# $40 trillion in debt: Republican policy is bad for the economy and working people. Here are the sourced receipts — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:economy.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/97b31cddba4c96e0

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:economy)  published 2026-11-15 20:38 ingested 2026-11-16 02:39

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/economy/comments/1xx6356/40_trillion_in_debt_republican_policy_is_bad_for/)

## retained text



```
# $40 trillion in debt: Republican policy is bad for the economy and working people. Here are the bills.

I keep seeing "both parties spend" every time the debt comes up. So I went through the actual bills. Who wrote them, whether there was an emergency, and whether anyone paid for them.

My rule: emergency spending counts as emergency spending, no matter which party passed it. Take that out and see what's left.

**What Republicans passed with no emergency and no way to pay for it**

- The Bush tax cuts (2001, 2003) plus Trump's 2017 tax cuts: about $10 trillion added to the debt through 2023. That includes the 2012 extension, more on that below.
- Iraq and Afghanistan: trillions, almost all borrowed. No war tax. Korea and Vietnam both came with tax increases to help pay for them. These didn't.
- Medicare Part D (2003): GOP Congress, Bush signed it, never paid for.
- The 2025 "Big Beautiful Bill": CBO says $4.7 trillion more through 2035. CBO also says it raises interest rates enough that it costs more than the sticker price. It doesn't pay for itself.

None of these were forced by a crisis. Somebody chose them.

One stat from the Center for American Progress: if you take out the one-time costs of COVID and the 2008 recession, the Bush and Trump tax cuts are more than 90% of the rise in debt as a share of the economy since 2001.

**The 2008 crash**

The commission Congress set up to investigate the crash pointed to two big things: mortgage standards falling apart and Wall Street derivatives with no oversight.

Derivatives: in 2000 Phil Gramm (R-TX) stuck the Commodity Futures Modernization Act into a huge spending bill. It basically took derivatives out from under any regulator. The commission called it a key turning point on the way to the crisis. Clinton's Treasury backed it and Clinton signed it, so Democrats don't get a pass. But Republicans wrote it.

Mortgages: by 2004 more than 30 states had passed laws against predatory lending. Bush's bank regulators overrode them and exempted national banks. Researchers found that kicked off a race to the bottom in lending.

Then it all blew up. Tax revenue cratered, unemployment went through the roof, and the debt went with it.

**What Democrats passed**

- Recovery Act (2009): about $830 billion. That was the response to the worst crash since the Depression.
- Affordable Care Act (2010): CBO has always scored it as reducing the deficit.
- American Rescue Plan (2021): $2.1 trillion. Pandemic.
- Inflation Reduction Act (2022): CBO said it cuts the deficit by $238 billion.

So the big Democratic bills that added debt were emergency responses, and their two biggest non-emergency laws cut the deficit.

**Trump's COVID money: where did it go?**

COVID was a real emergency, I'm not knocking that. But look at where the business money ended up.

PPP was sold as saving paychecks. An MIT study (David Autor and others) found only 23 to 34 percent of it went to workers whose jobs were actually saved. The rest went to owners and shareholders. About three quarters of the benefit went to the top 20% of households.

Then Congress let businesses deduct the expenses PPP had already covered. That cost about $100 billion and some companies ended up with a negative tax rate.

The stimulus checks and the extra unemployment did the opposite. Most of that money reached the bottom 80%. The parts aimed at regular people helped regular people. The parts aimed at owners helped owners.

**TARP**

The bank bailout passed with votes from both parties and ended up costing about $33 billion net. The bailout wasn't what hurt the budget. The crash was.

**"But Republicans are better for the economy"**

The record says otherwise. Two Princeton economists, Alan Blinder and Mark Watson, looked at every president from Truman through Obama's first term:

- GDP grew 4.3% a year under Democrats vs 2.5% under Republicans.
- Unemployment fell 0.8 points on average under Democrats and rose 1.1 points under Republicans.
- 10 of the 11 recessions between 1953 and 2020 started under Republican presidents.

To be fair, Blinder and Watson say a lot of that gap comes down to luck, like oil shocks and productivity swings, and presidents don't control the economy by themselves. I'm not claiming Democrats magically create growth. But if Republicans were really better for the economy, you'd expect it to show up somewhere in 70 years of data. It doesn't.

**Where Democrats share the blame**

I'm not going to pretend they're clean.

In 2012 Obama signed the deal that made 82% of the Bush tax cuts permanent. The Senate passed it 89 to 8.

How he got there matters though. In 2010 Republicans blocked legislation until the Bush tax cuts got extended, and Obama traded a two year extension for unemployment benefits. In 2011 they held the debt ceiling hostage and he signed automatic spending cuts to avoid a default. By the end of 2012 both of those deadlines landed at the same time, the "fiscal cliff," and CBO was projecting another recession if nothing passed. He kept the cuts for the middle class and got the top rate back up to 39.6% on income over $400K.

Add Clinton signing the derivatives law, and plenty of Democrats voting for the Iraq war. Republicans wrote the tax cuts and drove the deregulation. Democrats went along more than they should have.

**Then there's interest**

We're now paying over $1 trillion a year in interest. Only Social Security costs more. Every tax cut nobody paid for and every war on credit keeps costing us interest every single year.

**Bottom line**

Take out the emergencies and what's left is tax cuts tilted to the top, Part D, wars nobody paid for, and a crash that deregulation helped cause. We don't have a spending problem so much as a revenue problem with a war bill, a crash bill and an interest bill stacked on top.

So next time somebody says "both parties spend" or "Republicans are better for the economy," you've got the receipts.

---

Sources:

- [Blinder & Watson: Presidents and the US Economy (NBER)](https://www.nber.org/papers/w20324)
- [Jeffrey Frankel (Harvard) on the Blinder-Watson findings](https://www.belfercenter.org/publication/does-economy-really-do-better-under-democratic-presidents)
- [CAP: Tax cuts are primarily responsible for the increasing debt ratio](https://www.americanprogress.org/article/tax-cuts-are-primarily-responsible-for-the-increasing-debt-ratio/)
- [CBPP: Bush tax cuts and wars drive deficits](https://www.cbpp.org/research/economic-downturn-and-legacy-of-bush-policies-continue-to-drive-large-deficits)
- [CRFB: Trump and Biden debt by bill](https://www.crfb.org/papers/trump-vs-biden-national-debt)
- [CRFB: What's in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act](https://www.crfb.org/blogs/whats-one-big-beautiful-bill-act)
- [CRFB: CBO scores IRA with $238B deficit reduction](https://www.crfb.org/blogs/cbo-scores-ira-238-billion-deficit-reduction)
- [CBPP: ACA still reduces deficits](https://cbpp.org/blog/affordable-care-act-still-reduces-deficits-despite-tax-repeals)
- [CBO: Recovery Act total cost](https://cbo.gov/publication/49958)
- [POGO on the 2000 derivatives law (cites the FCIC)](https://www.pogo.org/analysis/how-clinton-team-thwarted-effort-to-regulate-derivatives)
- [NBC: Bush administration blocked state predatory lending laws](https://www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/wbna27121535)
- [UNC study on 2004 preemption and foreclosures](https://ourfinancialsecurity.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/UNC-CCC-Preemption-Effect-Impact-of-Federal-Preemption-on-Foreclosure-Crisis.pdf)
- [Autor et al., NBER: Where did the PPP money go?](https://www.nber.org/papers/w29669)
- [CBPP: 2012 deal made 82% of Bush tax cuts permanent](https://cbpp.org/research/budget-deal-makes-permanent-82-percent-of-president-bushs-tax-cuts)
- [Timeline of the 2010–2013 budget fights](https://nationalpriorities.org/analysis/2014/history-us-federal-budget-2011-2013/)
- [PolitiFact on Medicare Part D](https://politifact.com/factchecks/2010/dec/07/bobby-scott/bobby-scott-says-republicans-created-1-trillion-pr/)
- [NPR: debt passes $40T, interest now 2nd biggest expense](https://www.kuow.org/npr-news/2026-08-19/the-u-s-debt-tops-a-record-shattering-40-trillion-yes-with-a-t)
```



document fetched 2026-11-16 00:38 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/economy/comments/1xx6356/40_trillion_in_debt_republican_policy_is_bad_for
