# Why it’s bad to trade frequently (even if we ignore transaction fees and the difference between short vs long term capital gains) — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:stocks.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/a3c2b68603c201f4

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:stocks)  published 2026-10-13 04:44 ingested 2026-10-14 02:40

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/stocks/comments/1x4nkjn/why_its_bad_to_trade_frequently_even_if_we_ignore/)

## retained text



```
For a long time, I assumed the following two scenarios are mathematically equivalent (ignoring transaction fees and assuming only long term capital gains applies):  
\- buying a position, holding it for a long time, then selling it for a gain  
\- buying a position, selling mid way through then buying it back at the same share price as the sale, then holding it the rest of the way then sell

The reason my intuition said these scenarios should have the identical outcome is because you’ll eventually need to pay taxes on all of the gains anyway, what’s the difference of recognizing a portion of the gains early?

A few days ago, I wanted to check my intuition, so I came up with a thought experiment. For ease of explanation, let’s say capital gains tax is a flat 20%.  
\- scenario 1: buy $100 of a stock, it doubles, I hold, then it doubles again, I sell for a total of $400. I pay $60 in tax (20% x $300), so I end up with $340.  
\- scenario 2: buy $100 of a stock, it doubles, I sell for a total of $200, pay $20 in tax, then use the remaining $180 to buy it back at the same share price as the sale. It then doubles again, I sell for a total of $360, pay $36 in tax, and end up with $324.

If you repeat this experiment with other tax rates, the two scenarios are identical only when the tax rate is 0% or 100%, and for any other tax rate between these two extremes, scenario 1 comes out ahead.

This result may be intuitive to some, but it wasn’t to me. This really made me appreciate just how much of an uphill battle it would be if you wanted to beat the market by trading.

**Edit to address some common responses:**  
\- “your scenarios aren’t realistic!” - My scenarios are set up without the complication of other factors so it can illustrate the factor I’m trying to explain. The second scenario making an extra sell then buy at identical share price is the only way to make them directly comparable.  
\- “scenario 2 could have reinvested the entire $200!” - No it couldn’t have. If you don’t set money aside for taxes, you’re either relying on having other cash on the sidelines which isn’t part of the scenario (and, it probably would’ve been better if you invested that cash to begin with), or you’re having to sell a part of your portfolio by the tax due date, exposing yourself to more volatility risk. In the US you must pay quarterly estimated taxes if your investment gains exceed your regular withholding from your W2 job, so the upside of reinvesting money that should’ve been set aside for taxes is 0-3 more months in the market, but also with volatility risk.
```



document fetched 2026-10-14 00:33 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/stocks/comments/1x4nkjn/why_its_bad_to_trade_frequently_even_if_we_ignore
