# apparently USPS’ pricing is my fault — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:EtsySellers.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/36d0c4b2005cd301

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:EtsySellers)  published 2026-11-06 19:09 ingested 2026-11-07 02:38

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/EtsySellers/comments/1xplbdj/apparently_usps_pricing_is_my_fault/)

## retained text



```
I’m a sticker seller in the US who has been using the infamous untracked/partially tracked letter mail shipping option since I opened my shop about 2 years ago. if you’re a sticker seller you’re aware of the issues this can come with I’m sure. the premature delivery notifications that confuse buyers and make them think their package was stolen, orders getting sent back to my return address with no explanation despite the buyer’s address being correct, orders taking inordinately longer than the estimated delivery window that Etsy provides them with, packages never showing up at all, the list goes on.

but I’ve dealt with it because the percentage of orders that actually did experience issues was very low, and packages going missing entirely has been pretty rare. I just have disclaimers about the “snail mail” option posted all over my listings and shop and urge people to select the tracked shipping upgrade if they’re buying time sensitive gifts, although many people still don’t see these disclaimers somehow. I have lots of saved replies to easily send when someone has an issue, and I utilize Etsy’s protection policy and they always cover cases for missing orders so I don’t lose money. and generally speaking my customers are usually super kind and understanding as soon as I explain things to them. it’s been easy enough to deal with up until now.

the past month or two there has been an atrocious uptick in these cases, (despite sales being *lower* than usual) and it’s hurting my shop, and people have become increasingly less understanding, seriously I just got back from vacation and the whole time I was getting multiple messages and help requests every day about “my order never arrived.” I had auto-replies on but I still saw the messages coming through and tried to reply to them as I could because it was stressing me out. 

I’ve been considering moving away from untracked letter mail nearly the whole time my shop has been open. after getting messages from almost every single customer from a particular batch of orders and then some, it was the last straw for me and I finally turned off that shipping option and switched only to calculated tracked mail as soon as I got home.

it’s been a few days since I did this and I actually immediately saw an increase in sales which was really interesting, many of my bumper sticker orders used to come out to $10-12 including shipping, now people are happy to pay $16-18 for a bumper sticker?? I mean I’m down. i’ve been feeling great about the change, after feeling discouraged about my shop for so long it feels like things are finally starting to look up a bit, not to mention the numerous help requests are certain to go down and I‘ll be able to breathe a bit again.

and then I get this message today out of the blue. I knew this would upset people but I wasn’t expecting it so soon so it makes me wonder if this type of hate mail is going to be like a weekly thing. of course I graciously explained to him why I had to make the change, I don’t expect him to reply nor do I think I really want him to.

anyway I‘d like to hear other sticker shops’ experience with turning off that godawful letter mail shipping. are angry customers a regular occurrence for you? how do you handle them? I have also wondered if people will feel like they’re paying $18 for the product itself even if that total does include shipping, and then feel like their expectations aren’t met when they open it up and it’s smaller or thinner or blah blah blah than they expected and it isn’t worth the money they paid. btw I have hundreds of 5 star reviews, only a couple negative ones that weren’t actually my fault. I sell quality items. but I’m afraid a higher total, after shipping is factored in, will make people expect a much nicer item.

it feels unfair to be getting a message like this just because the item I sell is small, light, and flat and can fit in an envelope. if it was anything else, such as washi tape, I wouldn’t be expected to use snail mail to ship it.

just feeling a bit discouraged and want to hear other experiences, maybe I don’t have anything to worry about…?
```



document fetched 2026-11-07 00:24 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/EtsySellers/comments/1xplbdj/apparently_usps_pricing_is_my_fault
