# ICLR position paper criticized for lacking experiments and making speculative claims — how to respond? [D] — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:MachineLearning.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/c52cb30e70a0fc64

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:MachineLearning)  published 2026-11-07 01:36 ingested 2026-11-08 02:37

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/1xpu5g0/iclr_position_paper_criticized_for_lacking/)

## retained text



```
One reviewer criticizes it for lacking an implemented system, empirical validation, results and for making speculative arguments. But its a position/argumentative paper, it doesnt have to have any of those. We provide technical arguments, falsifiable hypotheses, and other contributions, and ICLR has accepted position papers before.

The only way to answer I can think of is some variation of "Hey man this is what a position paper is. And ICLR has precedent in allowing position papers like ours. These things you mentioned arent weaknesses, they are characteristics of a position paper."  
But I fear that may sound too combative or rude, but cant think how else to answer
```



document fetched 2026-11-08 00:24 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/1xpu5g0/iclr_position_paper_criticized_for_lacking
