# How much do you let players define your game? — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:gamedev.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/c9bcdd0bf95b374b

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:gamedev)  published 2026-09-29 17:31 ingested 2026-09-30 02:39

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1wtgh8k/how_much_do_you_let_players_define_your_game/)

## retained text



```
I'm interested to hear from other devs about their experience with playtester feedback and the impact it had on the design of their games. Do you take all feedback with a large grain of salt and focus on your core vision? Do you heavily listen to feedback and shape the game towards it, even if it goes against your vision? What are some experiences you've had in the past?

I'm asking this because while working on my newest game MineEmAll (an incremental mining game), I did a bunch of competitor analysis before I even started working on the game to figure out what my design philosophy would be. I ended up culminating my analysis into a design doc with a large list of dos and don'ts for designing the game.

One of the big "don'ts" was to have manual clicking dominate the gameplay. Several incremental games end up becoming exhausting when you have to spam click over and over. I decided that I'd have automation right off the bat, and that would make the game more appealing.

However, after initial playtests, I got a lot of feedback that the lack of clicking felt less interactive. I changed automation to be an unlock you can acquire early on, but I got some more push back from that as well. I made it an upgrade later on, and I've now just completely removed it since it doesn't fit the new direction of the game (my reasoning is in the next section).

My game uses a grid system and you mine tiles using the shape of your miner. One of the main aspects people were enjoying while playtesting was the sort of reverse block puzzle of punching holes with the different shapes. However, the automation was making that harder to pull off, so I added a control to pause the automation with right click (and eventually just toggle it on and off with spacebar).

In the end though, it just seemed better to not have automation at all, make the shapes more interesting and random (tetromino, pentomino, hexomino, etc.), and rebalance the game to be a lot slower paced instead of a fast ramping grind fest.

This is very different approach from my previous game RoGlass where I had a clear vision and stuck to it. Playtesters had suggested gameplay loops that heavily deviated from my vision and while I think that those ideas could have worked, I stuck to my guns to make the game I had in mind.

After having done both sides of the process, I think there is merit to both approaches, but I'm curious to hear about experiences other devs have had!

Edit: Definitely a lot of interesting conversations about design philosophy, but I'd really like to hear anecdotes/stories of your own experiences and how it played out for you!
```



document fetched 2026-09-30 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1wtgh8k/how_much_do_you_let_players_define_your_game
