← sources

My Experience So Far With Claude Pro As A Gemini Fanboy

source: reddit (reddit:ClaudeAI)published 2026-10-24 20:57ingested 2026-10-25 02:36

retained text

I'm not a bot or a troll or anything. I don't even use Reddit so much but I just wanted to share this one. I'm a dental student and I don't use AI for any professional work. I'm just an AI pleb, you can say.  
  
A short lore of me first, then my experience:

Been using AI as an amateur since 2020. I remember when I was so excited, waiting for OpenAI's DALL-E image generator model to be published. When I started college, I felt the need to do more work and have been closely following everything about AI ever since.

I started with Gemini 2 IIRC, then Gemini 2.5 dropped and it was a banger. I used Gemini for so many things (mostly study related stuff like PDF summaries, generating tests etc.) and have been a Gemini Pro subscriber for 3 years now.

After all the drama about Google this year, I felt like I should try something new. I had an AI model tier list in my mind and Gemini was #1, especially after the 2.5 Pro model which stayed at the top for a long time. Then there was GPT but it fell off for me after some scandals I don't remember well right now. And I was thinking of Claude like a rip-off model, it wasn't even in my tier list.

Anyways, I started seeing Claude more and more this year, and after seeing Argon's limits and people praising Fable and Opus 5.5, I decided to give this "rip-off" a try.

The things models can do, the features Claude app has, the limits of Pro and everything like skills, projects and code really surprised me. For a long time, Google only had the "Extended" option in its own app, now it's 3. Seeing efforts in Claude go from Low to Ultracode was impressive, also with the option to use older models in the app.   
  
And today, I wanted to just talk about animating something. When it said "I can do it for you." and it did, I was really surprised. I let it use my PC to open Blender, make an animation, render it and export the file to my desktop. Maybe Antigravity does that too, but I might never be able to test it because of the limit usage.

I even tried making a game with Opus and it understood me very well. I made a brief plan about a game and while we planned what to do, it just correctly guessed (as a recommendation) what I would choose and want. This was very surprising too.

I also made it code for 45 minutes on xhigh and it only used around %30 of my limits which is crazy (in a good way) to me.

I'm both happy and sad that the #1 is Claude for me now. Google had always released models a little bit late, but they were better so I always thought "only those who do it better will rise, the advertising and being a little bit late to the party doesn't matter". It's still true for me but right now, Claude is better overall for me with a huge gap too.

Claude's models really made me think that I was getting closer to do whatever I wanted in the past such as making the games I had in mind or making mods. I thought I would never be able to since I needed to learn to code, which was (and is) impossible for a long time since I already have tons of classes in my college to worry about. It's just crazy how good Claude performs. I now understand why people praise it so much, it even made me share this huge ahh text here.

In short, as a huge Gemini fan, Claude is now #1 for me and what impressed me is:  
1. Limits. Compared to Gemini 4 Argon, my limit goes longer with Opus.  
2. Features and the things it can do. Being able to control so many things, files, using the screen and GitHub. Also Claude Code and Projects are amazing!  
3. It's reasoning and ability to understand with shorter prompts with no detail.  
4. Highly configurable effort levels and freedom to choose a lot of older models.

I repeat, I'm an AI pleb so what I said or my wording might be incorrect so sorry in advance. But this is just my experience. I'm happy so far and I don't consider cancelling my subscription as long as it keeps maintaining its quality. I still have the Pro Student Plan in Gemini though lol.

document fetched 2026-10-25 00:21 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ClaudeAI/comments/1xejo1i/my_experience_so_far_with_claude_pro_as_a_gemini