Bit of backup (restoring) paranoia?
retained text
Hello all! I've been delving into homelabbing for the last couple of years right now, and have lately been putting my focus on backups and most importantly checking said backups. Currently have a Synology NAS at home with 2 drives in RAID 1 (ext4 though, would like to upgrade to BTRFS or ZFS in the future), one at my grandparents house in RAID 1 too, and a Hetzner storage box. So, for 3 2 1 i am covered. Once in a while I check the logs and files to make sure that they have backed up properly. Now ive dug into the topic further and seen often recommended to actually restore and test the backups, to not blindly trust the logs and verify them yourself. That involves downloading entire proxmox VM snapshots, immich libraries, etc. It all seems quite time consuming, not to mention is recommended to do once every couple of months. On top of that, people recommend to run hash checks, by just throwing together some scripts to compare the source to the destination. Or as i said entire distaster recovery procedures that involves way too many GB of data to restore just to see if it all works. And even then, how much should i check? A debian VM might have some part corrupted but i could easily overlook it. Or what if a couple of my photos did get corrupted but since its thousands of them i'd never notice. So, i'm a bit stuck in a "valley of despair". I'm gaining knowledge on the subject but also becoming more worried about things that can go wrong now that i have gained that knowledge. I understand that backup engineer is a literal job title, but i just wish for my important files to be backed up with the peace of mind that they are properly backed up without huge procedures every couple of months. Anyone feeling me on this, or can help me out?
document fetched 2026-10-05 00:32 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/homelab/comments/1wxfcp2/bit_of_backup_restoring_paranoia