# 1,455 signups but only 54 paying users. What am I doing wrong? — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:SaaS.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/44edc50da902c2d0

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:SaaS)  published 2026-11-19 15:29 ingested 2026-11-20 02:37

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/SaaS/comments/1y0c6q8/1455_signups_but_only_54_paying_users_what_am_i/)

## retained text



```
I build an Instagram growth tool for creators in the evenings, next to my full-time job. It schedules Reels, and when someone comments a keyword on your post it sends them a DM with your link, analytics, carousel builder and so on. It launched on August 5.

Three and a half months later, 1,455 people have signed up and 54 of them pay me. I'm not sure if that is normal for a free plan or if I'm doing something wrong, so here is the whole funnel.

|Step|People|Share of signups|
|:-|:-|:-|
|Signed up|1,455|100%|
|Clicked "connect Instagram"|656|45%|
|Connected Instagram|527|36%|
|Built something (a DM automation or a scheduled post)|243|17%|
|Viewed pricing|472|32%|
|Opened checkout|138|9%|
|Paying today|54|3.5%|

The 54 are 46 subscriptions and 8 lifetime deals from the launch weeks. Almost all the subscriptions are on my $9.99 plan, so MRR is about $410 USD.

What people get for free, with no card and no time limit:

* Unlimited post scheduling
* 5 comment-to-DM automations
* MCP access
* A small "Sent via" line at the end of the DMs, which goes away on the paid plan

What I see in the data:

* 64% of signups never connect their Instagram. They create an account, look around and leave. Without a connected account the product can't do anything for them.
* Only 53 people have ever hit a limit on the free plan. For most people who do use it, free is enough.
* Some people create a second account to stay on the free plan.
* The people who pay decide fast. 31 of my first 52 customers paid on the same day they signed up. Almost nobody upgrades slowly after weeks on free.
* 58 people deleted their account.

What I have tried so far:

* Added the $9.99 plan after a customer on the $29 plan cancelled and told me it was costly. Most of my customers are on it now.
* Personal emails to people who got stuck. That brought a few customers and is the best thing I have done.
* Two discount codes a week apart. The first brought 4 customers. The second brought 1, and he asked to cancel three days later.

My questions:

1. Is 3.5% from signup to paid bad for a product with a free plan, or is the real problem the 64% who never connect an account?
2. Would you make the free plan smaller, or leave it and work only on getting people to connect?
3. If most buyers pay on day one, is it worth spending any time on the people who are still on free after a month?
```



document fetched 2026-11-20 00:28 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/SaaS/comments/1y0c6q8/1455_signups_but_only_54_paying_users_what_am_i
