# Netflix (NFLX): the P/E of 18 includes a $2.8B one-off break-up fee from Warner Bros. Without it: 21. — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:ValueInvesting.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/d6ce919cde476469

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:ValueInvesting)  published 2026-11-16 19:57 ingested 2026-11-17 02:42

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xxzga3/netflix_nflx_the_pe_of_18_includes_a_28b_oneoff/)

## retained text



```
Netflix did not pop up on the automatic radar (i.e. the filters I used for the screener), but as a direct user I've always been curious about the business so I decided to give it a proper look. My "GBL" method (a Graham/Buffett/Lynch checklist) gives a quality score of 66% - pretty high! - and then I saw the price drop consistently this year. Might we be on to something?

Netflix's last twelve months of profit, $14.8B, include $2.8B that Warner Bros. Discovery paid it in the first quarter, after WBD declared Paramount's offer superior and Netflix stepped aside. That money did not come from subscribers and it's a one-off. With it, the P/E is 18 and the free cash flow yield on most screens is 9.8%; **without it, the P/E is 21 and the yield is 4%**. The stock fell from **$134** in June 2025 to **$62** at the close on Friday, November 13, which is **54% lower**, and the screens tell you the drop made it cheap. Let's check together if that's true. 

The slowdown behind the drop is all in the shareholder letters --> **Revenue growth went 17.6%, 16.2%, 13.4%, 11.8%,** and Netflix guides **11.5%** for the fourth quarter. On October 20 it also **cut** its 2026 advertising target from $3B to $2.7B, and the shares lost two days in a row. **Hours watched grew 2% in the first half while revenue per hour grew 12% or 13%,** so price increases are carrying the growth. Nielsen has Netflix at 7.7% of US television time in August, with YouTube at 15.8%. From 2027 the company will publish its viewing report once a year, which means the number that worries investors will be harder to follow.

**How do I look at the price**:

* I start from the $12B of free cash flow Netflix guides for 2026 and take out the fee after tax ($2.25B). Then I add back two one-off payments that pulled the guidance down, a $729M tax deposit in Brazil and a $500M real estate deal.
* Then I subtract $540M a year of stock pay, because buybacks have to cover it with real cash. That leaves $10.45B.
* With growth of 11% a year for five years and a discount rate of 10%, a share is worth $56.6. The Monte Carlo median is $57, and 41% of 20,000 runs land above the price.
* At the $62 of November 3, the market was paying for growth of 12.7% a year, 1.7 points above the 11% I get when I build revenue (9% a year) and margin (35.5% by 2031) one piece at a time.

The other side of that is the 2027 earnings estimate, $3.80 a share: If it materializes, the stock trades at 16x, which is low for a business with a 36% ROC. It would need 24% more earnings than my 2026 figure, though. The range from my models is $47 to $81, and the price sits inside it.

Which basically says: Netflix is properly valued by the market, hey. Which does not mean the price can't go either way, but there's no "magnet" P50 that would draw it upwards.

**My own range for potential pitfalls is wide:**

* The Monte Carlo P10 is 47% below the price, at $33. In the bad story hours stay flat, churn rises after the next price increase and revenue grows 5% or 6%, which my report puts at $40 to $42.
* The "good story" has advertising above $4B, a margin heading to 38% and a DCF of $67 to $75.
* Insiders have not bought on the open market in any of the 158 Forms 4 filed this year, and the executives and directors together own 1.24%.
* The bigger risk is capital allocation: Netflix planned $70B of debt for Warner Bros., and net debt today is 0.46 times operating profit.

**Three tests would change the story, and I have the robots check them every month:**

1. **Revenue growth under 6.5%** for two quarters,
2. **operating margin under 22%** for two quarters,
3. or **net debt above 1.5 times operating profit**.

All of them hold today, and the next real test is January 19, 2027, when Netflix reports the fourth quarter and gives 2027 guidance.

If hours watched keep rising 2% a year, how much price rise can a subscription take? I mean, is this even sustainable? I personally stopped watching Netflix (or Prime, or anything else) in 2026 because I found a more destructive vice - Warren Buffett's letters to shareholders seem to occupy most of my free time now. **What's your take on streaming services?**

*Of course: this is analysis, not investment advice.*
```



document fetched 2026-11-17 00:44 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xxzga3/netflix_nflx_the_pe_of_18_includes_a_28b_oneoff
