← sources

What are the origin of money? A solution to barter or debt?

source: reddit (reddit:economy)published 2026-11-09 08:56ingested 2026-11-10 02:43

retained text

We all learned that people used to barter and then invented money to simplify transactions. However, I've learned that this is not the only major story.

What if debt came first and money was a solution to debt, not barter? David Graeber argues no ancient economies have ever been documented to mainly use barter. Early communities ran on favours and debt not barter.

Whichever story is true isn't obvious, on one hand Adam Smith didn't provide evidence of his barter theory. On the other Graeber's theory has many legitimate criticism but is at least based on archeological evidence. 

I'm curious what you think about this? 

If you want to learn more I've written a complete article on the subject : [https://thethoughtprocess.xyz/en/where-money-comes-from](https://thethoughtprocess.xyz/en/where-money-comes-from)

document fetched 2026-11-10 00:42 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/economy/comments/1xrmsu2/what_are_the_origin_of_money_a_solution_to_barter