Need advice about employee
retained text
I started my business just under seven years ago. It is a day spa offering lash, brow, wax, and skin services. Up until about three months ago, it had just been me wearing all the hats and doing all the services. I’ve been incredibly fortunate to grow enough that I was able to move into a storefront, expand our services, and hire estheticians. I want my spa to be a good work environment for its staff, and I want both employees and clients to feel good about coming here. Unfortunately, I’m having a few issues with one employee, and I’m struggling to figure out whether these are normal growing pains with a new employee or signs that this simply isn’t a good fit. During the interview process, she told me that she was newly moving to the area, fresh out of school, and has two young children at home whom she needs to be home with during the week. She was looking for a part-time position that worked with her partial SAHM schedule. I told her that wasn’t a problem, and we worked out a schedule that seemed to work for both of us. She was hired to work Friday from 3:30 p.m.–8:00 p.m., plus Saturday and Sunday from 10:00 a.m.–6:30 p.m. I hired her at a 50/50 commission rate plus tips and told her that I’m very understanding when things come up—sick children, being out of town, family obligations, etc.—but that I needed to know about those things ahead of time and, whenever possible, before clients had been booked on her schedule for those days. She signed an employment contract outlining expectations and immediately informed me of three work periods that she already had obligations for. I thanked her for letting me know ahead of time and marked those dates off her schedule. Her first week comes, and she texts me asking, “Hey, can you see if my clients for Saturday will come on Sunday? Our parents are coming into town that day.” I reminded her that I really don’t like moving clients who have already scheduled appointments because they plan their own schedules around coming to us for services. However, I went ahead and moved the appointments and asked her to please make sure this didn’t become a recurring issue. Then, about two weeks later, I was trying to book a client on the computer and discovered that she had marked herself off for another Saturday, as well as another entire weekend later in the year, without notifying me or asking whether those dates were available to take off. I texted her because I had no idea this had happened. We went back and forth with me explaining my expectations, and a few comments she made stood out to me: “I was under the impression in the interview that you would be flexible with hours.” “I’m sorry that the calendar didn’t notify you that I blocked it off. I’ll be back in the following day.” “On weeks that I can’t make my scheduled three days, you can just schedule me for other days.” “I don’t think this is fair.” I absolutely did tell her during the interview that I would be flexible with her moving to a new town and having two small children at home. However, what I meant by flexibility was that I was willing to accommodate occasional conflicts with advance notice—not that her established schedule was optional or that days could be blocked off without approval. So far, she has taken off 14 of the 47 days she was scheduled to work before the end of the year. Her start date was only in September. I ended the conversation by allowing the days off since they had already been marked unavailable on the work calendar. I then asked her whether she could confirm that she would be available for the remaining scheduled workdays through the end of the year. I also asked whether she would be available on two additional days and, if so, what hours she could work. She has not responded. She already has upcoming client appointments booked on her schedule, and I’ve invested quite a bit of time and money into training and onboarding her, so I don’t want to make a knee-jerk decision. There have also been several other boundary issues that are making me question whether this is simply a scheduling misunderstanding. She has repeatedly pushed me to purchase supplies and decor after I’ve declined—including giving me a list totaling around $950 where I felt only a couple of the items were actually necessary. She has told me how she thinks the studio should be decorated, regularly accepts calls from her husband while clients are in her chair, has yelled across the room telling me to do something for her rather than asking, and has “organized” areas and thrown away items that we actually need to perform services despite me trying to politely establish boundaries. The difficult part is that I’m new to having employees, and I genuinely want to make sure I’m being fair. I don’t want to mistake someone being comfortable communicating with me for disrespect, nor do I expect an employee to never need time off. At the same time, I need to be able to operate the business, book clients confidently, and know that an employee’s agreed-upon availability is actually their availability unless time off has been communicated and approved. My other employee has only needed to leave early once, told me ahead of time, is great with clients, and is genuinely very pleasant to work with. Unfortunately, she doesn’t perform the same services as this employee. Replacing this employee would mean absorbing some of her appointments into my already roughly 80-hour workweek while recruiting someone else. It could also mean weeks or even months of hiring, training, and investing in another person all over again. For those of you who have managed employees: would you treat this as something that could reasonably be corrected with one formal conversation and clearly documented expectations, or do the repeated scheduling and boundary issues this early in employment suggest that the arrangement is unlikely to work long-term?
document fetched 2026-10-03 00:31 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/smallbusiness/comments/1wvi0zl/need_advice_about_employee