# I backtested every SIP and lumpsum start month on NIFTY 50 since 2007. Lumpsum made more money, but SIP had the better yearly return 80% of the time over 15 years — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:indianstockmarket.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/f55b0b617a70d01d

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:indianstockmarket)  published 2026-11-14 10:28 ingested 2026-11-15 02:37

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/IndianStockMarket/comments/1xvz7x6/i_backtested_every_sip_and_lumpsum_start_month_on/)

## retained text



```
most sip vs lumpsum answers here use one start date so I ran every start month on nifty 50 instead. month end data from yahoo finance, sep 2007 to oct 2026. price index only so no dividends, expense ratio or tax (dividends would add maybe 1 to 1.5% a year to both so it doesn't change the comparison)

compared 10k a month sip vs 18L put in on day one, so same total money

latest 15 year window (oct 2011 to oct 2026) the sip ended at 40.1L and the lumpsum at 77.9L. but the yearly return was about 10.0% vs 10.3%, basically the same. took me a while to get why. the average rupee in the sip was only invested for around 7.5 years, the lumpsum money sat there all 15

then I ran it for every start month. over 3 years lumpsum ended with more money 90% of the time, 5 years 95%, 10 years 98%, 15 years every single time. but sip had the better yearly return 53% of the time at 3 years, 61% at 5, 65% at 10 and 80% at 15 (40 out of 50 windows). note the sip return is xirr and the lumpsum is cagr, so this compares return per rupee actually invested, not final money

typical 15 year result was around 11.9% a year for sip vs 10.7% for lumpsum. worst 15 year result was 9.9% for sip and 7.5% for lumpsum

big caveat though. every 15 year window in this data starts between 2007 and 2011, right around the 2008 crash when nifty fell 55%. a sip that starts before a crash keeps buying cheap so this flatters sip. calmer start years would probably shrink the gap

also sip is not safe short term. a 10k sip started oct 2023 had 3.6L put in and was worth 3.51L in oct 2026

I also tried the question that actually matters if you already have the money. 12L all at once vs 1L a month for 12 months with the rest sitting in a liquid fund at 6%. all at once came out ahead about 62 to 63% of the time over 5 and 10 years, usually by around 3%, and at 15 years it was basically 50/50. but when it lost it lost badly. starting dec 2007 and valued in oct 2026, all at once ended at 45.1L vs 65.6L for the slow way

so for salaried people sip vs lumpsum isn't really a choice, a sip is just how you invest a salary. if you already have a lump sum, putting it in soon usually wins by a bit and spreading it over 6 to 12 months saves you from the ugly cases

has anyone run this on a longer series like sensex from the 90s so the 15 year windows don't all start near 2008?
```



document fetched 2026-11-15 00:39 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndianStockMarket/comments/1xvz7x6/i_backtested_every_sip_and_lumpsum_start_month_on
