# 14 of the last 23 people who reached our trial's card screen left without even trying a card. Here's what the data says and what we're changing. — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:SaaS.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/3ac32c1d7b7c9e79

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:SaaS)  published 2026-11-15 17:50 ingested 2026-11-16 02:36

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/SaaS/comments/1xx1v33/14_of_the_last_23_people_who_reached_our_trials/)

## retained text



```
We sell a B2B prospecting tool with a 14-day free trial that asks for a card upfront. Stripe kept pinging us with "new customer" notifications, but the trial count wasn't moving. So I pulled one week of data.

**Where the "new customers" came from**

They weren't sign-ups. Our checkout creates the Stripe customer the moment someone clicks Continue on the plan screen, before the card form even renders (so a declined card retried later doesn't create a duplicate customer). Every "new customer" ping meant one thing: someone reached the card form.

**The week, in numbers**

| What | Count |
|---|---|
| Stripe customers created | 23 |
| Paid or started the trial | 9 |
| Left at the card form | 14 |
| Of those 14, picked the free trial | 13 |
| Card attempts among the 14 (declines included) | **0** |

Zero attempts is the interesting part. Nobody tried a card and got declined. They saw the form and left.

The pay-as-you-go option (no subscription, add credit) showed the same pattern: 3 paid, 13 sessions expired.

**What we already had to win them back, and how it did**

Two automated emails: one an hour after their first search ("here are 5 of the people we found"), one three days later ("your setup is one step from done"). Over 30 days:

- First email: about 5% real clicks, 3 trials out of 138 within 14 days.
- Second email: 3.5% clicks, 1 trial out of 86.

Then we found out both were landing in Gmail's Promotions tab (we checked on a cold inbox). We rewrote them as plain letters from a person, and only a change of subject line moved them to Primary.

**What I think is actually going on**

1. The card form is the first moment the product asks for trust instead of giving value. Our follow-up email said "one step left" without ever answering the real objection: will I be charged?
2. The fix in the email: say it plainly. Nothing is charged before day 14, cancel in one click in Settings, or skip the subscription and pay only for what you use.
3. The bigger question we haven't answered: a trial without a card for part of the traffic. Fewer people would convert to paid, but many more would start, and we'd see which number wins.

**What I'd check in your own funnel**

- Count card attempts, not just abandoned checkouts. "Abandoned with zero attempts" and "abandoned after a decline" need opposite fixes.
- Check where your rescue emails land with a cold Gmail inbox (search `category:promotions`). Ours were invisible.
- Read your Stripe "new customer" notifications as "reached the card form", if your checkout creates customers early like ours.

Has anyone here A/B tested card vs no-card trials for a B2B tool around 100 €/month? I'd love real numbers before we try it.

Disclosure: I'm a co-founder of BeReach, the product in question.

```



document fetched 2026-11-16 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/SaaS/comments/1xx1v33/14_of_the_last_23_people_who_reached_our_trials
