← sources

I’ve made $523K from AI agents… most of you have it doing the human’s job

source: reddit (reddit:AI_Agents)published 2026-10-03 18:24ingested 2026-10-04 02:35

retained text

Probably an unpopular take, oh well.

I run a B2B cold outreach agency, mostly texting business owners on the public numbers they list on Google. 58.5K MRR as of today, and some agent stuff in here is kinda crazy. Not the good crazy.

Everybody's building the "autonomous" AI appointment setter so no human ever touches the lead. Meanwhile the AI we actually use is super boring:

1. One reads each prospect's website and writes an opener about their business    
2. One reads every reply and tells "yes I'm interested" from "what would make you think I'm interested" (both literally say interested)    
3. One is solely focused on using the data from first agent to send personalized responses, BUT only if human can’t get to it first (with a call).

The "secret"? Half of cold outreach is finding the RIGHT person, and AI is insanely good at that half.

But nobody here wants to hear it… I'm a huge fan of AI, but setting appointments on the phone is the best way to convert leads, and humans CRUSH AI on conversion rate. AI setters flush leads down the toilet and are not cost effective, relative to a human setter even when factoring in the additional costs.

You’re paying for leads, then an AI setter comes in to just fuck it all up. If it was truly better, setters would be out a job, they exist and will continue to exist in at least the near to mid term future, because humans convert better. Period.

Ask me anything.

document fetched 2026-10-04 00:18 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/AI_Agents/comments/1wwu70a/ive_made_523k_from_ai_agents_most_of_you_have_it