← sources

Is this game idea too ambitious for a solo dev?

source: reddit (reddit:gamedev)published 2026-10-14 12:40ingested 2026-10-15 02:38

retained text

Hello everyone.

I figured I'd post on here before potentially wasting 1+ year of my life.

For context, I've recently returned to game development this year after an 11 year break. Since returning, I've made several small games that haven't been complete failures (9,000 downloads on one). But these were relatively simple, small games and to be entirely honest, I don't think they're that fun.

So I am thinking about a mega project. I want to create a multiplayer PVP survival game like Ark Survival evolved and Rust. I want to capture the core loop that made these games so addicting and fun but package it in a unique and accessible way.

As you get older, you get less time to play video games. You often simply can't play games like ARK or Rust because they require too much time and too much of a commitment. (Especially ark, you need to be a kid or flat out unemployed to get anywhere).

At the same time, there's also a big learning curve to these games which makes things fun and exciting, but in ARKs case at least, it'd probably take you 6 months of playing it constantly before you know all the little tricks and stuff.

So with that, I think there's an underserved market for that sort of game but more for casual players who can't dedicate their life to it.

This sort of game typically requires a team and is a multi-year effort. I've laid out some initial plans however, and think it would take me around 12 - 18 months for the first playable version.

This would be leveraging a lot of professional freelance work and SI to do a lot of the grunt work with networking.

My biggest fear is spending 12 months on this project to then realise that it's too difficult for a solo dev.

This project would also require significant infrastructure which is a job in itself to maintain.

I also wanted to make this game free for everyone but am not sure about the economics of it as there would be a significant ongoing cost.

I can handle most of the work myself but I lack expertise in 3D art and animation. I can put around £25,000 ($33,000) into this project but I worry that this wouldn't be enough for the amount of work I'd need.

So my biggest fear is wasting my time and wasting a big chunk of money only to scrap the project half way through. 

I don't mind spending £25,000 and a year of my life making this game so long as I can at least finish it. I wouldn't be risking my livelihood or be counting on this game to turn a profit, but I'd at least like to finish it even if no one plays it.

Are there any experienced game devs here who can weigh in? perhaps ones who have worked or works at a proper studio? Am I in way over my head here? As I said, I've never attempted a game even half this size before, I don't work professionally in the industry so I have no concept on how this will actually play out.

Thanks for your time.

document fetched 2026-10-15 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1x5q5s3/is_this_game_idea_too_ambitious_for_a_solo_dev