# Jonas Tyroller's "design is a search" video is great. I tested the one part I had data for: where to put your boat. Hits happen where hits already are. — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:gamedev.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/d6245f175247e37c

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:gamedev)  published 2026-11-01 10:49 ingested 2026-11-02 02:38

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xl036i/jonas_tyrollers_design_is_a_search_video_is_great/)

## retained text



```
Chart: [https://steammaho.com/static/charts/hits-around-you-2026-11.png](https://steammaho.com/static/charts/hits-around-you-2026-11.png)

If you haven't seen Jonas Tyroller's video on game design as a search, watch it first, it's one of the best things I've seen on how to think about what to make. The point that stuck with me: you are not building, you are searching, and the search gets stuck in places that feel fine from the inside. I have been stuck in exactly such a place and his video is what got me to look up. Everyone building a game should watch it, especially the part about not just making what you think is cool.

He has a metaphor I liked: making a game is a boat on a lake searching for the deepest spot, and successful games are other boats. His advice is to be near them but give them plenty of space. I had the data to check that one part, so I did. For every paid Steam game released since 2023 I took the 10 games most like it by gameplay, and counted how many of those were already hits (1,000+ reviews) when it came out.

First the version of his claim. Distance to the nearest earlier hit, with the share that reached 1,000 reviews:

|Nearest earlier hit is...|Games|Reached 1,000 reviews|
|:-|:-|:-|
|nowhere in the 10 closest|1,695|3 in 100|
|far|5,113|10 in 100|
|some distance|5,613|12 in 100|
|near|5,839|12 in 100|
|right on top|6,145|10 in 100|

The sweet spot he describes exists, but it's a bump of one or two points. What actually moves the number is how many hits are around you, not how close the nearest one is:

|Earlier hits among the 10 closest games|Games|Reached 1,000 reviews|
|:-|:-|:-|
|none|1,695|3 in 100|
|1 to 2|8,910|6 in 100|
|3 to 4|8,645|10 in 100|
|5 to 6|3,971|18 in 100|
|7 to 10|1,164|37 in 100|

The obvious objection is that games surrounded by hits are made by studios that already had one. So here it is for first-time studios only, nobody with an earlier game above 1,000 peak players:

|Earlier hits among the 10 closest games|First-time studios|Reached 1,000 reviews|Studios with an earlier hit|Reached 1,000 reviews|
|:-|:-|:-|:-|:-|
|none|1,522|2 in 100|63|16 in 100|
|1 to 2|7,661|3 in 100|480|30 in 100|
|3 to 4|6,988|5 in 100|743|39 in 100|
|5 to 6|2,942|9 in 100|540|54 in 100|
|7 to 10|694|17 in 100|322|76 in 100|

Same slope for both. A first-time studio making the kind of game that already has seven hits around it reached 1,000 reviews 17 times in 100. Making a kind of game with no hit near it: 2 in 100.

How I read it: "space" is the wrong word. Hits around you mean there are players who want this kind of game and they know how to find it. Empty water mostly means nobody is fishing there. The small bump for "near but not on top" is real but it's the second-order thing.

Small print: hits are counted as of today, so a neighbour that became a hit after your game still counts, which flatters the crowded rows a little. "Most like it" is by what you do in the game, not by look or theme, and comes from a model reading store pages and reviews, so some are wrong. Only games I have gameplay data on, which needs a few reviews. What goes together, not what causes what: a crowded shelf may also be a splace where more good teams go.
```



document fetched 2026-11-02 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xl036i/jonas_tyrollers_design_is_a_search_video_is_great
