# ~4K wishlists vs 60K wishlists, same ~2,000 sales in week one. What is a wishlist actually worth today? — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:gamedev.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/f6dd1d8ec2c74759

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:gamedev)  published 2026-11-13 19:59 ingested 2026-11-14 02:37

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xvi1by/4k_wishlists_vs_60k_wishlists_same_2000_sales_in/)

## retained text



```
We got \~4K wishlists and sold 2,000+ copies in our first week of Early Access. Another dev recently shared that they had 60K wishlists and also sold \~2,000 copies at a similar pace. That made me wonder: what is a wishlist actually worth today?

Something that surprised us: less than half of our sales came from people who had wishlisted. Our wishlist conversion looks normal, but most buyers never wishlisted at all.

\-------

Here's my theory, built from years of making my own game, studying other launches and following the market.

**1. Novelty has a short shelf life.**

The other dev spent two years collecting wishlists. By launch day, the people who were excited at the start had probably moved on, and the "new cool game" feeling was gone. Our situation was the opposite: little visibility early on, then a demo during Next Fest and a release about a week later. Lots of people saw the game for the first time when it was already buyable.

Competition on Steam has never been this intense. Lots of games release every day, all fighting for the same players. Very few games build a loyal community that sticks around for years, so you can't count on people waiting for you. Building hype long in advance works well for big IPs, much less for an unknown indie game.

**2. Don't burn attention on "wishlist only".**

Everyone has a limited amount of attention to give your game. If most of it lands while the only possible action is "wishlist", you spent it on a number. The goal was never to collect wishlists. It's to sell the game. Be careful with your marketing beats and time them with moments when people can actually play: a playtest, a demo, or even better, when the game is buyable.

**3. Who is your buyer?**

People who scroll social media for new games are not always people who buy and play many games. We compete with movies, series and social media scrolling itself. The real buyers spend most of their time on Steam, buying and playing. A wishlist from them may be worth more than ten from doomscrollers who just liked the trailer.

**4. Quality over quantity.**

Steam rewards games people actually play. Fewer wishlists with a game people play beats many wishlists nobody converts. Wishlists are still a useful metric, and Steam's algorithm uses them to decide what to show. But if they don't turn into sales, Steam may start showing your game less.

People also tend to forget wishlist velocity: when you get your wishlists matters. A game that sells a lot and gets a lot of wishlists at the same time gets picked up and recommended more.

**5. Early previews burn people too.**

In our experience, someone who has played the game a lot once rarely comes back for the next round. They wait for a big release and sometimes forget. You can see it with playtests and demos: it's rare for players to come back for a second playtest or after a demo patch. Getting someone's attention a second time takes a big update or something that feels like a new game. That's why an Early Access launch or a 1.0 is often the big milestone that brings players back. If your milestone doesn't change that much, you might miss your goals, even with a big following.

\-------

What I take from all this: in today's market, a long hype window can work against you. I'd rather test quietly while the game is rough, then build the page, demo and release close together so the excitement carries straight into a purchase.

Curious whether you've seen the same.

**TL;DR:** My take: hype fades fast, so time your marketing with moments people can actually play or buy, and care about who wishlists and when, not just how many.
```



document fetched 2026-11-14 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xvi1by/4k_wishlists_vs_60k_wishlists_same_2000_sales_in
