# What if there was a fantasy RTS where two players command entire armies, but everyone else plays as heroes fighting in those armies? — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:gamedev.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/fcfa12951347a269

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:gamedev)  published 2026-11-11 03:22 ingested 2026-11-12 02:38

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xt75kj/what_if_there_was_a_fantasy_rts_where_two_players/)

## retained text



```
I’ve been thinking about a multiplayer game concept that combines Total War, League of Legends, Dynasty Warriors, and Chivalry.

The basic idea is that two teams fight over a massive fantasy battlefield. Each team has one player acting as the **Overlord**, who plays the game like a traditional RTS, while the remaining players control individual heroes fighting in first or third person.

**Here’s how I imagine it working:**  
**The Overlords (RTS gameplay)**  
Each team has one Overlord who controls the army from a top-down perspective. They build bases, gather resources, manage economy, recruit troops, research upgrades, and command hundreds of AI soldiers. They can organize infantry formations, send cavalry to flank enemies, construct siege equipment, and coordinate attacks across the battlefield. Essentially, they’re playing Total War or Age of Empires against the opposing Overlord.

**The Heroes (Action RPG gameplay)**  
Meanwhile, the other 5-10 players on each team are fighting directly on the battlefield.  
Players choose fantasy classes like Knights, Rangers, Battlemages, Assassins, Necromancers, or Healers.

Combat would feel something like Chivalry or Dynasty Warriors, with abilities and character progression inspired by League of Legends. Heroes would have their own gold, experience, abilities, and item builds. They could purchase weapons, armor, magical artifacts, and equipment throughout the match. A Knight could build into a tank, duelist, or battlefield commander. A Necromancer might specialize in raising undead soldiers, while a Ranger could focus on scouting and disrupting enemy supply lines.

**The part I find most interesting is how the two systems interact.**  
The Overlord could assign actual AI battalions to hero players. Imagine you’re playing a Knight, and your Overlord gives you command of 30 infantry and orders you to defend a bridge. You’d fight alongside your soldiers in first person, issue basic formation commands, and coordinate with other heroes. Meanwhile, the Overlord is managing the larger war. Or imagine your Overlord launches a massive frontal assault while you and two other heroes sneak behind enemy lines to destroy their siege equipment. Your small mission could completely change the outcome of a battle involving hundreds of soldiers.

**Matches would be longer, persistent wars.**  
I’m imagining 45–90 minute matches where both teams start with small settlements and gradually expand. You’d capture mines, villages, magical ruins, and strategic chokepoints to strengthen your economy and unlock more powerful units.  
Eventually, both sides would have massive armies, elite heroes with completed item builds, siege engines, and fortified castles. The ultimate goal would be to destroy the enemy Citadel.

**The biggest design challenge would probably be balancing the two experiences.**  
You wouldn’t want heroes to become so powerful that the AI armies are irrelevant. But you also wouldn’t want the heroes to feel like insignificant soldiers in someone else’s RTS game. Ideally, a brilliant Overlord with terrible heroes could lose, and a team of amazing heroes with a terrible Overlord could also lose. The best teams would need both strategic coordination and individual skill.

**Would you play something like this?**  
And what do you think would be the biggest challenge: balancing heroes against armies, making the Overlord role enjoyable, or getting 20 players to actually cooperate?

Also what are some ideas that you have that could make this game idea better?
```



document fetched 2026-11-12 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xt75kj/what_if_there_was_a_fantasy_rts_where_two_players
