← sources

Hartford says it booked a $497M gain from settling with Berkshire. Its own books say it took about $316M less than it was owed.

source: reddit (reddit:SecurityAnalysis)published 2026-09-26 15:51ingested 2026-09-27 02:40

retained text

On Thursday, Hartford said Berkshire's insurer paid it $1.12 billion in cash. That ends an old deal on its asbestos claims. It also ends a fight between them. Hartford will book a $497 million gain before tax.

Most stories stopped there. The older filings tell you what the gain hides.

In 2016 Hartford paid $650 million for this cover. The cover was worth up to $1.5 billion. By the end of 2025 the claims had used all of it. The 10-K says $1,436 million was still owed on claims not yet paid.

Early in 2026 Berkshire's side paid a bit. Then it stopped over a dispute. That is in the June 10-Q.

Those first payments look small. Hartford counts a stored gain as cash comes in. Only $36 million of $850 million was counted. That fits about $64 million paid. So about $1,436 million was still owed.

So Hartford took $1.12 billion for about $1.44 billion. That is about $316 million less. It is 78 cents on the dollar.

The gain lines up too. In June Hartford held a stored gain of $814 million. The new gain is $497 million. The gap is $317 million.

The fair pushback: that money would have come in over many years, claim by claim. Cash today is worth more, so some cut is normal. And the cover was used up. So any new growth in these claims was Hartford's risk anyway.

What we don't know: what the fight was about. The filings call it private.

My view: Hartford still earns more than $1.3 billion this quarter. The deal adds $393 million after tax. The June quarter made $1,298 million. Storms are the risk.

Is 78 cents fair for claims that pay out over decades? Or did Hartford give up too much to end the fight?

Sources:  
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/874766/000087476626000064/hig-20260923.htm  
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/874766/000087476626000060/hig-20260630.htm  
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/874766/000087476626000012/hig-20251231.htm

document fetched 2026-09-27 00:40 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/SecurityAnalysis/comments/1wqtws2/hartford_says_it_booked_a_497m_gain_from_settling