← sources

My close rate on automation retainers went from under 10% to 39%. Most of it came from how I handle proposals

source: reddit (reddit:EntrepreneurRideAlong)published 2026-11-02 12:31ingested 2026-11-03 02:38

retained text

Some background first. I've been in sales 10+ years. #1 AE at Builder.ai, #1 at BuildFire (143% of quota one year), then I co-founded a company where I was the only one selling. We did $1.2M in year one and later got to $100K MRR.

These days I close for AI and automation agencies, somewhere between 5 and 10 retainers a month. When I started on this kind of work I was closing under 10% of my calls, which was humbling given the resume. I'm at 39% now. Three changes got me there.

I stopped emailing proposals. Completely. The proposal became the reason for the second meeting. I book that meeting before the first call ends and walk them through it live. No meeting, no proposal.

I got disciplined about discovery. Every first call has to cover their current process and where it breaks, what it's costing them, the outcome they want, and who decides plus budget and timing. That transcript ends up being the raw material for everything else.

I automated the proposal build. Fireflies records the call, and some Claude skills I built turn it into a proposal on my own domain with a Stripe or QuickBooks payment link built in. It has an executive summary, their goal, the methodology, a clickable prototype, scope and timeline, proof from a similar client, ROI or the cost of doing nothing, what we need from them, and the next step to pay and get started. About 30 minutes of my time, with Claude doing around 20 of that on its own. Ready the same day.

The clickable prototype was the surprise. Clients keep telling me the proposal gave them the full picture and made it easy to pick us.

The speed came from turning it into a defined process. The close rate came from the personalization, because every proposal is built from that client's own words.

Happy to answer questions here. And if you run an agency, I'm looking to work with 1 or 2 more. If you've got your own leads I can handle the closing for you, or if you just want someone to look over your sales process I'll do a free call and share tips. DM me either way.

document fetched 2026-11-03 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/EntrepreneurRideAlong/comments/1xlvwvo/my_close_rate_on_automation_retainers_went_from