← sources

1 star review with AI manipulated photo

source: reddit (reddit:EtsySellers)published 2026-10-23 17:28ingested 2026-10-24 02:36

retained text

I make custom printed products. Each customer needs to approve a proof before printing which this customer did. After she received her product, she messages me with a photo complaining about something very silly. I still offered to remake them for her or offer a partial refund. She denies both and says she wants a full refund. So I tell her that she can send the product back for a full refund but denies that as well.

She then files a case with the same photo, I send screenshots of the whole situation and etsy denies her refund.

I fully expected a bad review and was prepared to deal with it. What I did not expect was for the customer to manipulate the photo (probably with AI) to make the product look horrible! I report the review but it gets denied. I then contact customer service and file a help request, citing the following in Etsy's own handbook:

*#4 on the review removal page - “Undermine the integrity of the reviews system” because the customer digitally altered the photo after receiving the product and posted the manipulated image in their review, making the product appear defective when the original photo shows it was printed correctly."*

*Etsy’s Buyer Policy, Section 5.4, which states that members may not upload content that is “false, deceptive, or misleading.”*

I don't care if they don't remove the actual review but I care about the manipulated photo. I have responded to the review citing that the photo is manipulated and that is not what the customer received. However, on the etsy if someone only clicks on the review photo, they do not see the reply from the seller. They only see the photo and the review.

A once thriving listing is now dead.  
It's been a month now and Etsy's chat keeps saying they will forward this to the right team. My help request has gone completely ignored.

Is there anything else I can do? Do you think Etsy should remove the photo or do you think they are in the right for not doing so?

document fetched 2026-10-24 10:28 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/EtsySellers/comments/1xdket3/1_star_review_with_ai_manipulated_photo