# Help Deciding Between Google and Startup Offer — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:sales.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/d114b05b90c19e09

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:sales)  published 2026-10-28 20:09 ingested 2026-10-29 02:39

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/sales/comments/1xhz1q5/help_deciding_between_google_and_startup_offer/)

## retained text



```
Hey all, 3 years into my career as a SaaS AE at a big company oft-mentioned in this sub and I have just received two offers this week. PLEASE SDRs refrain from giving me advice lol. If possible, in your response it would help me weigh the advice I receive if you give me an idea of your YOE and role. I need help! Good problem to have and am beyond excited to finally leave my shitty company but am not sure what to do.

**Google Offer** **- Account Strategist (Google Ads not GCP)**

Account management role covering 50 accounts focused on revenue expansion and product adoption. This is a Google Ads role, not Google Cloud, so I won't be selling LLM or cloud infra or anything.

>*Base: 106k*

>*Commission: 37k @ 100% of quota*

>*Stock: 10k per year*

>*OTE: 150-160k per year (stock vesting schedule is irregular)*

Main pro here for me is the brand name. Google has a ton of perks and internal mobility. It seems stable, most people hit quota (validated with people I know there), and people generally like the role. Not a super high-pressure toxic environment, but hitting quota is the expectation.

Cons: would be hard to pivot back into SaaS. Is this really a con? I kind of hate SaaS, but I have only ever sold ERP which is notorious for being a total pain in the ass, other SaaS seems "easier." I'm not totally sure where Google Ads sellers end up after a few years, but being at Google is in and of itself a good and cushy option. The OTE is also lower than the startup offer, but the base is higher with stock that is guaranteed worth something. I can't imagine that this would be a bad option for my career.

**Start-up Offer: Gov-Tech SaaS Account Executive**

So this is an interesting one - they take everything at face value, don't want to get too detailed and dox myself. They are a 30-person company that provide an AI native product for the public sector, but only 20% go through RFP - mostly they are below threshold with 3-4 month deal cycles. Lots of procurement paths with this product, but its still gov so of course decisions are bureaucratic. The product has very, very few competitors - really just one. Other than that they compete with the status quo which is far more expensive and painful, which is why they're getting so much traction. The product market fit is proven. They've *10xed* their customer count in the last year and need an AE to cover their most lucrative territory.

I really like the founder and CRO. Vibes seem good, the employees are very credentialed.

They recently raised a seed at a valuation over $40M. Equity grant looks to be about 0.042% of the total company, pending confirmation.

>*Base: 95k*

>*Variable/Commission: 95k*

>*Equity: 0.042%\~ @ 40M+ valuation*

*OTE: 190k*

Most of the AEs are hitting their number and closing 5-7 deals per quarter, average win rate is 40-50%, average contract value is around 50k. I am speaking with two of the AEs one on one to vet the opportunity and ensure that quality of life is good. But again, the CRO is a chiller and seems to be a good manager. Overall the leaders seem genuine, competent, and kind.

My quota would be $1M. I would hopefully hit at least enough to match the Google OTE. Average cycles as I mentioned are about 3-4 months long but can stretch to 6-12 months. I think my job is safe even if I hit 75-80% which I think is realistic. I need to close 20 deals to hit quota, since average deal is about 50k.

I am frankly leaning toward this company when it comes to everything except for the 1M quota which seems like a stretch and the .042% equity which I also feel like is low given the company is 30 people. That would a $42,000 payout at $100M liquidity event, but likely lower after dilutions. This part I'm pretty stuck on, I feel like I should be getting at least around 0.07-0.1% equity but also I don't know jack about start ups and wouldn't know where to start in negotiating that.

Any tips on if this is fair equity and how to negotiate higher?

**Things to consider**

In terms of my preference, the start up -- with its strong PMF, major referenceable customers referenceable in my territory, plenty of greenfield, and which is solving a crucial problem with very little competition -- is really attractive for me. I feel like I'll learn way more than just managing existing customers and slinging Google Ads in Big Tech again. Google Ads might pigeonhole me out of SaaS forever, and I'm not too concerned about the start up pigeonholing me into Gov Tech just because I feel like the skills needed in it are comparable to B2B SaaS and if I really wanted to I'm sure I could find a way to switch back into B2B private sales.

So what are your thoughts? and how should I go about negotiating up my equity portion with the start up?

\*\*EDIT\*\* One thing I didn't mention is that the Google offer has not been provisioned in writing - I passed the interviews with great feedback and the recruiter said the offer letter would come in December for an April start date. Sounds weird and suspicious but this happened to my friend and other i know of and it worked out fine, it's a Google bureaucracy and headcount planning thing. I am technically called a finalist and will be notified when a spot opens up. If I wanted a different office that has spots, I would have the offer letter this week but I am waiting on my preferred location
```



document fetched 2026-10-29 00:30 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/sales/comments/1xhz1q5/help_deciding_between_google_and_startup_offer
