# Nike vs On vs Deckers: which stock would I buy? — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:ValueInvesting.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/4642fbc2e62a5600

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:ValueInvesting)  published 2026-10-24 19:31 ingested 2026-10-25 02:40

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xehm0s/nike_vs_on_vs_deckers_which_stock_would_i_buy/)

## retained text



```
Three shoe companies and I’m choosing between three very different bets. Nike needs a comeback. On needs to keep growing fast. Deckers needs HOKA and UGG to keep earning what they earn today. At the October 23 closes, I’d put my money on **Deckers** for the next two to five years. Here’s why .

Nike’s problem is what I’d have to pay while I wait. Revenue fell 4% last quarter, direct sales fell 8%, and management expects a high-single-digit revenue decline this fiscal year. At $37.30, it trades around 30 times the midpoint of management’s adjusted earnings guidance. I like the brand. I don’t like paying for the recovery before I can see it. ([investors.nike.com](https://investors.nike.com/news-events/press-releases/detail/575/nike-inc-reports-fiscal-2027-first-quarter-results?utm_source=chatgpt.com))

On is the one that makes this a real contest. On is winning customers *right now* . Sales grew 21.6% in constant currency last quarter, direct sales grew 34.3% and gross margin hit 65.4%. People are buying the shoes without On having to chase them with discounts. If it keeps that up for years, it could beat both rivals. I would not dismiss that as a passing shoe trend. There’s money behind the growth, too. On had CHF 1.21 billion in cash at June’s end. From its reported cash flows, I calculated roughly CHF 429 million of operating cash after equipment and intangible purchases over the twelve months to June. Management is aiming for high-teens annual sales growth through 2029. If it delivers, today’s cash generation could look small in hindsight. That is the case for putting **On ahead of Nike**.

Why does On stop at second against the three? At $32.51, On’s recent cash generation works out to a **roughly 5% free-cash-flow yield** by my calculation, after converting Swiss francs and accounting for the different economic rights of its share classes. Deckers’ comparable starting cash yield has been roughly twice that. On can close the gap by growing; Deckers gives me more cash flow at the start. On’s lower share price alone tells us nothing about which stock is cheaper. 

Deckers didn’t give me an all-clear in its latest report. HOKA sales grew 6.8% and UGG grew 3.5%, but comparable direct sales fell 6.4%. And $0.28 of quarterly EPS came from tariff refunds. Anyone celebrating the earnings jump without mentioning those two facts is skipping the part I care about. ([ir.deckers.com](https://ir.deckers.com/news-events/press-releases/detail/666/deckers-brands-reports-second-quarter-fiscal-year-2027-financial-results?utm_source=chatgpt.com))

Here’s why I still pick it. At $81.09, Deckers trades around **11 times this year’s guided earnings after subtracting the expected tariff-refund benefit**. It has $1.21 billion in cash and no outstanding borrowings. There’s also $4.4 billion left on its buyback authorization, though authorization is only permission to buy, not a promise that every share will be bought cheaply. ([ir.deckers.com](https://ir.deckers.com/news-events/press-releases/detail/666/deckers-brands-reports-second-quarter-fiscal-year-2027-financial-results?utm_source=chatgpt.com))

I could be wrong about what those earnings are worth. If HOKA keeps slowing and Deckers has to discount to move shoes, 11 times earnings won’t save the thesis. That’s the next test: **are HOKA and UGG still selling well at full price, and can Deckers grow operating profit without one-time refunds**.

  
**I’d buy Deckers today and keep On very close on the watchlist.** My order at these prices is **Deckers first, On second , Nike**. If On sustains this pace and turns more of its sales into cash per share, it could be the better ten-year investment. If Deckers’ direct sales keep falling, I’ll have ranked it too highly. For now, On has the better growth story; Deckers gives me the better deal on profits I can see today. Nike gets another look when its sales turn. 

  
Happy Weekend !






```



document fetched 2026-10-25 00:38 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xehm0s/nike_vs_on_vs_deckers_which_stock_would_i_buy
