← sources

The anti-AI people

source: reddit (reddit:ClaudeAI)published 2026-09-28 15:52ingested 2026-09-29 02:37

retained text

… Remind me of the Victorian’s reaction to cars, the Bob Dylan crowd’s reaction to an electric guitar, the 1960s classical music connoisseur first hearing The Beatles. When will these people get a grip. The uncreative use of it is 100% on the human being.

If you are a slop machine with no taste, making low effort stuff by one shot, short one line prompts with no original idea behind them, making worse copies of what already exists and flooding the market with trash, this is 100% on you. The general public is forming their opinion based on this because this is how most of them choose to use it themselves. Press button, done.

Another thing they don’t get - If you write some incredible lyrics, but use an AI song generator to do the music and instrumentation, it’s still your lyrics and probably an incredible, moving and poetic end result that is worthy of attention and enjoyment by others. It’s not an “AI song”, it’s a hybrid. Man and machine.

Same with Claude Code. There is a big difference between working on an ambitious project for 6 months and thousands of human made decisions, vs one shot. The more of yourself that goes into it the more it is yours. In filmmaking, a director directs. Sometimes yes, they’ll do a lot else themselves as well, but when Spielberg directs a movie or Kubrick crafts a masterpiece he is not a polymath doing every single job on the set. He is prompting. He is the overall decision maker. Same with ambitious AI work. You don’t need to be an actor, writer, set designer, director and cinematographer all in one job.

He prompts maybe a 100 takes, sometimes just 2 or 3 and chooses the best. It’s that choice - the judgement to choose the best direction - that separates a masterpiece from the slop.

document fetched 2026-09-29 00:22 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ClaudeAI/comments/1wsibnm/the_antiai_people