# I built a C.AI alternative during its collapse. Hundreds of thousands of potential users, 126 signups, 0 customers. — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:SaaS.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/deaa45330b72ed19

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:SaaS)  published 2026-10-24 02:10 ingested 2026-10-24 10:58

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/SaaS/comments/1xdwnsa/i_built_a_cai_alternative_during_its_collapse/)

## retained text



```
My SaaS got 126 users in 2 weeks, but not a single person bought Pro. Then I realized something critical.  
  
It was an AI roleplay platform. I built it during a goldmine: the fall of [Character.AI](http://Character.AI), which was getting bashed massively over its updates, the legal stuff, the monetization, the greed, all of it.  
  
I locked in for a month to make a solid alternative. Then I launched and posted in every relevant subreddit I could like r/CharacterAIrunaways, r/CharacterAIrefugees, r/CAIRevolution. Combined, those communities had hundreds of thousands of people. Perfect timing, perfect audience, right?

Wrong. Nobody bought. Not one person.

I tweaked the monetization, reworked the plans, edited the pricing cues. Nothing. And since it’s an AI subscription, I couldn’t realistically survive on free trials either, because inference costs real money. (Plus a bunch of legal headaches on top, but that’s another post.)  
  
Then I finally figured out the real reason: **I was marketing to the wrong people.** 

* **The audience was mostly teens.** The reason they left [C.AI](http://C.AI) in the first place was the age verification. Either they were too young to pass it, or they cared way too much about privacy to hand over ID. Both of those are a problem for a paid product like mine.
* **They had endless free options.** There are hundreds of open-source, privacy-first roleplay apps. Why would anyone pay me when they can self-host or use something free?
* **A lot of them wanted the impossible.** Unlimited AI chats, no ads, no limits... and they expected the devs to survive on donations. That’s not a business model, that’s a charity.
* **They were angry at monetization itself.** I’d launched into a crowd that left a platform *because* of monetization. Putting a paywall in front of them was always going to feel like a betrayal, no matter how fair the price.

**The lesson:** a huge audience means nothing if it’s the wrong audience. Being angry at a competitor isn’t the same as being willing to pay for an alternative. People who leave a product over pricing and policy are often the *least* likely to become customers, not the most.

If I did it again, I’d validate willingness to pay before building anything, and I’d target adults who already pay for AI tools instead of whoever’s loudest on Reddit.

Anyone else here chased a “perfect timing” audience that turned out to be allergic to paying?


```



document fetched 2026-10-25 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/SaaS/comments/1xdwnsa/i_built_a_cai_alternative_during_its_collapse
