# IFF publishes submissions defending a poster dealer in Vivek Oberoi’s suit — retained record

> Retained reddit record from reddit:india.

Canonical: https://highsignal.app/data/records/fdec4a2a7f9b5022

[← sources](https://highsignal.app/data)


source: [reddit](https://highsignal.app/data/reddit) (reddit:india)  published 2026-11-03 10:48 ingested 2026-11-04 02:38

[original source ↗](https://www.reddit.com/r/india/comments/1xmptff/iff_publishes_submissions_defending_a_poster/)

## extract

[Donate Now](https://internetfreedom.in/donate/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in)

# tl;dr

On 28 October 2026, our Founder Director, Mr. Apar Gupta concluded arguments for Indian Hippy / Bollywood Movie Posters assisted by our Counsel, Ms. Pragya Jain, Defendant No. 5 in *Vivek Anand Oberoi v. Collector Bazar & Ors.*, CS(COMM) 105/2026. Its written submissions, filed on 13 October 2026 seek to vacate an *ex-parte ad-interim* injunction affecting the resale of five original film posters. They also address the wider question before the Delhi High Court: whether “personality rights” can support takedowns without establishing copyright infringement, passing off, invasion of privacy, defamation, or another recognised wrong. We are publishing those submissions. 

# Background

Indian Hippy is a proprietorship of Hinesh Durgadas Jethwani. Since 2009, it has collected and resold vintage Indian film memorabilia, including publicity posters that preserve a record of the cinema and commercial artwork of earlier decades. Its business includes original material dating back to the 1930s. The five listings challenged in this case concern *Company* (2002), *Omkara* (2006), and *Shootout at Lokhandwala* (2007).

The defence is that these are genuine physical copies made around the films’ release, acquired for resale. The plaintiff’s own documents reproduce listings recording print dates, dimensions, condition and the credited cast. They identify The Safire Industries, Endeavour, Epigram, and Shivang Creations as printers or design studios. One *Company* poster is described as showing wear along its folds. These particulars describe collectable objects already in circulation.

|**Film**|**Material challenged**|**Plaintiff’s documents**|
|:-|:-|:-|
|Company (2002)|Three original publicity posters|Volume II pages 55, 57 and 58|
|Shootout at Lokhandwala (2007)|One publicity show card|Volume II page 56|
|Omkara (2006)|One original publicity poster|Volume II page 59|

Images extracted from the plaintiff’s documents, Volume II pages 56, 57, and 59. Source watermarks retained. 

Oberoi’s suit, instituted on 4 February 2026, describes Defendant No. 5 as creating custom-made posters using his image without authorisation. The defendant disputes that description. It says it manufactured none of these items, added no image to them, and made no representation that Oberoi endorsed its business. He appears in the original publicity for films in which he acted, alongside other cast members.

On [5 February 2026](https://indiankanoon.org/doc/89789541/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in), a single Judge of the Delhi High Court granted an *ex parte ad-interim* injunction against the content impugned by Oberoi. Paragraph 31 referred to “the copyright of the plaintiff over his own personality”. The directions restrained extensive uses of Oberoi’s name, voice, image and likeness, and products or content said to dilute his persona through blurring or tarnishment. The disputed posters appeared in the content impugned by Oberoi, alongside links concerning other merchandise, AI-generated content, and social media material.

In compliance, Defendant No. 5 removed all five listings on 12 April 2026 and filed its reply dated 22 June 2026 contesting the restraint. 

The breadth of the February order has already required correction. On [28 July 2026](https://indiankanoon.org/doc/11314035/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in), following X Corp.’s application,  two URLs were excluded, finding that they had no relevance to Oberoi’s personality rights. The plaintiff had filed no reply despite opportunities to do so. The order also recorded other defendants’ objections that news reporting had been brought within the injunction. Those objections were submissions made to the Court, rather than findings establishing the underlying allegations.

On [28 September 2026](https://indiankanoon.org/doc/140385651/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in), the Court recorded that the plaintiff had neglected to pursue the matter after obtaining a favourable order. The wider legal questions are now being considered alongside the suits brought by Janhvi Kapoor and Aaradhya Bachchan, with Advocates Gautam Bhatia and Rohan J. Alva assisting as *amici curiae*. Defendant No. 5’s October submissions respond to that wider discussion as well as its own circumstances.

# Analysis

# How personality rights have become a ground for takedowns

“Personality rights” is used to describe claims concerning a person’s name, image, voice, likeness, and other identifiable attributes. Courts have granted protection under this description, drawing upon copyright, trademarks, privacy, and common law. India has no dedicated statute defining a general personality right, its duration, its defences or the remedies available for its violation. The decisions have consequently developed through claims involving substantially different kinds of conduct.

Some concern fraudulent endorsements or non-consensual sexual imagery. Others concern merchandise, fan material, parody or news. [Reuters reported on 1 October 2025](https://www.reuters.com/sustainability/society-equity/spooked-by-ai-bollywood-stars-drag-google-into-fight-personality-rights-2025-10-01/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in) that the litigation brought by Aishwarya Rai Bachchan and Abhishek Bachchan had resulted in takedown directions covering 518 links and posts. An [Indian Express explainer first published on 24 December 2025](https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/explained-law/delhi-hc-bans-unauthorised-use-of-madhavans-likeness-how-personality-rights-evolved-in-india-10436900/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in) described the increasing use of preventive orders, including mechanisms for action against future URLs. The consequences reach well beyond compensation for a particular misuse.

People subjected to impersonation, fraud or intimate abuse require effective remedies irrespective of fame. The legal difficulty arises when these wrongs are combined with objections to lawful publications and an injunction follows without identifying what each defendant has done. A person’s recognisability may establish that an image depicts them. It does not, on its own, establish why publishing or dealing in that image is unlawful.

The written submissions ask the Court to require a claim to satisfy the law under which protection is sought. The key argument goes beyond the absence of a statute. They oppose a freestanding proprietary right in identity, and a separate commercial misappropriation tort that would dispense with the limits of passing off and privacy.

The absence of a specific statute does not end the inquiry, since Indian courts can develop common law. The objection is to recognising a new right without defining its ingredients, defences and relationship to legislation governing the same conduct. A legal label cannot resolve the competing claims of the person depicted, the creator of a work and the person publishing or selling it.

# Copyright in a work does not arise from appearing in it

[Sections 13 and 16 of the Copyright Act, 1957](https://www.indiacode.nic.in/bitstream/123456789/1367/5/a1957-14.pdf?ref=static.internetfreedom.in) confine copyright to recognised works and rights created by law. A film poster may qualify as an artistic work. The person depicted does not become its copyright owner merely by appearing in it. The submissions point out that Oberoi has not pleaded ownership of copyright in these posters.

An actor also has statutory performers’ rights, including protections concerning the identification and prejudicial distortion of a performance. These rights have their own conditions and limits. They do not automatically confer ownership of every photograph, poster or other work in which the actor appears. The submissions therefore question the February order’s reference to copyright in personality itself.

They rely on *Akuate Internet Services v. Star India*, decided by a Division Bench of the Delhi High Court on 30 August 2013, which cautioned against creating exclusive rights in a field governed by the Copyright Act. The argument is that a claimant cannot obtain, under a new description, control that the statutory scheme does not confer.

# Reselling a genuine copy is a separate question from reproducing it

Section 14(c)(iii) of the Copyright Act excludes copies already in circulation from the copyright owner’s exclusive right to issue copies of an artistic work to the public. The accompanying explanation treats a copy sold once as already in circulation. This is the first-sale or exhaustion principle: a lawful purchaser can ordinarily resell that physical copy. Buying a poster does not confer a right to print further copies, but subsequent sale of the poster so bought does not ordinarily require repeated permission from the copyright owner.

The defence asks the Court to apply that distinction to these five listings. A general right over the actor’s likeness would allow control to be asserted again after the law governing the original work has exhausted the right to control that copy’s circulation. The implications extend to dealers in old books, magazines, photographs and other memorabilia bearing identifiable faces.

On [10 November 2025, in *Jaya Bachchan v. Bollywood Bubble Television*](https://delhihighcourt.nic.in/app/showlogo/1762946270_3931a8052dc27c9c_589_11942025.pdf/2025?ref=static.internetfreedom.in), the Delhi High Court declined to restrain a film-poster reseller at the *ex parte* stage. Paragraph 57 of this order recorded that the poster did not *prima facie* violate publicity rights and left further consideration until the reseller was impleaded and heard. It is a directly relevant instance of a court examining the material before restraining its sale.

# Passing off requires a misleading representation

Passing off protects goodwill against deception about the source, licence or endorsement of goods or services. A claimant must establish goodwill, a misleading representation and damage. Identifying a famous person and making a sale do not by themselves supply those elements.

In [*Digital Collectibles v. Galactus Funware*, decided on 26 April 2023](https://images.assettype.com/barandbench/2023-04/7b7c1570-0d3f-433f-8101-4ecd69e2852f/Digital_Collectibles_Pte_Ltd_v_Galactus_Funware_Technology_Pvt_Ltd.pdf?ref=static.internetfreedom.in), the Delhi High Court applied passing-off principles to publicity claims. Paragraph 55 of the judgment rejected identification or commercial gain alone as sufficient to establish infringement. Paragraphs 56–58 of the judgment recognised the constitutional protection of expressive uses and commercial speech. A publication does not lose protection simply because someone earns money from it.

The submissions also examine the English Court of Appeal’s decision in [*Fenty v. Arcadia*, dated 22 January 2015](https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/fenty-others-v-arcadia-others1.pdf?ref=static.internetfreedom.in). Rihanna succeeded against Topshop because the particular circumstances conveyed a misleading impression of authorisation. The court maintained that English law recognised no general image right. The comparison illustrates how an established cause of action can address deception without creating ownership of every depiction of a celebrity.

Here, the defendant says its listings accurately identify original film publicity. A purchaser is offered a poster with a stated print date and condition. The defendant has already taken the position that the said posters do not contain any representation that Oberoi licensed the dealer or approved the sale. The defendant also objects to borrowing trademark concepts such as dilution and tarnishment without satisfying Section 29(4) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, which concerns registered marks and contains specific requirements.

# Privacy and defamation have their own limits

Privacy belongs to everyone. Public recognition does not strip a person of protection against intrusion into their private life. Equally, the defendant argues that publicity deliberately released for a film reveals nothing private merely because an actor remains identifiable in it. Drawing on *R. Rajagopal v. State of Tamil Nadu* and later decisions, it asks the Court to examine the privacy interest actually affected and the lawful remedy for its invasion.

Reputational complaints require a similar examination. In [*Bloomberg v. Zee Entertainment*, decided on 22 March 2024](https://orderlawstorage.blob.core.windows.net/judgements/supreme_court/2024/YWRtaW4vanVkZ2VtZW50X2ZpbGUvanVkZ2VtZW50X3BkZi8yMDI0L3ZvbHVtZSAzL1BhcnQgSVYvMjAyNF8zXzk5NC0xMDAzXzE3MTM5NTQyNTgucGRm.pdf?ref=static.internetfreedom.in), the Supreme Court stressed the exceptional nature of *ex parte* restraints on journalistic publication. Courts must assess whether the defence would undoubtedly fail at trial and give reasons for restricting publication before hearing the affected party. Truth and fair comment cannot be disregarded by relabelling alleged defamation as injury to personality.

This is how an undefined right can exceed the sources of law invoked to justify it. Copyright ownership goes unproved, deception becomes unnecessary, privacy is detached from an intrusion, and reputational injury escapes the safeguards governing defamation. The submissions ask the Court to retain those requirements when deciding whether an injunction should be issued.

# Procedural rules cannot create the right being enforced

The submissions also address reliance on the Delhi High Court Intellectual Property Rights Division Rules, 2022, which refer to certain privacy and publicity claims. Their argument is that rules allocating cases to a court division regulate procedure; they do not create a substantive cause of action. A reference to publicity in those rules cannot establish what the claimant owns or what a defendant has infringed. The distinction matters when a commercial suit seeks remedies drawn from intellectual property law for a grievance that is, on examination, about reputation or privacy.

# Each restraint must be justified against the person affected

The submissions question the use of the plaintiff’s popularity as a substitute for findings about each defendant’s conduct. Courts must assess the apparent strength of the claim, the comparative hardship of granting or refusing relief, and whether damages would adequately compensate the injury. An original poster dealer, an impersonation account, and a producer of synthetic imagery require separate examination.

They also seek limits on dynamic injunctions, which permit action against further material without a fresh suit each time. The proposed restriction is to unidentified or rogue actors and synthetic or impersonating content. Identified creators should ordinarily be heard. In [*Hrithik Roshan v. Ashok Kumar*, on 15 October 2025](https://indiankanoon.org/doc/126963257/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in), the Delhi High Court excluded certain URLs, preserved specified fan profiles and required some creators to be heard before directions were passed. Such safeguards matter at the interim stage itself.

The wider burden falls on users whose material disappears. [Mint reported on 30 July 2026](https://www.livemint.com/news/personality-rights-lawsuits-social-media-platforms-india-courts-11785219086727.html?ref=static.internetfreedom.in) that these suits increasingly require platforms to assess material against takedown orders. Insufficient removal carries consequences for platforms, while excessive removal generally carries no immediate consequence. A small trader or individual creator must then find the time and resources to contest an order already operating against them.

# Action

Defendant No. 5 has asked the Court to vacate the order dated 5 February 2026 insofar as it operates against it, and dismiss the injunction application against it with costs. Its wider submissions ask that every restraint identify the legal wrong, the conduct constituting it and the material to which the direction applies. The submissions support the amicus Gautam Bhatia’s approach of examining each alleged wrong separately, while opposing a distinct commercial misappropriation tort beyond passing off and privacy.

We are publishing the written submissions because the questions affect everyone who reports on, criticises, depicts or collects material concerning public figures. Those activities should be tested against ascertainable legal standards, with an opportunity to be heard before lawful expression and trade are restrained.

This position is consistent with our assistance to comedian Pulkit Mani in his [suit concerning fraudulent copyright strikes](https://internetfreedom.in/delhi-high-court-issues-notice-in-fraudulent-copyright-strike-case-filed-by-stand-up-comic-pulkit-mani/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in). That case concerns a creator seeking protection for his own work against unsupported infringement complaints. In both situations, requiring the claimant to identify the right and establish the alleged violation protects users against arbitrary removal. The legal requirements for taking material down are part of the protection afforded to expression.

# Important documents

1. Written submissions on behalf of Defendant No. 5 dated 13 October 2026 in Vivek Anand Oberoi v. Collector Bazar & Ors., CS(COMM) 105/2026. ([Link](https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1Dzxi4k4dPWeAjlNkdJ5yoCY4g0SUHL7v?usp=sharing&ref=static.internetfreedom.in))

***Doxxing and threats have not stopped us, and we are still here, doing this work. IFF is a small team that relies on people like you to keep fighting for your digital rights. If this analysis was useful, please chip in and help us grow.*** [***Donate to IFF***](https://internetfreedom.in/donate/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in)

[Donate Now](https://internetfreedom.in/donate/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in)

## retained text (truncated)



```
[Donate Now](https://internetfreedom.in/donate/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in)

# tl;dr

On 28 October 2026, our Founder Director, Mr. Apar Gupta concluded arguments for Indian Hippy / Bollywood Movie Posters assisted by our Counsel, Ms. Pragya Jain, Defendant No. 5 in *Vivek Anand Oberoi v. Collector Bazar & Ors.*, CS(COMM) 105/2026. Its written submissions, filed on 13 October 2026 seek to vacate an *ex-parte ad-interim* injunction affecting the resale of five original film posters. They also address the wider question before the Delhi High Court: whether “personality rights” can support takedowns without establishing copyright infringement, passing off, invasion of privacy, defamation, or another recognised wrong. We are publishing those submissions. 

# Background

Indian Hippy is a proprietorship of Hinesh Durgadas Jethwani. Since 2009, it has collected and resold vintage Indian film memorabilia, including publicity posters that preserve a record of the cinema and commercial artwork of earlier decades. Its business includes original material dating back to the 1930s. The five listings challenged in this case concern *Company* (2002), *Omkara* (2006), and *Shootout at Lokhandwala* (2007).

The defence is that these are genuine physical copies made around the films’ release, acquired for resale. The plaintiff’s own documents reproduce listings recording print dates, dimensions, condition and the credited cast. They identify The Safire Industries, Endeavour, Epigram, and Shivang Creations as printers or design studios. One *Company* poster is described as showing wear along its folds. These particulars describe collectable objects already in circulation.

|**Film**|**Material challenged**|**Plaintiff’s documents**|
|:-|:-|:-|
|Company (2002)|Three original publicity posters|Volume II pages 55, 57 and 58|
|Shootout at Lokhandwala (2007)|One publicity show card|Volume II page 56|
|Omkara (2006)|One original publicity poster|Volume II page 59|

Images extracted from the plaintiff’s documents, Volume II pages 56, 57, and 59. Source watermarks retained. 

Oberoi’s suit, instituted on 4 February 2026, describes Defendant No. 5 as creating custom-made posters using his image without authorisation. The defendant disputes that description. It says it manufactured none of these items, added no image to them, and made no representation that Oberoi endorsed its business. He appears in the original publicity for films in which he acted, alongside other cast members.

On [5 February 2026](https://indiankanoon.org/doc/89789541/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in), a single Judge of the Delhi High Court granted an *ex parte ad-interim* injunction against the content impugned by Oberoi. Paragraph 31 referred to “the copyright of the plaintiff over his own personality”. The directions restrained extensive uses of Oberoi’s name, voice, image and likeness, and products or content said to dilute his persona through blurring or tarnishment. The disputed posters appeared in the content impugned by Oberoi, alongside links concerning other merchandise, AI-generated content, and social media material.

In compliance, Defendant No. 5 removed all five listings on 12 April 2026 and filed its reply dated 22 June 2026 contesting the restraint. 

The breadth of the February order has already required correction. On [28 July 2026](https://indiankanoon.org/doc/11314035/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in), following X Corp.’s application,  two URLs were excluded, finding that they had no relevance to Oberoi’s personality rights. The plaintiff had filed no reply despite opportunities to do so. The order also recorded other defendants’ objections that news reporting had been brought within the injunction. Those objections were submissions made to the Court, rather than findings establishing the underlying allegations.

On [28 September 2026](https://indiankanoon.org/doc/140385651/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in), the Court recorded that the plaintiff had neglected to pursue the matter after obtaining a favourable order. The wider legal questions are now being considered alongside the suits brought by Janhvi Kapoor and Aaradhya Bachchan, with Advocates Gautam Bhatia and Rohan J. Alva assisting as *amici curiae*. Defendant No. 5’s October submissions respond to that wider discussion as well as its own circumstances.

# Analysis

# How personality rights have become a ground for takedowns

“Personality rights” is used to describe claims concerning a person’s name, image, voice, likeness, and other identifiable attributes. Courts have granted protection under this description, drawing upon copyright, trademarks, privacy, and common law. India has no dedicated statute defining a general personality right, its duration, its defences or the remedies available for its violation. The decisions have consequently developed through claims involving substantially different kinds of conduct.

Some concern fraudulent endorsements or non-consensual sexual imagery. Others concern merchandise, fan material, parody or news. [Reuters reported on 1 October 2025](https://www.reuters.com/sustainability/society-equity/spooked-by-ai-bollywood-stars-drag-google-into-fight-personality-rights-2025-10-01/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in) that the litigation brought by Aishwarya Rai Bachchan and Abhishek Bachchan had resulted in takedown directions covering 518 links and posts. An [Indian Express explainer first published on 24 December 2025](https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/explained-law/delhi-hc-bans-unauthorised-use-of-madhavans-likeness-how-personality-rights-evolved-in-india-10436900/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in) described the increasing use of preventive orders, including mechanisms for action against future URLs. The consequences reach well beyond compensation for a particular misuse.

People subjected to impersonation, fraud or intimate abuse require effective remedies irrespective of fame. The legal difficulty arises when these wrongs are combined with objections to lawful publications and an injunction follows without identifying what each defendant has done. A person’s recognisability may establish that an image depicts them. It does not, on its own, establish why publishing or dealing in that image is unlawful.

The written submissions ask the Court to require a claim to satisfy the law under which protection is sought. The key argument goes beyond the absence of a statute. They oppose a freestanding proprietary right in identity, and a separate commercial misappropriation tort that would dispense with the limits of passing off and privacy.

The absence of a specific statute does not end the inquiry, since Indian courts can develop common law. The objection is to recognising a new right without defining its ingredients, defences and relationship to legislation governing the same conduct. A legal label cannot resolve the competing claims of the person depicted, the creator of a work and the person publishing or selling it.

# Copyright in a work does not arise from appearing in it

[Sections 13 and 16 of the Copyright Act, 1957](https://www.indiacode.nic.in/bitstream/123456789/1367/5/a1957-14.pdf?ref=static.internetfreedom.in) confine copyright to recognised works and rights created by law. A film poster may qualify as an artistic work. The person depicted does not become its copyright owner merely by appearing in it. The submissions point out that Oberoi has not pleaded ownership of copyright in these posters.

An actor also has statutory performers’ rights, including protections concerning the identification and prejudicial distortion of a performance. These rights have their own conditions and limits. They do not automatically confer ownership of every photograph, poster or other work in which the actor appears. The submissions therefore question the February order’s reference to copyright in personality itself.

They rely on *Akuate Internet Services v. Star India*, decided by a Division Bench of the Delhi High Court on 30 August 2013, which cautioned against creating exclusive rights in a field governed by the Copyright Act. The argument is that a claimant cannot obtain, under a new description, control that the statutory scheme does not confer.

# Reselling a genuine copy is a separate question from reproducing it

Section 14(c)(iii) of the Copyright Act excludes copies already in circulation from the copyright owner’s exclusive right to issue copies of an artistic work to the public. The accompanying explanation treats a copy sold once as already in circulation. This is the first-sale or exhaustion principle: a lawful purchaser can ordinarily resell that physical copy. Buying a poster does not confer a right to print further copies, but subsequent sale of the poster so bought does not ordinarily require repeated permission from the copyright owner.

The defence asks the Court to apply that distinction to these five listings. A general right over the actor’s likeness would allow control to be asserted again after the law governing the original work has exhausted the right to control that copy’s circulation. The implications extend to dealers in old books, magazines, photographs and other memorabilia bearing identifiable faces.

On [10 November 2025, in *Jaya Bachchan v. Bollywood Bubble Television*](https://delhihighcourt.nic.in/app/showlogo/1762946270_3931a8052dc27c9c_589_11942025.pdf/2025?ref=static.internetfreedom.in), the Delhi High Court declined to restrain a film-poster reseller at the *ex parte* stage. Paragraph 57 of this order recorded that the poster did not *prima facie* violate publicity rights and left further consideration until the reseller was impleaded and heard. It is a directly relevant instance of a court examining the material before restraining its sale.

# Passing off requires a misleading representation

Passing off protects goodwill against deception about the source, licence or endorsement of goods or services. A claimant must establish goodwill, a misleading representation and damage. Identifying a famous person and making a sale do not by themselves supply those elements.

In [*Digital Collectibles v. Galactus Funware*, decided on 26 April 2023](https://images.assettype.com/barandbench/2023-04/7b7c1570-0d3f-433f-8101-4ecd69e2852f/Digital_Collectibles_Pte_Ltd_v_Galactus_Funware_Technology_Pvt_Ltd.pdf?ref=static.internetfreedom.in), the Delhi High Court applied passing-off principles to publicity claims. Paragraph 55 of the judgment rejected identification or commercial gain alone as sufficient to establish infringement. Paragraphs 56–58 of the judgment recognised the constitutional protection of expressive uses and commercial speech. A publication does not lose protection simply because someone earns money from it.

The submissions also examine the English Court of Appeal’s decision in [*Fenty v. Arcadia*, dated 22 January 2015](https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/fenty-others-v-arcadia-others1.pdf?ref=static.internetfreedom.in). Rihanna succeeded against Topshop because the particular circumstances conveyed a misleading impression of authorisation. The court maintained that English law recognised no general image right. The comparison illustrates how an established cause of action can address deception without creating ownership of every depiction of a celebrity.

Here, the defendant says its listings accurately identify original film publicity. A purchaser is offered a poster with a stated print date and condition. The defendant has already taken the position that the said posters do not contain any representation that Oberoi licensed the dealer or approved the sale. The defendant also objects to borrowing trademark concepts such as dilution and tarnishment without satisfying Section 29(4) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, which concerns registered marks and contains specific requirements.

# Privacy and defamation have their own limits

Privacy belongs to everyone. Public r
```



document fetched 2026-11-04 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/india/comments/1xmptff/iff_publishes_submissions_defending_a_poster
