← sources

Tested 'give me 3 options' vs 'give me your one best answer' on 40 real work emails. The single answer won 31 times

source: reddit (reddit:PromptEngineering)published 2026-11-17 14:09ingested 2026-11-18 02:41

retained text

Method (small, not scientific): 40 real emails I needed to reply to. Same model, same context. 

Version A: 'give me 3 reply options'. 

Version B: 'give me the one reply you'd send'. A colleague picked the better reply blind.  
  
Results:  
\- Single best answer preferred: 31/40  
\- One of the 3 options preferred: 7/40  
\- Tie: 2/40  
  
Why I think it happens: with 3 options the model splits effort and makes them deliberately different, so two are usually worse. With one, it commits.  
  
Where options DID win: subject lines and first lines of cold outreach, where variety matters.  
  
Anyone seen the same or the opposite?

document fetched 2026-11-18 00:43 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/PromptEngineering/comments/1xyldo1/tested_give_me_3_options_vs_give_me_your_one_best