# Upgrade or downgrade? You tell me. — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:homelab.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/bc7e8fad9aedcd36

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:homelab)  published 2026-10-31 21:18 ingested 2026-11-01 02:39

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/homelab/comments/1xklnxw/upgrade_or_downgrade_you_tell_me/)

## retained text



```
In September 2019, I found r/homelab and was a couple years into my IT career. Thoughts of creating my own network, virtual labs for learning new skills, Kali Linux to break things, full of dreams.

I mounted a board in the basement. Bought a Dell Poweredge R510 and filled it with 40TB (10x4TB) drives and got a HP switch. Thought I was cool and took an old laptop screen and a converter board and mounted that too. Gave myself a foldable keyboard tray but never did a mouse pad/tray for some reason.

I installed Hyper-V on the R510. Managed from my desktop upstairs. Installed PfSense VM, VMs for Win XP thru Win 10, couple Linux VMs, raid 6 on the drives, added an extra 4 gigabit network adapter and more RAM.

Decided to use some storage for the wife's obsession with taking photos of the kid and installed 4 x 4k security cameras around the house. Installed BlueIris on a Win10 VM to manage the camera needs with 24/7 4k recording (not motion). Always has video quality issues and found it to be a lack of GPU processing acceleration but not willing to buy a fix that would have worked with R510.

Found out I hate PfSense firewall rules. Still can't wrap my brain around where, how, zone which....

Isolated storage networks, security network, wireless networks, LAN networks, VPN network, lab network, etc. It was a pain.

Tried some syslogging learning with graylog, didn't like it. Thought about setting up alerting and monitoring also, never did. 

Then promotions at work took all the time and dreams. Lost interest in learning how to pen test and build out more tools and stuff. Ended up just shutting down all those VMs. Then the HP switch just up and died on me. So I just said f it and put in a TpLink dumb switch.

So for last 6 years, I had a power hungry overkill R510 server spinning away to run a firewall, NAS, VDR, and a crypto HDD storage project on the spare storage the wife wasn't using. The crypto project paid for the power until they basically gave up and filed for bankruptcy this summer.

So now I have overkill and no use. I decided to downgrade with the focus on power. I repurposed a PI 4b and a 10TB Ironwolf drive in a dock for the wife's photos using OMV. Bought a Dell Optiplex 7060 for BlueIris min requirements and added the second 10TB Ironwolf to that. Video quality was totally resolved.  HDDs were used for the crypto project so no costs there.

To replace the PfSense firewall, now that I don't have an externally exposed port for crypto project, I got a TpLink Omada firewall and VPN box. Spent a day building out the config and was able to rip out the PfSense from the network first try. Got my network segmentation back finally too.

So now I have the POE switch top left to power the cameras, the 7060 for camera OS and storage top right, shelf holding the PI 4b and HDD middle left, dumb switch for hardwired LAN only, Omada firewall mid right, and the laptop monitor bottom right. Powered off the R510 today. Will be doing power comparisons this weekend to see if what I did worked or not.

I estimated I would be atleast 50% the power.

Now to wipe the R510 and see if it still have resale value. If interested DM me. 
```



document fetched 2026-11-01 00:32 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/homelab/comments/1xklnxw/upgrade_or_downgrade_you_tell_me
