# Instagram restores four protest reporters’ accounts after legal notices, but won’t name the “legal requirements” it cited — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:india.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/5df1c20084668349

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:india)  published 2026-10-23 12:50 ingested 2026-10-24 02:37

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/india/comments/1xdd4yd/instagram_restores_four_protest_reporters/)

## extract

# tl;dr

Since the start of October 2026, journalists and news creators reporting on the protests in Delhi have had their Instagram posts and, in several cases, their entire accounts withheld in India, with a one-line notice that cites the IT Rules, 2021 as a whole and names no provision, authority, order or offending post. Their complaints to Meta’s Grievance Officer were closed within two to four minutes. On 15 October 2026, legal notices were sent to Meta, with IFF’s assistance, on behalf of four of them. All four accounts were restored on 19 and 20 October 2026, without any clear notification from Meta and without any explanation of why they were restricted. All of this is happening alongside an unpublished MeitY advisory of 10 October 2026 that asks Meta for “*enhanced diligence*” over content on “*ongoing public events*” and to ensure that its recommendation systems do not result in “*disproportionate exposure of users to a single or limited set of narratives*”. We explain why the restrictions are unlawful, why Meta’s grievance process has failed, and what we are asking of Meta and MeitY.

# Background

# The restrictions

Since the first week of October 2026, independent journalists and news creators reporting on the protests in Delhi have found their Instagram posts made unavailable in India and, in several cases, their entire accounts restricted. Each account, once restricted, displayed to users in India the same statement: “*We temporarily restricted access to this account pursuant to legal requirements under India’s Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules.*” The statement does not disclose the provision invoked, the authority at whose instance Meta acted, the content said to be unlawful, or how long the restriction would last. Meta’s notifications to the account holders, including some that described the action as a “*suspension*”, came from a “*no-reply*” address that admits no response. The four account holders whose cases we set out below have received no order or notice from any authority, and none of them was heard before the restriction.

The notices that users have shared with us take two forms. Some state that Meta acted on “*a notice from the Government of India/Law Enforcement under Section 79(3)(b)*”. Others state that the content was restricted “*through an automated system implemented pursuant to legal requirements under India’s Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules*”. Neither names the issuing agency, the order, the provision of law or offence the content is said to disclose, or the URL complained of. From our litigation, we know that the first form corresponds to an order issued by a law enforcement agency through the Sahyog Portal, while the second rests on no legal order at all. The account restrictions described in this post cite only the IT Rules. Several other users received no communication at all.

The practice is not new. In April 2026, [The Hindu reported](https://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/technology/meta-sets-up-automatic-blocking-for-govt-police-referred-content/article70901931.ece?ref=static.internetfreedom.in) that Meta automatically restricts content flagged by the government and the police in India, at scale, and seeks a separate government direction before restoring content that it later finds to be legally unsupported. IFF wrote to Meta objecting to this on 4 May 2026. Instagram used the same “*automated system*” notice against Anjali Priya, Varnika Dhawan and Sachin Gupta after the July protests, and against cartoonist Satish Acharya, who lost nine cartoons and then his account between February and September 2026. This month, the accounts of journalists reporting on protests have been restricted while those protests are under way.

# Four accounts, four legal notices

Four of the journalists affected sought our assistance, and legal notices were later sent to Meta on their behalf. The facts recorded in those notices are summarised below.

|**Account**|**Followers when restricted**|**Posts made unavailable**|**Account restricted**|**Complaint closed within**|**Status on 20 October**|
|:-|:-|:-|:-|:-|:-|
|Utkarsh Gaur (@utkarshgaurpodcasts)|about 4.7 lakh|Two on 3 October; one on 9 October|9 October|2 minutes|Restored|
|Sunny Tomar (@sunnytomar06)|about 1.05 lakh|Two on 2 October; two more on 6 and 9 October|9 October|3 minutes|Restored|
|Shubhangi Dasgupta (@shubhangi\_decodes)|about 37,900|Two, on 11 and 12 October|12 October|3 minutes|Restored|
|Journo Mirror (@journomirror)|about 5.36 lakh|Not recorded in the notice|12 October|4 minutes|Restored|

In three of the four cases, posts reporting on the protests were made unavailable first, and the whole account followed within days. On 12 October 2026, Shubhangi Dasgupta’s post on X captioned “*Current at Barakhamba road*” was also withheld in India, on a “*legal request*” stated to be “*based on local laws*”. 

# Complaints closed in minutes

Each of the four complained to Meta’s Grievance Officer, which proved harder than the IT Rules contemplate. Meta’s Help Centre names its Grievance Officer for India and gives an email address, but confines that address to “*questions about the grievance redressal mechanism process*”, and complaints sent to it are not acknowledged. Complaints “*regarding violations of Meta’s Terms of Service, Facebook’s Community Standards or questions about accounts*” are directed instead to a [web form](https://help.meta.com/requests/1371776380779082/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in) titled “Indian Grievance Officer Complaint”. None of the form’s six categories allows a user to complain that their own content or account has been restricted, and the form requires the complainant to declare “*a good-faith belief that the content you are reporting is unlawful*”. On the list of Grievance Officers maintained on the portal of the Grievance Appellate Committee, nine of eleven entries, including WhatsApp, give an email address; against Instagram and Facebook, there is only this form. Meta’s in-app appeal covers only decisions under its Community Standards.

All four nonetheless filed grievances through the form, under the nearest available category, “*I’ve lost access to a page or a group that I used to manage*”. Each complaint was registered with the assurance that “*We will look into your matter shortly*”. Each was closed within two to four minutes by an email that described itself as “*a no-reply message*”, stated that “*we can’t support this type of request through this channel*”, and gave no reason beyond a direction to “*Visit the Help Center*”.

# MeitY’s advisory to Meta

On 10 October 2026, the day the Delhi Police detained protesters and journalists at demonstrations called over the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, the Cyber Laws Division of the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) issued an advisory to Meta bearing File No. 6(2)/2026-Cyberlaws. It was not published on MeitY’s website. The [Hindustan Times](https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/centre-asks-meta-to-review-content-recommendation-system-over-law-and-order-posts-to-avoid-public-confusion-disorder-101792262032757.html?ref=static.internetfreedom.in), and then [the Press Trust of India](https://www.deccanherald.com/india/govt-asks-meta-to-ensure-its-recommendation-systems-dont-expose-users-to-a-limited-set-of-narratives-4187445?ref=static.internetfreedom.in), reported it on 18 October. It followed, by two days, an advisory of 8 October to all social media intermediaries that called for “enhanced diligence” over content on “ongoing public events”, asked platforms to “label or add context” to misleading content, and to “give priority to complaints from authorised Government agencies”. IFF [called for the withdrawal of that advisory](https://internetfreedom.in/meitys-enhanced-diligence-advisory-pressures-platforms-to-police-protest-speech-it-must-be-withdrawn/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in) on 9 October.

The advisory states that content relating to “ongoing public events and developments”, including “videos, images, statements and static graphics relating to public-order and law-and-order situations”, is being “prominently displayed and recommended” on Meta’s platforms, and that such content, “when presented without adequate context or disproportionately amplified through recommendation mechanisms, may contribute to public confusion, apprehension and disturbance of public order and social tranquillity” (para 1). It advises Meta to “exercise enhanced diligence” over content surfaced through its feeds, “particularly during periods of heightened public-order sensitivity”, giving “particular attention” to content that “contains unverified or misleading claims regarding the imposition of emergency, restrictions, police action or other official measures” (para 3). It asks Meta to review its “recommendation and content-ranking mechanisms”, to ensure that its recommendation systems “do not result in disproportionate exposure of users to a single or limited set of narratives”, to strengthen the “rapid identification, review and escalation” of content gaining reach, and to ensure “timely cooperation with law-enforcement and other authorised Government agencies, including furnishing information or assistance” (para 4). Meta is to act “with immediate effect” and to “apprise the Ministry of the measures undertaken” (para 7). PTI reports that, according to IT Ministry sources, the Ministry “had reports from agencies that Meta platforms were not promoting all narratives equally”.

The four accounts are not alone. On 10 October, the Instagram account of Molitics India was withheld in India. On 11 October, a Mathrubhumi English reel showing a woman clinging to a pole as police officers attempted to detain her was restricted, citing “*a notice from the Government of India/Law Enforcement*”, and a video report by Observer Post Hindi was restricted on Facebook by what Meta called an “*automated system*” acting under the IT Rules. The account of Fridays For Future India has since been withheld without any stated reason.

# Analysis

# No provision of the IT Rules requires an entire account to be restricted

Meta told users in India that these accounts had been restricted “*pursuant to legal requirements*” under the IT Rules. No provision of the IT Rules requires the restriction of an entire account. Under Section 79(3)(b) of the IT Act, as read down in *Shreya Singhal v. Union of India*, and Rule 3(1)(d) of the IT Rules, as substituted on 22 October 2025 and amended on 10 February 2026, an intermediary acquires actual knowledge only through a court order or a reasoned written intimation from an authorised senior officer “*clearly specifying the legal basis and statutory provision invoked, the nature of the unlawful act, and the specific uniform resource locator*” of the information to be removed. The obligation attaches to specific unlawful information. The IT Rules define a “*user account*” separately, in Rule 2(1)(y), and Rule 3(1)(c)(i) links the suspension of a user’s access to non-compliance with the platform’s own rules, privacy policy or user agreement, which no one has alleged against these journalists.

That leaves three possibilities, and on none of them is the restriction lawful as carried out. If Meta acted on an intimation under Rule 3(1)(d), it could restrict only the URLs specified in it; being bound by Rule 3(1)(n) to respect Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution, it could not give effect to an intimation that demanded more; and no law bars it from showing that intimation to the account holder. If Meta acted on its own, Rule 4(8) required it to give the user prior notice with reasons and an opportunity to dispute the action, and it gave none. If it acted on a blocking direction under Section 69A, its attribution of the restriction to the IT Rules is plainly incorrect, and the account holder was denied the hearing contemplated by Rule 8 of the Information Technology (Procedure and Safeguards for Blocking for Access of Information by Public) Rules, 2009.

# Restriction by “automated system” inverts Shreya Singhal

The question of who decides what is unlawful online was answered on 24 March 2015, when the Supreme Court decided *Shreya Singhal* v. *Union of India* \[(2015) 5 SCC 1\]. Among the questions before the Court was the validity of the IT Rules, 2011 (since replaced by the IT Rules, 2021). Rule 3(4) of the 2011 Rules, read with Rule 3(2), required an intermediary, “*upon* ***obtaining knowledge by itself*** *or been brought to actual knowledge by an affected person in writing or through email signed with electronic signature*”, to act within thirty-six hours to disable the information. This placed the burden on the intermediary itself to judge what was unlawful, and to take it down, as and when it came to its notice.

The petitioners argued that the rule required the intermediary to “*exercise its own judgement under sub-rule(4) and then disable information that is in contravention of sub-rule(2)*”. The Court noted that “*The Intermediary applying its own mind to whether information should or should not be blocked is noticeably absent in Section 69-A read with the 2009 Rules*”. Reading down Section 79(3)(b), it reasoned that “*otherwise it would be very difficult for intermediaries like Google, Facebook, etc. to act when millions of requests are made and the intermediary is then to judge as to which of such requests are legitimate and which are not.*” On the 2011 Rules, it held that “***The knowledge spoken of in the said sub-rule must only be through the medium of a court order.*** *Subject to this, the Information Technology (Intermediaries Guidelines) Rules, 2011 are valid.*” In its operative conclusions, the Court read down both Section 79(3)(b) and Rule 3(4) to mean that an intermediary is obliged to act only upon a court order, or upon being notified by the appropriate government or its agency, and only in respect of unlawful acts relatable to Article 19(2). An intermediary that restricts content without such an order is applying its own terms, not a legal requirement.

An “*automated system implemented pursuant to legal requirements*”, which is how Meta has described restrictions such as the one on Observer Post Hindi’s video report, is the intermediary applying its own mind to what the law requires, at scale and in code. That is the very judgment *Shreya Singhal* said intermediaries could not be expected to make. Where the IT Rules speak of automated tools, they concern specified categories of content: Rule 3(3) deals with synthetically generated information, and Rule 4(4) with depictions of rape and child sexual abuse and with content identical to content already removed under Rule 3(1)(d), which presupposes a valid intimation in the first place. None of those categories describes a journalist’s report of a protest, and Meta has not claimed that any of the restricted content was synthetic.

The same judgment tested Section 66-A of the IT Act, 2000 against various tests of law. Of these, the test of “*Chilling effect and overbreadth*” \[paras 87 to 94\] is the most relevant here. Automated tools are not perfect. They are code written by a significant social media intermediary that would rather be over-cautious and be seen to comply than ask whether the Constitution permits the restriction at all. Content that is unlawful may be restricted, by the procedure the law prescribes. That cannot come at the expense of innocent speech, and a journalist’s report of a protest is innocent speech.

>“***94****. …We, therefore, hold that the section is unconstitutional also on the ground that it takes within its sweep protected speech and speech that is innocent in nature and is liable therefore to be used in such a way as to have a chilling effect on free speech and would, therefore, have to be struck down on the ground of overbreadth.*”

(Emphasis Supplied)

Restricting an entire account is overbroad in exactly this sense. Even where an authority has validly identified a post as unlawful, Rule 3(1)(d) permits action against that post alone. Withholding the account withholds every other post with it, and operates as a prior restraint on all of the journalist’s future reporting. The freedom of the press extends to expression over the internet and may be restricted only by law, on a ground under Article 19(2), and proportionately, as the Supreme Court held in *Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India* \[(2020) 3 SCC 637\]. A restriction that names no law cannot meet that standard.

# An advisory is not law

MeitY’s advisory to Meta is neither a blocking direction under Section 69A of the IT Act nor an intimation under Section 79(3)(b) read with Rule 3(1)(d). It identifies no URL, and it cites no provision of the IT Act or the IT Rules empowering the Ministry to issue it, because none does. Its own text concedes as much: it asks Meta to ensure that “*any action taken pursuant to this advisory is consistent with the Information Technology Act, 2000, the IT Rules, 2021 and other applicable laws*” (para 6). An advisory that confers no power cannot be relied upon to restrict what the law does not otherwise permit. Yet it is framed as an instruction, to be carried out “*with immediate effect*” and reported back to the Ministry (para 7).

What the advisory asks of Meta also goes beyond Article 19(2). In *Shreya Singhal*, the Supreme Court held that speech may be restricted in the interest of public order only where it has a proximate connection with public disorder, and struck down Section 66A because the “*annoyance*” and “*inconvenience*” it penalised bore no such connection. “*Public confusion*” and “*apprehension*”, which the advisory invokes, are of the same kind. The advisory singles out “*unverified or misleading claims*” about “*police action*” for particular attention. During a protest, the report most likely to be called unverified is the one the police dispute, and reporting on police action at a protest is the core of what a free press does.

The advisory then moves from content to curation. It asks Meta to ensure that its recommendation systems “*do not result in disproportionate exposure of users to a single or limited set of narratives*” (para 4(d)), and PTI’s report tells us why: agencies had told the Ministry that Meta’s platforms “*were not promoting all narratives equally*”. It is not for the State to decide how far each account of a protest against the State should travel. Downranking also leaves no trace. A journalist whose reach is reduced under paragraph 4 will not receive even the one-line notice the four account holders did, and will have nothing to take to a Grievance Officer or a court.

We cannot say which of the restrictions described above, if any, Meta made because of the advisories. Posts were being withheld from 2 October, before either advisory was issued. Two of the four accounts were restricted on 9 October, the day after MeitY’s advisory to all intermediaries, and the other two on 12 October, two days after its advisory to Meta. Neither Meta nor MeitY has disclosed what Meta has done under the advisory, or what it has reported to the Ministry under paragraph 7. Even with their accounts back, the people affected cannot tell whether they were restricted on a police intimation, by Meta’s own systems, or in response to an unpublished letter from a Ministry. That uncertainty is itself the injury, because it leaves them nothing to challenge.

# The grievance process has been rendered illusory

Rule 3(2)(a) of the IT Rules obliges an intermediary to publish the contact details of its Grievance Officer and a “*mechanism by which a user or a victim may make complaint*”, and requires the Grievance Officer to acknowledge every complaint within twenty-four hours and resolve it within seven days. Rule 4(6

## retained text (truncated)



```
# tl;dr

Since the start of October 2026, journalists and news creators reporting on the protests in Delhi have had their Instagram posts and, in several cases, their entire accounts withheld in India, with a one-line notice that cites the IT Rules, 2021 as a whole and names no provision, authority, order or offending post. Their complaints to Meta’s Grievance Officer were closed within two to four minutes. On 15 October 2026, legal notices were sent to Meta, with IFF’s assistance, on behalf of four of them. All four accounts were restored on 19 and 20 October 2026, without any clear notification from Meta and without any explanation of why they were restricted. All of this is happening alongside an unpublished MeitY advisory of 10 October 2026 that asks Meta for “*enhanced diligence*” over content on “*ongoing public events*” and to ensure that its recommendation systems do not result in “*disproportionate exposure of users to a single or limited set of narratives*”. We explain why the restrictions are unlawful, why Meta’s grievance process has failed, and what we are asking of Meta and MeitY.

# Background

# The restrictions

Since the first week of October 2026, independent journalists and news creators reporting on the protests in Delhi have found their Instagram posts made unavailable in India and, in several cases, their entire accounts restricted. Each account, once restricted, displayed to users in India the same statement: “*We temporarily restricted access to this account pursuant to legal requirements under India’s Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules.*” The statement does not disclose the provision invoked, the authority at whose instance Meta acted, the content said to be unlawful, or how long the restriction would last. Meta’s notifications to the account holders, including some that described the action as a “*suspension*”, came from a “*no-reply*” address that admits no response. The four account holders whose cases we set out below have received no order or notice from any authority, and none of them was heard before the restriction.

The notices that users have shared with us take two forms. Some state that Meta acted on “*a notice from the Government of India/Law Enforcement under Section 79(3)(b)*”. Others state that the content was restricted “*through an automated system implemented pursuant to legal requirements under India’s Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules*”. Neither names the issuing agency, the order, the provision of law or offence the content is said to disclose, or the URL complained of. From our litigation, we know that the first form corresponds to an order issued by a law enforcement agency through the Sahyog Portal, while the second rests on no legal order at all. The account restrictions described in this post cite only the IT Rules. Several other users received no communication at all.

The practice is not new. In April 2026, [The Hindu reported](https://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/technology/meta-sets-up-automatic-blocking-for-govt-police-referred-content/article70901931.ece?ref=static.internetfreedom.in) that Meta automatically restricts content flagged by the government and the police in India, at scale, and seeks a separate government direction before restoring content that it later finds to be legally unsupported. IFF wrote to Meta objecting to this on 4 May 2026. Instagram used the same “*automated system*” notice against Anjali Priya, Varnika Dhawan and Sachin Gupta after the July protests, and against cartoonist Satish Acharya, who lost nine cartoons and then his account between February and September 2026. This month, the accounts of journalists reporting on protests have been restricted while those protests are under way.

# Four accounts, four legal notices

Four of the journalists affected sought our assistance, and legal notices were later sent to Meta on their behalf. The facts recorded in those notices are summarised below.

|**Account**|**Followers when restricted**|**Posts made unavailable**|**Account restricted**|**Complaint closed within**|**Status on 20 October**|
|:-|:-|:-|:-|:-|:-|
|Utkarsh Gaur (@utkarshgaurpodcasts)|about 4.7 lakh|Two on 3 October; one on 9 October|9 October|2 minutes|Restored|
|Sunny Tomar (@sunnytomar06)|about 1.05 lakh|Two on 2 October; two more on 6 and 9 October|9 October|3 minutes|Restored|
|Shubhangi Dasgupta (@shubhangi\_decodes)|about 37,900|Two, on 11 and 12 October|12 October|3 minutes|Restored|
|Journo Mirror (@journomirror)|about 5.36 lakh|Not recorded in the notice|12 October|4 minutes|Restored|

In three of the four cases, posts reporting on the protests were made unavailable first, and the whole account followed within days. On 12 October 2026, Shubhangi Dasgupta’s post on X captioned “*Current at Barakhamba road*” was also withheld in India, on a “*legal request*” stated to be “*based on local laws*”. 

# Complaints closed in minutes

Each of the four complained to Meta’s Grievance Officer, which proved harder than the IT Rules contemplate. Meta’s Help Centre names its Grievance Officer for India and gives an email address, but confines that address to “*questions about the grievance redressal mechanism process*”, and complaints sent to it are not acknowledged. Complaints “*regarding violations of Meta’s Terms of Service, Facebook’s Community Standards or questions about accounts*” are directed instead to a [web form](https://help.meta.com/requests/1371776380779082/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in) titled “Indian Grievance Officer Complaint”. None of the form’s six categories allows a user to complain that their own content or account has been restricted, and the form requires the complainant to declare “*a good-faith belief that the content you are reporting is unlawful*”. On the list of Grievance Officers maintained on the portal of the Grievance Appellate Committee, nine of eleven entries, including WhatsApp, give an email address; against Instagram and Facebook, there is only this form. Meta’s in-app appeal covers only decisions under its Community Standards.

All four nonetheless filed grievances through the form, under the nearest available category, “*I’ve lost access to a page or a group that I used to manage*”. Each complaint was registered with the assurance that “*We will look into your matter shortly*”. Each was closed within two to four minutes by an email that described itself as “*a no-reply message*”, stated that “*we can’t support this type of request through this channel*”, and gave no reason beyond a direction to “*Visit the Help Center*”.

# MeitY’s advisory to Meta

On 10 October 2026, the day the Delhi Police detained protesters and journalists at demonstrations called over the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, the Cyber Laws Division of the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) issued an advisory to Meta bearing File No. 6(2)/2026-Cyberlaws. It was not published on MeitY’s website. The [Hindustan Times](https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/centre-asks-meta-to-review-content-recommendation-system-over-law-and-order-posts-to-avoid-public-confusion-disorder-101792262032757.html?ref=static.internetfreedom.in), and then [the Press Trust of India](https://www.deccanherald.com/india/govt-asks-meta-to-ensure-its-recommendation-systems-dont-expose-users-to-a-limited-set-of-narratives-4187445?ref=static.internetfreedom.in), reported it on 18 October. It followed, by two days, an advisory of 8 October to all social media intermediaries that called for “enhanced diligence” over content on “ongoing public events”, asked platforms to “label or add context” to misleading content, and to “give priority to complaints from authorised Government agencies”. IFF [called for the withdrawal of that advisory](https://internetfreedom.in/meitys-enhanced-diligence-advisory-pressures-platforms-to-police-protest-speech-it-must-be-withdrawn/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in) on 9 October.

The advisory states that content relating to “ongoing public events and developments”, including “videos, images, statements and static graphics relating to public-order and law-and-order situations”, is being “prominently displayed and recommended” on Meta’s platforms, and that such content, “when presented without adequate context or disproportionately amplified through recommendation mechanisms, may contribute to public confusion, apprehension and disturbance of public order and social tranquillity” (para 1). It advises Meta to “exercise enhanced diligence” over content surfaced through its feeds, “particularly during periods of heightened public-order sensitivity”, giving “particular attention” to content that “contains unverified or misleading claims regarding the imposition of emergency, restrictions, police action or other official measures” (para 3). It asks Meta to review its “recommendation and content-ranking mechanisms”, to ensure that its recommendation systems “do not result in disproportionate exposure of users to a single or limited set of narratives”, to strengthen the “rapid identification, review and escalation” of content gaining reach, and to ensure “timely cooperation with law-enforcement and other authorised Government agencies, including furnishing information or assistance” (para 4). Meta is to act “with immediate effect” and to “apprise the Ministry of the measures undertaken” (para 7). PTI reports that, according to IT Ministry sources, the Ministry “had reports from agencies that Meta platforms were not promoting all narratives equally”.

The four accounts are not alone. On 10 October, the Instagram account of Molitics India was withheld in India. On 11 October, a Mathrubhumi English reel showing a woman clinging to a pole as police officers attempted to detain her was restricted, citing “*a notice from the Government of India/Law Enforcement*”, and a video report by Observer Post Hindi was restricted on Facebook by what Meta called an “*automated system*” acting under the IT Rules. The account of Fridays For Future India has since been withheld without any stated reason.

# Analysis

# No provision of the IT Rules requires an entire account to be restricted

Meta told users in India that these accounts had been restricted “*pursuant to legal requirements*” under the IT Rules. No provision of the IT Rules requires the restriction of an entire account. Under Section 79(3)(b) of the IT Act, as read down in *Shreya Singhal v. Union of India*, and Rule 3(1)(d) of the IT Rules, as substituted on 22 October 2025 and amended on 10 February 2026, an intermediary acquires actual knowledge only through a court order or a reasoned written intimation from an authorised senior officer “*clearly specifying the legal basis and statutory provision invoked, the nature of the unlawful act, and the specific uniform resource locator*” of the information to be removed. The obligation attaches to specific unlawful information. The IT Rules define a “*user account*” separately, in Rule 2(1)(y), and Rule 3(1)(c)(i) links the suspension of a user’s access to non-compliance with the platform’s own rules, privacy policy or user agreement, which no one has alleged against these journalists.

That leaves three possibilities, and on none of them is the restriction lawful as carried out. If Meta acted on an intimation under Rule 3(1)(d), it could restrict only the URLs specified in it; being bound by Rule 3(1)(n) to respect Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution, it could not give effect to an intimation that demanded more; and no law bars it from showing that intimation to the account holder. If Meta acted on its own, Rule 4(8) required it to give the user prior notice with reasons and an opportunity to dispute the action, and it gave none. If it acted on a blocking direction under Section 69A, its attribution of the restriction to the IT Rules is plainly incorrect, 
```



document fetched 2026-10-24 10:29 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/india/comments/1xdd4yd/instagram_restores_four_protest_reporters
