# Why can’t India become a superpower! — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:india.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/5e2fbe60c25a9961

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:india)  published 2026-11-03 12:25 ingested 2026-11-04 02:38

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/india/comments/1xmrlje/why_cant_india_become_a_superpower/)

## retained text



```
**Why Can’t India Become a Superpower?**  
Naturally, this question is bound to provoke many patriotic Indians.  
However, let us temporarily set patriotism aside and examine the issue through the lens of facts and reality.  
**What is the most important factor that truly makes a country a superpower?**  
It is technological dominance.  
Technological advancements in weaponry enabled European nations to conquer much of the world and establish colonies across continents.  
With the invention of gunpowder-powered firearms, they gained a leading position in military technology.  
What happened afterwards is history.  
The invention of machines powered by energy, followed by the Industrial Revolution, enabled the Western world to make rapid economic and cultural progress.  
**How did the United States become a superpower?**  
Primarily through its technological superiority.  
Almost all the major technologies the world relies on today originated in the United States, with many others originating in Europe.  
**How did Japan become a major economic powerhouse within just 30 years after World War II?**  
Through significant advances in engineering, Japan captured major shares of the global automobile and electronics markets.  
**How did China become a superpower?**  
Much like Japan, China made tremendous technological advances in critical sectors. Once a country with a GDP smaller than India’s, China has now emerged as a global superpower.  
What can we learn from all this?  
Only a country that promotes science and technology, and encourages its people to acquire knowledge, explore new possibilities, and develop new technologies, can become a superpower.  
**What happens in these countries?**  
Their largest corporations invest heavily in science and technology.  
They allocate a significant portion of their revenue to Research and Development (R&D).  
Consider major American companies such as Nvidia and Google.  
They continuously invest in innovation, improving their existing technologies and developing new ones.  
Now, look at some of India’s largest business groups, such as Reliance and the Adani Group.  
They are not known for developing globally dominant foundational technologies of their own. Instead, much of their business activity involves using technologies developed by companies in Western countries or China.  
Understand the enormous difference between these two approaches.  
One involves creating fundamental knowledge and developing foundational technologies.  
The other primarily involves trading and commercial activity.  
Extracting oil from the ground, refining it, adding value, and selling it as various products is business.  
But developing the technologies and equipment used in that process is an achievement of science and engineering.  
Only when a country has an advantage in the latter can its companies truly help transform that country into a superpower.  
How can India become a major military power when it does not even independently manufacture a world-class fighter aircraft without relying heavily on foreign technology and suppliers?  
It is simply not possible.  
Therefore, India should only dream of becoming a superpower when the country and its private corporations develop a mindset of investing substantial amounts in Research and Development.  
However, for the government and private companies to invest heavily in R&D, they must have confidence in the scientific mindset of the country’s people and their ability to create new knowledge.  
Otherwise, such investments could end up becoming financial losses.  
Why do Indian companies, and even the Indian state itself, seem to have doubts about the capabilities of their own citizens in this regard, often holding back from making such investments?  
One of the main reasons is that, deep down, we recognise that ours is a society held captive by beliefs, traditions, and rituals.  
Even among highly educated people with impressive academic qualifications, there are those who walk around with the foolish notion that our ancestors possessed technologies far more advanced than anything we have today.  
Naturally, investors find it difficult to expect much from a society that embraces such ideas.  
Even investors themselves may share similar beliefs, but the awareness that they are risking their own money makes them hesitate before committing large investments.  
It is the realisation that knowledge was limited in the past that motivates a member of the Homo sapiens species to pursue new and modern knowledge.  
Otherwise, instead of exploring new scientific possibilities, people will continue searching for technological miracles in ancient manuscripts or in mantras and rituals passed down through generations without even understanding their original meanings.  
They end up wasting their wealth, energy, time, and intellectual potential on futile pursuits.  
For a country with such a mindset, achieving technological superiority becomes extremely difficult.  
All it can do is celebrate the number of Rafale fighter jets it has purchased from France and feel immensely proud of the acquisition.  
But it will struggle to independently develop and manufacture a fighter aircraft superior to the Rafale.  
Consequently, it cannot become a greater air power than France, a much smaller country.  
But China can.  
Because China has developed the capacity to compete with the world and establish its own technological dominance.  
A society that refuses to question established beliefs, abandon unfounded convictions, and understand its past realistically rather than through romanticised narratives can only remain dependent on societies that take the opposite approach.
```



document fetched 2026-11-04 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/india/comments/1xmrlje/why_cant_india_become_a_superpower
