales rose **17%** last quarter and Cloud sales rose **82%**. Reported profit was **$9.11 per share**, but **$6.26** came from gains on investments, which may not repeat. Take away those gains and the figure is **$2.85**. My estimate based only on operating profit is lower, at **$2.58 per share for the quarter**. At **$320.58 a share**, that means paying about **31 times a full year of profit at that quarterly pace**. My five-year forecast is **$16.20 in annual profit per share**; valuing it at **22 times** gives roughly **$356 a share** before costs and dividends. Alphabet spent more cash than its operations brought in last quarter, although it still generated **$53.3 billion of cash after investment over the past year**. It plans **$195 billion–$205 billion in capital spending this year** and expects more next year. It also raised **$49.6 billion by issuing shares and convertible preferred stock**; a further **$40 billion share-sale programme** had not been used by June’s end. Cloud may do better than I expect, and Alphabet’s investment holdings have value I have not added separately. I rank it fourth until I can see more of that growth turning into cash for each share.

**Here is what the ranking pays in my model, cumulatively rather than per year.** At **two years**: **Nvidia +50%, Meta +19%, Amazon +11%, Alphabet +10%**. At **five**: **Amazon +79%, Nvidia +67%, Meta +49%, Alphabet +14%**. At **ten**: **Amazon +173%, Nvidia +83%, Meta +62%, Alphabet +41%**. I use bear/base/bull weights of **25%/55%/20%**, future diluted share counts, assumed dividends, **0.5% buying and 0.5% selling costs**, and lower earnings multiples as these businesses mature. The odds and future EPS are **my assumptions, not management guidance or calibrated probabilities**. My modeled Nvidia two-year bear loses roughly a third; Amazon’s five-year bear loses roughly a fifth. Those are scenarios, not worst-case limits. None of the weighted outcomes reaches my **+500% five-year** or **+1,000% ten-year** ambition.

**My pick is Amazon for the long haul, Nvidia for the next two year.** In a separate twelve-month test, my weighted net returns are about **+30% for Nvidia, +14% for Meta and −1% each for Amazon and Alphabet**.  Alphabet reports on **October 28** and Amazon on **October 29**, so I would refresh the numbers before acting. **AI revenue is exciting. Cash earned for each future share is the prize.** 

Lovely Day.
```



document fetched 2026-10-29 00:47 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xhpgpx/alphabet_vs_amazon_vs_meta_vs_nvidia_which_stock
