← sources

I tested a “65% win-rate” Nasdaq 20/80 strategy — then compared it with 44 placebo versions

source: reddit (reddit:algotrading)published 2026-10-04 15:45ingested 2026-10-05 02:41

retained text

I tested the claim that NQ prices ending in **20 and 80** are unusually strong reaction levels.  
Rules:  
NQ futures  
NY morning  
10-point stop  
15-point target  
fade the 20/80 level  
Initial 5-minute test:  
247 signals  
Resolved win rate: **46.4%**  
Claimed benchmark: **65%**  
20/80 rank vs all 45 decimal-ending pairs: **23rd**  
Because many 5-minute trades were ambiguous, I reran it at 2-minute resolution:  
119 signals  
Win rate: **41.0%**  
Even if EVERY ambiguous trade were counted as a winner: **50.4%**  
20/80 placebo rank: **30th of 45**  
**29 arbitrary ending-pairs did better**  
A recent 1-minute spot check also produced **42.9%** and again ranked 20/80 **30th of 45**.  
So far I can’t find evidence that 20 and 80 themselves are special.  
This does **not** prove the trader’s full discretionary strategy doesn’t work — only that the measurable 20/80 level claim hasn’t survived these tests.  
I’d genuinely like people here to critique the methodology. If you spot a legitimate flaw, I’ll rerun it.  
What would you change?

document fetched 2026-10-05 00:38 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/algotrading/comments/1wxitxw/i_tested_a_65_winrate_nasdaq_2080_strategy_then