Great idea, I have no clue what I’m doing.
retained text
TL;DR: Enthusiast has a game idea and has absolutely no clue what they’re doing or even which direction to go. So I got it in my head about a year ago that if my perfect hard sci-fi space combat sim didn’t exist, that I should be the change I wanted to see in the world. I’ve got programming experience but in C#, a bit of Python and in the completely useless now VB.Net, and all of it in a business setting none of it on the same continent as game development. I wrote out a huge document with an outline of the plot of the game, the setting, the key gameplay features I wanted, rules the game had to obey, the nice to haves that I could add after the key stuff was in place, factions, ship and weapon types, etc. I downloaded the Unreal Engine and got it hooked up into VS; I started watching YT guides, building basic UAssets, and I started learning how to draw so I could sketch out some of the ships and stations I wanted for the game. And then burnout hit. Every inch forward was taking a Herculean amount of effort and I felt like I wasn’t even treading water. I kept hearing that voice in my head saying that I couldn’t actually do this, this game would never exist, and that I should just wait for someone else to make something close to what I wanted and be happy about it. That has resulted in me not touching anything relating to it in about 5 months. I still think about it every day almost though. I really want to give this a go because while I think it would be niche, this is MY ideal space combat sim and even if nobody else ever wanted to touch it, at least it would exist. I am so woefully equipped though that I’m considering getting a degree in game development from a university without any intention of ever making another game again after this just so I could know what I was doing and actually make this thing a reality. I came here because this seemed like the best place to get a no-BS reality check from a group of people that understood, and had no personal stake in the outcome one way or the other. So as seemingly insane as it is to ask strangers on Reddit for advice, here I am. My questions to you guys are these: Can what basically amounts to an enthusiast actually make a full fledged game like this as a one man show, or did I just delude myself into thinking I could actually do this by learning as I go? If I’m not completely insane, what exactly am I getting myself into and is there any good way to look forward and see the path ahead or is part of the point to just grope in the dark and figure it out as you go? Is a university program a decent path to go down for this or is there a more effective path? (Please understand, I’m not looking for ‘least effort’, just least likely to have me realize halfway down the road that I took a wrong turn and have to backtrack) I think what I’m really looking for is validation that this isn’t completely insane and that even if it’ll be the hardest thing I’ve ever done, there is actually a way forward that gets me to where I want to go and this idea I have doesn’t need to be doomed to the proverbial “what if” pile.
document fetched 2026-10-28 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xh4hki/great_idea_i_have_no_clue_what_im_doing