# 3.4 million people just handed Meta an agent with the keys to their inbox, calendar and bank. I'm building the version that never leaves the phone. — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:artificial.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/d8d5e3cab24f3fa6

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:artificial)  published 2026-09-26 16:33 ingested 2026-09-27 02:35

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/artificial/comments/1wquwvv/34_million_people_just_handed_meta_an_agent_with/)

## retained text



```
Two weeks ago Meta launched Muse. It's #1 on the App Store and Google Play, 3.4 million downloads, growing faster than ChatGPT did. It books, buys, negotiates your internet bill, reads your email, and it comes with a cream-coloured doll avatar called Jolly and a Tamagotchi keychain. Zuckerberg's is called Agrippa and wears a toga.

It's genuinely good. So was Instinct in August, right up until people read the terms: a "perpetual and irrevocable" license to your data (revised after the screenshots), an inbox summary emailed three hours after the user had revoked access, an agent that followed instructions planted in an email.

Muse learned from that. It runs each agent on a "Muse Secure VM", a dedicated computer in Meta's cloud, with a second agent gating network access. Meta says a "Confidential VM" where even Meta can't look is planned. Planned. And your queries feed Meta's models by default; the switch is in the settings.

Here's my problem with the whole Muse-vs-Instinct debate: it's a debate about whose computer your life lives on. Meta's or a startup's. Sandboxed or not. Training on by default or opt-out.

I'd rather there wasn't a computer.

So I'm building the same agent with the opposite architecture:

\- **The model, the memory and the index live on your phone.** It reads your messages, files and calendar there. It nudges you there: "your dad wrote two days ago, you never answered, here's a reply."

\- **Per app, you choose Read / Draft / Send**. Start with Read.

\- **Internet is off by default**. When a task needs it, it asks. Once.

\- **Our server holds four things**: your email, your seat number, whether your subscription is active, the app version. That's the whole database. It's printed on the landing page, in a card, because it fits in a card. Nothing to sandbox, nothing to leak, nothing to subpoena, nothing to train on.

It's early. 500 founding seats, first builds in a few days. Link in the first comment.

I'm not saying Meta is evil. I'm saying a cloud agent *has* to hold your life on a server to work, and everything else follows from that. Tell me where the on-device version breaks. That's why I'm here.
```



document fetched 2026-09-27 00:19 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/artificial/comments/1wquwvv/34_million_people_just_handed_meta_an_agent_with
