How much CO₂ have wind and solar avoided since 2006? A country-by-country counterfactual gives about 24 Gt net.
retained text
Hi! I was curious about how much CO2 was actually avoided in the last 20 years with the implementation of renewable energy systems. The most cited study on avoided emissions from wind and solar is the IEA’s estimation, which is about 2.6 Gt CO₂ for 2025, but that considers one year and only the capacity that was added since 2019. I wanted to have a look at the cumulative number, so I built a counterfactual: what if every TWh from wind and solar since 2006 had come from coal and gas plants instead, with demand unchanged? In the calculation i considered the following: (a) the annual wind and solar generation by country from 2006 to 2025 (Our World in Data, compiled from Ember and the Energy Institute); (b) each country-year’s output is split between coal and gas in proportion to that country’s actual coal and gas generation that year, so that a Polish wind farm mostly displaces coal and a Spanish one mostly displaces gas; (c) fleet efficiencies of 37% for coal and 48% for gas according to the IPCC 2006 default combustion factors; (d) lifecycle emissions subtracted for the renewable technolgies, that is 12 g/kWh for wind and 48 g/kWh for solar (Ember); (e) the upstream methane is excluded, so the result is conservative on that side. To check that the model worked, I applied it only to the capacity added since 2019 and the model gives about 2.5 Gt for 2025, against the IEA’s 2.6 Gt. The results from the calculation are so that about 34,900 TWh were generated over the period, roughly 60% of it displacing coal and about 60% of that output came in the last years, from 2021 to 2025. About 7 billion tonnes of coal equivalent and 2,900 bcm of gas were left unburned and the gross avoided emissions are 25 Gt globally (considering the manufacturing of ca. 0.9 Gt (3.5% of gross), the net avoided emissions are about 24 Gt). To give the 24 Gt a context, this would be equal to 7.5 months of everything the world now emits from energy, at about 38 Gt a year (IEA) and over the 20-years period, wind and solar kept cumulative fossil CO₂ about 3.5% lower than it would otherwise have been. Europe alone shows the effect more clearly, because wind and solar make up a bigger share of its power: EU wind and solar avoided about 4.7 Gt, leaving the EU’s cumulative emissions about 8% lower. I have the full analysis with references, the equations I used, and the counterfactual arguments that could have changed these results, for example the possibility that cheaper electricity raised demand instead of replacing fossil power, the extra fuel burned when fossil plants ramp up and down, and so on. You find the article [here](https://raw-science.org/wind-solar-avoided-co2-emissions-2006-2025/).
document fetched 2026-11-10 00:36 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/energy/comments/1xruiy4/how_much_co%E2%82%82_have_wind_and_solar_avoided_since