# Follow-up: Tested the stuff from your comments on my 100+ strategies post (and found a mistake in my own test) — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:algotrading.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/99148cca0f1ff9df

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:algotrading)  published 2026-10-12 16:28 ingested 2026-10-13 02:42

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/algotrading/comments/1x46igq/followup_tested_the_stuff_from_your_comments_on/)

## retained text



```
A bunch of you asked things i couldnt answer without testing so i tested them. same setup as before, next open fills, costs, random entries as baseline, design and test periods, and a second script that rebuilds every result.

**is the momentum edge just beta?**

u/QuanTradin asked this and he was mostly right. in the 39 months SPY went down my momentum stocks went down exactly the same, -3.83% vs -3.83%. all the extra came in up months (+4.67% vs +3.40%). beta is 1.26 and what's left after adjusting for it isnt significant (t 1.14), and a lot of it is 2020 (+90%) and 2024-26. 2022 looks good on paper (-6.8% vs -18.7%) but thats which months it caught, not protection.

**same dates survivorship check**

u/traderpier pointed out my two runs had different windows. reran both on the exact same dates, Sep 2015 to Jul 2026 (the end of the delisted-stock dataset). SPY now comes out the same in both (15.2 vs 15.3) so the windows match.

* stocks listed today only: 21.0% a year, +5.8 over SPY
* with delisted stocks: 18.6% a year, +3.4 over SPY

so dead companies were worth about 2.4 points a year, more than the 5.3 vs 4.3 i said in the comments. most of the difference is 2020 alone (51% vs 35%).

**the "work zone" rule from** u/Cool_Big2955

his rules: above 50 SMA and 200 EMA, close in the bottom 30% of the 20 day range, 2% bounce off the 3 day low, no earnings within 7 days, ATR trailing stop, -8% hard stop.

2021-2026: 5,323 trades, 33% winners, profit factor 1.01, about +0.05% a trade after costs and negative if costs are a bit higher. worst trade -72%, stocks gapping straight through the -8% stop. a 10 position cash account lost 5.3% a year while SPY made 15.4%. 2014-2020 looked great but that was mostly 736 trades in the 2020 rebound.

and the mistake. my pre-registered random baseline actually said it passed. the audit caught that my random entries included days before each signal, and those days are always followed by the drop into the zone, so random was set up to lose. with fair baselines (random stocks on the same day, or same stock only after the signal) it fails. if you use random entries, only pick days after the signal.

not saying his live results are wrong, i couldnt test the news filter and had to guess the ATR multiple. but the rule as written doesnt hold up.

**volume filter on momentum** (only buy if 20 day avg volume is 1.4x the 60 day)

this one failed hard. only about 5% of liquid stocks pass it, so to fill 30 spots it digs into weak momentum names and meme stocks. momentum went from +25%/yr to about -2%, drawdown from -43% to -73%, and trades went up not down. a couple of comments claimed big improvements with this, i couldnt get anywhere close.

**TQQQ** (u/j_lyf)

simulated 3x QQQ back to 1999, it matches real TQQQ since 2010 at 0.999 correlation. buy and hold since 1999: 4.5% a year with a -99.9% wipeout in 2000-02, vs 10.9% for plain QQQ. with a 200 day filter 12.7% a year but still a -95% drawdown. if your backtest starts in 2010 you only see the bull market.

**how the 3 that held up do in bad times**

the momentum + SPY blend dropped -34% in covid and was back in \~3 months, but then spent 1,028 days under its old high (Feb 2021 to Dec 2023), longer than SPY's 708. the SPY dip rule's worst drop was only -12.7% but it took up to \~3.5 years to make a new high, though it's been 70-72% winners in every era since 1993. month-end trade worst drop -15%, 4 losing years out of 34, weaker since 2010. honestly the slow grinds bother me more than the crashes, and momentum is the one i trust least.

also u/Maleficent-Success-6, the fill logging is done. every signal gets logged when it fires, then the actual open fill, the gap and the outcome. anything logged after the fill is flagged so it cant count. will share when theres enough data.

next up is whether DCF fair values actually predict returns, rules written before running. if you have a strategy you want tested the same way drop it below.

https://preview.redd.it/5i0dhzbic2vh1.png?width=3584&format=png&auto=webp&s=3fef2c0852f647d316f18e2da0a1e716d5dde554


```



document fetched 2026-10-13 00:45 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/algotrading/comments/1x46igq/followup_tested_the_stuff_from_your_comments_on
