# About substituting generated steam capsules with human made — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:gamedev.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/76938c0719fd8f64

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:gamedev)  published 2026-10-24 14:19 ingested 2026-10-25 02:36

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xe9vly/about_substituting_generated_steam_capsules_with/)

## retained text



```
Hhey guys I'd like to vent a little about something that is happening for a while now and I think it is worth at least trying to bring it up to discussion.

I'm a 2D artist working on games for 4 years now and the past two i've been getting steam capsule commissions. Recently i've been receiving more and more e-mails from devs that just want to substitute their AI generated capsule with some art "because apparently players hate it". When they talk about the game on the email, it always is something that doesn't relate at all with anything on my portfolio and it gives a huge impression that they just mass emailed a bunch of artists and will take the fastest/cheapest option. Most times games described on the e-mail are also most likely vibe-coded or their art/ui is also fully generated and there is not a single thought on art direction.

I think we can all agree that marketing a game is something important and way too critical late stage production to mess up. And as most devs rely a lot on steam for their success it is counter intuitive to me that someone would choose a low effort un-thought path to do it. When i look at the massive list of steam next fest, it also very clear to me how generic ai flooded the store is and to generate your way into it is very unlikely a success path. I also think that it is very interesting as a dev to see what are the good reviews of games of the genre you are developing. In most indie environments, I see something about how much care and thought through development the team put into it. To me it is very clear that once we are not working with AAA budget, the premium - hand made feel is what makes it stand.

It is also really clear to me that **comparing your cheapest-quickest capsule to an AI generated one** , although it is trendy to ask other devs about it, does not address the issue that you are blending with a sea of generic low effort/badly executed games that players will most likely overlook. That you will most likely not get a good feedback from people that is only looking at the capsules

**If your capsule is AI**: a big chunk of people will not click (something that you should probably know by now)

**if it is handmade but doesn't match the art direction of the game**, or the game is full of AI assets: it will give a wrong first impression and players will be displeased.

be aware that in the second case, it could be either a super cool and expensive capsule from that premium artist that has no other connection to the game or something from an inexperienced artist that makes everything feel cheap.

**Not to say that it is offensive** that they think that I would be ok with using my work to hide the fact that your game is AI. To send to me your prompt (sometimes even with other companies or artists on the keywords) on the e-mail. that supper low-balling the service on the first e-mail is going to give you a truly good deal to your game. That they clearly cold emailed me and didn't even typed my name on it.

Anyway I'm tired of answering these emails professionally and trying to give any input on why this is a bad approach to game dev as a whole. Sadly I feel like more and more my services as an artist are being considered something premium. I hope that these guys are not substituting real interesting games and devs, they are just adding noise.

eddit: many grammar and spell mistakes sorry
```



document fetched 2026-10-25 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xe9vly/about_substituting_generated_steam_capsules_with
