← sources

Having hard conversations & giving criticism/feedback to a fellow senior dev? I feel like I'm overstepping but it impacts me so I'm more onboard with saying something.

source: reddit (reddit:ExperiencedDevs)published 2026-11-02 21:54ingested 2026-11-03 02:38

retained text

There's a recently promoted senior dev on my team (I believe he has 4-5 YOE) vs. my 10 YOE that I have mentally labeled as not very strong at the "coding" portion of work. He's more on the "ops" side and looks like he actively avoids working in any repository.

There are automated flags on systems and it was something very simple to mitigate and just was a org wide coding standard, like changing a hardcoded value to be a parameterized value.

This dev monitored the alerts and then sent me the alert with "Hi OP, can you look into this? -link to alert-".

I saw it, read the issue, simple enough to mitigate even without AI usage.

I responded with "this looks straightforward. Was there a reason why this needed to be assigned to me?"

He responded "since you coded in this repo, can you just fix it?"

I haven't responded to this yet... I'm just.. dumbfounded? It took me 15 minutes to spin up a PR and that was because I was in a meeting at the same time.

1) ..how do you not know how to do this?

2) I don't even know how to give "meaningful" feedback without sounding like a jerk like "dude, how do you NOT know how to do this"

3) I'm not sure if I'm crossing a line if I *do* give feedback. In my previous roles, I established a good rapport with coworkers so giving feedback like this was easy for me. I don't work with this person often so I don't think I can comfortably give this feedback.

4) Am I throwing this dev under the bus if I just flag this to my manager instead? Is putting the onus of a "hard conversation" on my manager a worse thing to do?

I don't really care if devs around me don't do work, they can rest and invest all they want... but I *do* care if I get established as the "throw this work at this guy because he's willing to do it" guy. I'm not sure on how to tacitly set that boundary without turning into the "coworker who I don't want to work with" guy. What would you all do? I imagine there would be a mix of "give the feedback personally vs. tell your manager to handle it" but would love to hear how prior experiences have gone.

document fetched 2026-11-03 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ExperiencedDevs/comments/1xmas5n/having_hard_conversations_giving