# An open letter to everyone asking "is this a good buy". — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:ValueInvesting.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/e1bf648515bdfa4d

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:ValueInvesting)  published 2026-11-18 21:48 ingested 2026-11-19 02:40

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xzrw1g/an_open_letter_to_everyone_asking_is_this_a_good/)

## retained text



```
Alright, slight rant. Hopefully useful to some of you newer folks out there.

And no, I'm not ignorant. I know this message will quickly disappear into the shadow realm never to be seen again, but if this subreddit can give us 1000 posts on Alphabet, surely, it can handle a single reminder from an older school value investor.

The stock price is the result of an aggregate weighing machine. If you see a stock drop after some news, it's because that new bad news has been incorporated based on the average money weighted average of the market. In other words, the market (or Mr. Market for you Graham fans) is always advising you what it thinks the appropriate valuation is for any relatively liquid stock. It's the "objective" consensus.

Legends like Buffett win because they move beyond consensus and are on average, in the ways that matter most, better at modelling the *reality of a business* when compared to the market or group (money weighted) consensus.

When you go onto a public forum and asking if something is a good buy, you're effectively recreating a poor approximation of the public consensus. You don't get anything really meaningful -- for those of you familiar with Efficient Market Hypothesis, this isn't an argument in favour of it, instead it's an observation on the mechanisms of pulling information from consensus.

**So if asking for a consensus of a stock is pretty much useless for a liquid asset, why does this subreddit even exist?**

Good question. To provide insights or ask questions that allow users to better think about the accuracy of their models when compared to consensus. It's an ideas mill to help expose you to new concepts and variables. At least that was the idea before the WSB and Robinhood lead to another mainstream surge in investing popularity. After all, this isn't the first time investing has been in vogue on Main Street, and certainly won't be the last.

There will always be competition philosophies. I don't claim to have the ultimate view on investment finance, but in the context of this subreddit's description, I do think this a fair one.
```



document fetched 2026-11-19 00:45 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xzrw1g/an_open_letter_to_everyone_asking_is_this_a_good
