# How does the grid manage split-second solar/wind volatility? (Clouds, wind shocks, and the plan for zero baseload) — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:energy.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/d941ba7f0062ff00

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:energy)  published 2026-10-25 05:46 ingested 2026-10-26 02:39

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/energy/comments/1xeu9hb/how_does_the_grid_manage_splitsecond_solarwind/)

## retained text



```
Hey everyone,

I’m trying to understand how the physical grid handles massive, sudden renewable supply shocks that happen in a matter of seconds. Specifically, I want to map out what happens mechanically and financially when the weather changes instantly while consumer demand remains completely flat.

Furthermore, I am looking at how this fits into Australia's long-term plan to completely phase out traditional "baseload" power plants in favour of a flexible renewable grid backed by energy storage and gas backup plants.

I’ve broken this down into four distinct scenarios. I would love for any power systems engineers, utility control room operators, or market traders to explain exactly how the grid manages each step:

Scenario 1: The Cloud Cover Shock (Sudden Drop)

A massive cloud bank rolls over a huge solar farm, causing its power output to plummet by 70% in seconds.

* What happens in the first 1 to 2 seconds physically to stop the grid from crashing?
* How do the grid's safety systems instantly catch the drop before backup power can even turn on?
* What happens over the next few minutes to permanently bridge the gap if the cloud cover stays all afternoon?

Scenario 2: The Wind Drop (Sudden Lull)

A sudden, localized change in weather causes a massive cluster of wind turbines to completely lose their wind, causing power generation to fall off a cliff within a few seconds while demand stays steady.

* Is a sudden wind drop physically different for the grid than a solar cloud cover?
* Do spinning wind turbines have any natural physical momentum that helps smooth out the drop compared to solar panels, or does it trigger the exact same emergency response?

Scenario 3: The Wind Surge (Sudden Oversupply)

Conversely, a storm front hits, and wind production suddenly surges way up across multiple regions in a matter of minutes, but consumer demand remains completely flat and big batteries are already fully charged.

* How do the market and hardware handle a sudden, massive injection of unneeded power in real-time before it causes a major grid trip?
* Can modern wind turbines slow themselves down fast enough to stop an oversupply spike in seconds, or does the market operator have to step in and remotely force them offline?

Scenario 4: The 17GW Gas Target & The End of Baseload

Australia's future energy plan maps out a grid with zero traditional baseload power, replacing it with distributed renewables, batteries, pumped hydro, and a projected 17GW of gas capacity by 2050 used purely for backup.

* If there is no "baseload" share left for gas, how does this 17GW target function purely as an emergency safety net that spends most of its time turned off?
* How does the grid physically transition away from 24/7 baseload generation without exposing itself to severe multi-day shortfalls during extended winter periods with no sun and no wind?


```



document fetched 2026-10-26 00:34 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/energy/comments/1xeu9hb/how_does_the_grid_manage_splitsecond_solarwind
