← sources

People who had hits: Are they mostly unexpected or you can almost always see it coming?

source: reddit (reddit:gamedev)published 2026-11-10 22:58ingested 2026-11-11 02:38

retained text

Not mentioning my game because this is not a promotion topic in disguise, but I've been really anxious the past a day.

I built a game with all my heart (not vibecoded) and even though I'm tired of playing it and can't feel fun anymore after 2k+ commits, I think I got a good product at the end. The reason why I made this topic is because of these things:

\- One reddit post and one tiktok video sum about 1Mi views, however my game only got 600 wishlists.

\- In the day of release, my game had about 30% of refund rate (almost had a heart attack), but now it "normalized" to about 14%, with a 15% wishlist conversion rate

\- My game seems to be keeping a trend, around \~25 wishlists and 15 copies sold a day post release for about 3 days now. It does not go up, but it also doesnt go down.

\- Impressively enough my impressions dropped a lot, but the interaction rate and sales stayed the same post release.

I'm not talking about being rich, from the bottom of my heart this is not my goal. But a lot of features that I built into my game needs a community (player has a unique collection, photo mode, etc) so I'm worried that it will fail to gather eyes before the community itself becomes active.

**TLDR/End of the post:** How often do a game trends after being stale for days post release? Anybody got through the same thing?

EDIT: Forgot to say something that may be very important: My game is on early acess and the multiplayer is on the works, which being honest fits my game really well, but hard to say how good of a spark it will be.

document fetched 2026-11-11 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xt1ezd/people_who_had_hits_are_they_mostly_unexpected_or