# 2k wishlists in 11 months. $0 marketing budget. Here's what worked, and what didn't. — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:gamedev.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/c37069064054c603

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:gamedev)  published 2026-09-09 17:02 ingested 2026-09-10 02:38

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1wbres4/2k_wishlists_in_11_months_0_marketing_budget/)

## retained text



```
My first game, *Ballisticards*, recently hit the milestone of 2000 wishlists, something that seemed impossible to me when I launched the Steam page 11 months ago. Here's a breakdown of the things that worked, with numbers, and things that didn't work.

# The Big Jumps

(Link to the wishlist graph in the comment below)

**A)** **Steam page launch**. **\~580 wishlists**, driven by Reddit. The Steam page featured a "lightweight trailer" (90 secs, only 6 different clips). Posted on Godot subreddit. Followed this with some memes on SoloDevelopment and IndieDev subreddits. 233k views total, for a conversion rate of 0.25%.

**B)** Featured in official **Godot 2025 Showreel** (for which I applied). **\~250 wishlists**, driven by the video and my Reddit post about it.

**C)** **Random X post**. **\~160 wishlists**, driven by X. Unbeknownst to me, an X user (@jettelly) posted my lightweight trailer on X (40k views). I didn't have an X account at that time, so I didn't reply with a direct Steam store link, which likely would have increased the conversion rate.

**D)** **Proper announce trailer,** increased social media presence (started using Instagram, X, YT Shorts, TikTok). **\~130 wishlists**, primarily driven by Reddit and Facebook. Posted on IndieGames and Roguelites subreddits.

**E)** **Improved announce trailer. \~400 wishlists**, driven by X, Instagram, and Reddit.

* I abandoned the strict narrative of "introducing the complexity bit by bit" and added a clip of some later-game chaos within the first 3 seconds. I also sped up the footage (and subsequently increased the gameplay speed to match).
* The minor changes above helped the trailer post really take off in X and Instagram (\~40k and \~80k views, respectively, despite my new accounts with \~0 followers). While there was \~2x engagement on Instagram, X had \~2x the conversions. Conversion rates: X was 0.5%, Instagram was 0.125%.
* On the Reddit side, \~60 wishlists from posting on Nubby's Number Factory (another ball-dropping roguelike) subreddit (with permission from the mods!), with a 1.3% conversion rate. A smaller, but much more targeted, audience.

**The Rest:** I tried to keep up with posting on the above-mentioned platforms (Reddit, X, Instagram). Posts that didn't go viral still drove some wishlists. You can see from the graph in the comment below that the steady growth picked up after (D), which is where I started using X and Instagram.

# Things That Didn't Work

* **Press outreach**. At steps (D) and (E) I did reach out to a number of press websites big and small(ish), broad and targeted. Got no responses from anyone. Perhaps I should have kept trying and held off my announcement until one of the big guys (e.g., IGN) was willing to post it (since they like *exclusive* posting), but I was too impatient for that.
* **TikTok**. I could write a whole post about this. In fact I wrote several posts about this. There's some serious issues these days with accounts being "shadow banned", which happened to me (*twice!*). I will leave it at that; you can check my other posts if you want to know more.
* **YouTube Shorts**. Some of the videos got an ok amount of views (>1k), but engagement was low and I didn't see much evidence of wishlist conversions.
   * The short-format (portrait orientation) format worked a little better on Instagram, with some videos with \~2k views, but ultimately none of these went viral like my trailer did.
* **Posting on gaming subreddit**. Got removed by mods, citing Reddit's 1-in-10 rule. I tracked my promo-vs-non-promo post ratio (since Reddit provides no tool for this), and I was just under 10%. The mod explained to me how they enforce this rule in practice.
   * The mods look at your *most recent posts*. Since I was in "game announce mode", most of my *recent* posts were about my game. Which basically destroyed the "credit" I earned with my prior non-promo posts.
   * The mods consider *anything showing content from my game* to be promotional. Even if it's a post legitimately asking for help/feedback/etc.

# Lessons Learned

I still feel like I'm fumbling through the marketing side of things, but I'll share a few non-expert opinions here.

* **Steam page**: worth getting it up early, so you can start collecting those wishlists. Some things will happen without you even trying (e.g., a random content creator will feature your game), so you want to be prepared.
* **Reddit**: posting about milestones can be effective. My other posts (e.g., devlogs), not so much. So save your Reddit posts about your game for those big milestones (e.g., demo launch, full launch).
* **Trailer quality** matters, but also... it's not everything. I have contradicting data here. The engagement difference between (D) and (E) (due to trailer quality) was significant. But it's also interesting to see that my biggest chunk of wishlists still came from (A) (my announcement on Reddit with a not-so-great trailer). *Game quality* (i.e., does it look interesting/fun-to-play) is likely more important than *trailer quality* (is it well-edited, etc.).
* **Localization**: yes, yes, I need to add some other languages to my Steam page, and I'm dragging my feet here.
```



document fetched 2026-09-10 00:28 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1wbres4/2k_wishlists_in_11_months_0_marketing_budget
