# I’ve Improved Everything I Can Think Of. My Conversion Rate Keeps Getting Worse. — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:ecommerce.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/4e6c1f070a58f313

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:ecommerce)  published 2026-10-09 16:16 ingested 2026-10-10 02:35

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/ecommerce/comments/1x1pm4a/ive_improved_everything_i_can_think_of_my/)

## retained text



```
I genuinely don't know whether to shut down my ecom business or keep grinding.

It's been 5 years now, and here's the part I cannot wrap my head around:

**The website keeps getting better. The conversion rate keeps getting worse.**

Over the years I've made what feels like every reasonable improvement I can think of:

* Expanded the menu to include more relevant subcategories
* Added better filtering
* Improved the homepage and imagery
* Made shipping costs and lead times much easier to find
* Added popular questions and answers to many of our most popular product pages
* Had our developer optimize the site for speed
* Spent an absurd amount of time working on SEO

And yet...

Our conversion rate peaked at around **0.14% in 2023 and is now down to around 0.04% in 2026.**

Absolutely terrible, I know.

BUT there is some important context: I sell high-end/luxury products with an average order value of around **$3,000**.

(I recently even sold a single desk for $22,000)

Over its lifetime, the site has done around **$1 million in sales**, with healthy margins averaging roughly 30%.

But with sales volume declining, the business is now struggling to stay afloat.

There's also clearly a market for these products. And there's no doubt, that even with luxury prices, there is still a multibillion-dollar online global market for this category.

Yes, there are other authorized vendors selling some of the same brands/products, so it's definitely competitive. And some massive competitors in this space are absolutely raking it in.

There's obviously huge demand. There's obviously a significant market. There's gotta be some market share in there for me, no? The giants may dominate the feast, but there's still plenty on the table for the rest of us.

My approach has been to offer a more curated, niche selection rather than trying to be everything to everyone, and I've put a lot of effort into making the product pages and overall UI as good as I can possibly think to make them.

# Here's the part that's driving me crazy.

I've looked pretty deeply into the customer journey.

Checkout works. I've tested it. The problem seems to happen way before checkout.

Our **add-to-cart rate is under 1%**, and yes, that is the number that has been gradually declining.

Some other numbers:

**Average time on page: 47 seconds**  
**Average pages/session: 1.5**

I've also considered traffic quality and search intent.

But our marketing/customer acquisition sources have remained generally stable over this period. The majority of our traffic comes through Google organic, and when I look at the actual searches bringing people to the site, the intent seems pretty relevant.

I then spent MONTHS aggressively working on SEO, thinking maybe the answer was simply more organic traffic.

Nope.

Despite all that work, organic traffic has remained generally flat/consistent.

At this point, I'm constantly analyzing audits, reading about new optimizations, spending money, and trying the next idea...only for nothing to really change. There's always another expert, another fix, another keyword strategy, and I genuinely don't know what to trust anymore or how long I can keep chasing the next thing.

I thought of investing in Google Ads because obviously more qualified traffic could generate more sales.

But I keep coming back to the same thought:

**Wouldn't Google Ads just be paying to send more people into a leaky bucket?**

And that's basically where I'm stuck.

**If you were looking at these numbers, what would you investigate next?**

And at what point would you stop optimizing and accept that it's time to shut it down?
```



document fetched 2026-10-10 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ecommerce/comments/1x1pm4a/ive_improved_everything_i_can_think_of_my
